Accountability for 3 Years ....

-Preeti- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Ohkay I've come up with this Topic with respect to y'day's Episode and Up Coming Tracks

I believe Mayank tells Gunjan about Nupur being Alive and Dia tells Samrat. But Mayank tells Gunjan with a belief that she's alive whereas Dia expects Samrat to help Mayank as she believes he's running behind an illusion.
So may be then we have Samrat talk to Gunjan about it that inbetween thier problems its Mayank who had to face the biggest Loss of his life and they being his have to support him in this. So in all i assume Samrat and Gunjan Still are not aware of Nupur actually being Alive.

So my Question is about the Future when all 4 of them come face to face. What Next?
Would life be the same for them then? Who's gonne be accountable for those 3 years which they spent Alone, which they spent with the Gulit, With the Misunderstanding, Which they spent blaming one another......

Mayank
Mayank lived with this fact that Nupur is no More and so did he punish himself and Samrat for her not being there. He blamed Samrat for 3 long years. He lived with the guilt that everything that happened was b'coz of his mistake, Samrat's mistake ....So after Nupur comes ...would it be easy for him to get back to a Normal Life?

Samrat
Samrat has been living with the guilt that its he who's responsible for Nupur's death. Not just that he made sure that he punishes himself in everyway possible and he did that. He had to loose his love and his chasmish .... he isolated himself from his best friends for 3 years ..... Would it be easy for him to forgive Mayank and Gunjan? Would it be easy for him to forgive himself?

Gunjan
She lost her sister and she held Samrat responsible for that. And to punish him for the same she decided to part ways from him. She thought thats the best way to punish Samrat as well as herself as she too believed even she was responsible for that accident. So now would it be easy for her to move ahead in Life? Would it be easy for her to face Samrat, whom she blamed for the accident.


Nupur > We dont know if She would return as Nupur with her Memory stable or Would she be facing Amnesia.
But would it be easy for her to accept Samrat, Gunjan and Mayank. As somewhere deep down she would have a thought that her Best friend, her sister and The Man she loved the Most her husband did'nt try to find her and left her alone for 3 Long Years.


Whose gonna be accountable for these 3 Long Years of thier Lives. If we see None are responsible for all that happened but then they are at fault too. Its the Situations/Circumstances that took a toll on thier lives and Now they are in a Situation where even if they wish to, they cannot get the Life, the Bond that they had created 3 yrs ago cannot be got back.

Atleast Not So Soon ......


Would Love to know Others View on the Same....... And hoping to have a Healthy Discussion without any kind of Sarcasm.

Thanks

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

3k

Users

22

Likes

220

Frequent Posters

Gagan-06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
All I can say its called circumstances. No one is at fault, but one accident changed everyone's life.
Till now we saw Mayank, Samrat, and Gunjan suffering.
I think its time we see Nupur's miseries. She was in trauma for three freakin years. She felt abandoned.
The track is soo unpredictable then the cliched track we were assuming. I do feel the memory loss could be extended more than this track so i might have gone for that..
however this is something new*
I dont mind any route they take as long as they can support it back with facts.

I think it would be amazing to see Nupur start her life over again.
I want to know what work would she find for herself... what would she do?



Edited by Gaganjot.S - 15 years ago
Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
preethi....i cant n i wnt blame ny of d four.....coz sab apne apna jagah sahi bhi the...aur galat bhi the...so storywise i wil blame situations for makin d lifes of four lik this..

bt if i think beyond story...i will blame CVs for creatin this track at the end of season 1 vich resultd in all worst things in show as well as in forum
cutemug thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

Well, they say "Time heals all wounds"

The same can be said in this case:

It's been 3 years'

A long period of time,

A time where in new impressions are formed, memories are cherished/tarnished/re-lived, grudges strengthened and also mistakes regretted upon.

Mayank could have never once even thought that he could reignite the hope of seeing Nupur alive again; I guess the joy of finding her would dilute all other accusations/anger about the people around him,

Samrat aside from the fact that, he would be relieved hearing that Nupur could be alive, would also have almost lost the love of his life, would be careful to step in a relationship again'

Gunjan, destroyed by the reality three years ago, coping with life gradually, and learning to live again, would feel that she'd definitely gained something but by losing something far more important, her soul to Samrat.

Nupur'Now, m skeptical to how they would portray her character'but again she would have lived those 3yrs,being too far away from the people she loved and believed in, would've formed new impressions in her mind about life, but destiny reveals something different to her now'

As you all know, People behave the way they behave because they find themselves in a certain set of circumstances which they don't have a say/control upon.

