India Forum's Music Ka Maha Muqqabla (Male) - Page 7

yaar i will simply say that to avoid problems dont include these absurdly low scores without justification(its obvious those r from fans of other singers) u say that fans give their favourites 10 without justification. I would say that in this level of competition 10 is not absurd because the performances are anyways great and only knowledgeable people are able to make out small mistakes. if a fan wants to promote his favourite, he can give him 10, but it is unfair to pull others down by giving them below average marks(4 in this case). If the voting is fair then the person should point out the deficiencies in the performance and educate us all. otherwise any absurd score (below average) should just not be counted. Giving extra weightage to posts etc. i think will be cumbersome and not the solution.

Originally posted by: saq123

yaar i will simply say that to avoid problems dont include these absurdly low scores without justification(its obvious those r from fans of other singers) u say that fans give their favourites 10 without justification. I would say that in this level of competition 10 is not absurd because the performances are anyways great and only knowledgeable people are able to make out small mistakes. if a fan wants to promote his favourite, he can give him 10, but it is unfair to pull others down by giving them below average marks(4 in this case). If the voting is fair then the person should point out the deficiencies in the performance and educate us all. otherwise any absurd score (below average) should just not be counted. Giving extra weightage to posts etc. i think will be cumbersome and not the solution.

If the current system continues, then even i will have to start thinking about my favourites and pulling other people down which is not fair. We dont want gaj ji's REALITY here. Please address this issue. I dont know why others see nothing wrong here and want to continue as it is. Its not hard to eradicate this malice and it will only help the competition.

You're right a 10 usually doesn't require justification. Nonetheless, there are still are some 10s that are given regardless of how the singer sang. Thats why there are many more 10s than 4s. Some of those 10s are deserved and rational, others are just favoritism. I think there are about as many favoritism 10s as hating 4s. That's why, since the favoritism 10s don't require justificiation, neither should the 4s.

as i keep saying again. even in real life stuff like this happens. and we have to reflect real life.

Also, Starting Next Round


You can give 1-10


This will make things more realistic. I still suggest audience to be fair!


So system will stay like it was last time!

Looks like things are tough already in Round 1...I must say, this competition is so tough, that the 1st eliminated contestant, or the winner of this competition, may very well be the 1st one out if it was run again. I mean, I bet if you ran this 2-3 times, there would be a different winner everytime. That goes on to speak how good each singer is .

Originally posted by: ssk13809

risingabove I think you did a good job selecting someone999 as a judge. He/she is fair.

thank you for the appreciation, its an honour 😊

^^^

You have done a good job for the first round.

Originally posted by: brahmabul

^^^

You have done a good job for the first round.

that's too kind of you to say that 😊

thank you. appreciate that a lot

Originally posted by: somone999

niccceee.. @ Summer3

have sent my recommendations. @ risingabove

Originally posted by: Summer3

Oh someone9999 there are so many lovely songs to choose.

It is a tough job too.

These days some of the modern songs do not need much of a voice to sing as it requires more shouting.😆

yup i know, it took me about half an hour to gather the songs from my mind for the recommendations 😆