But It's entirely up to them to unveil the plan of destiny, to understand how it works,

And most importantly, to live and love again'😊

Mugdha


P.S - Also I wanna quote the line in my profile pic,which aptly fits in the situation...

"Everybody wants Happiness,

Nobody wants Pain...

You can't have a Rainbow,

Without a little rain"


Edited by cutemug - 15 years ago
430105 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
You know, there's this axiom I always believed to be true. "Injuries are healed but the scars remain."

And in this case, it fits perfectly. I'll go character wise (Including SG, but I do not want anyone bashing me for the same.)

Mayank- He lost the love of his life. The ONLY girl he ever loved. The same girl who turned is black and white life into a colorful, cheerful life. He owed his life to Nupur. He owed her all the happiness in the world, in return to the happiness she gave him. And at such a time, when life snatched her away from him, he began blaming life. He blamed himself, that he couldn't reward her with the same happiness she'd given him. At times like this, the person who's going through such a loss, needs someone to throw all his burden upon. And that's what Mayank did. He threw that burden on Samrat's shoulders. He took his friend for granted, put the blame on him, so he could mourn on his wife's death, because somewhere he held himself responsible for Nupur's death, and he himself knew it that Samrat wasn't at fault. So when he comes face to face with Nupur, that guilt will resurface, this time, double the guilt. So it'll be a turning point in his life as well. That's what I feel it will be.

Gunjan- Like Mayank, she lost the most important part of her life. For her, Nupur's loss was like the loss of her mother. She couldn't bare the loss of her mother all over again. But yet, like Mayank, even Gunjan ended up taking Samrat for granted. She felt, if this could reduce her pain, she'd do it. She stayed away from Samrat, only because she didn't want to come to terms with reality, and in the process, trying to move on. Yet, when Nupur will return, that guilt will resurface. And her real challenge would be to deal with the fact that she's actually guilty of nearly destroying a life, for no fault of his. And I think Gunjan does deserve to go through this guilt.

Samrat- He has suffered the most. He was carrying Mayank's as well as Gunjan's burden on his shoulders, combined with his own feelings of guilt. He felt he deserved this, and he was so burdened with guilt, that he did not once bother to contemplate that it wasn't really his fault. He tried to punish himself, yet his punishment was to live alone the rest of his life. But with Nupur's return, unlike the other two, Samrat will be relieved of the guilt he'd been carrying since the beginning. But ofcourse, he'll be facing the guilt of not trying to inquire about Nupur. But how could he, when he couldn't even think for once that he wasn't guilty of her death? And for once, I feel Samrat needs to be selfish, and throw all his burden on Gunjan and Mayank. They do deserve it to an extent.

Nupur- The most suffered one. She was in trauma centre for 3 whole years, she'd suffered a lot. All she expected was to meet her loved ones once she came out of that place. But she was hurt beyond words when no one came to look for her. There was no one to hug her and free her from her sufferings, the mental trauma she'd gone through. And in such a situation, she blamed them, and decided to live life all on her own. But ofcourse, when she meets them, that hurt and pain and that trauma of 3 years will haunt her. So it'll be a real challenge for the other three to actually relieve her of her pain.

As for the relationship between the four, maybe it'll be back to normal later, but it won't be the same. Cause like I said, there may be instances when this could resurface again.
Edited by utfracks - 15 years ago
MrsJaimeFraser thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
res...need 2 think n then...
style14 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
Lovely post Preeti..
No one is to be blammed actually. Everyone is correct in their own way although I think Samrat had to face to much of wrath from Mayank and Gunjan for no fault, I really wanna see how the CV's will handle this situation. Hopefully without their "LOGIC". Now the story line should be strong otherwise viewers will loose interest.
3 yrs all four lived separate lives in sadness. We want them to now forget what happened and to move on. But the confrontation between the four will be worth the wait, I hope. Lets see what the CV's have planned. Hopefully they wont ruin the characters.
Faria. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#8

******* EDIT********************



Nice post Preeti Di.
i dont want to blame anyone here.
No one is at fault- it was an accident .
mayank and Gunjan were blame samrat which was not logical at all
but in such situation logic doesn't work
mayank lost his wife and gunji lost her mother like sis(now we nups is alive) and this pain mafde them to blame sammy.
Till now this trio are suffering.
and now we got the news that nups is not suffering from amnesia- she was in trauma center for last 3 years and had leads a
miserable life(i think so)

Now its really very interesting to c how the get back to a normal life
i know its not easy for them- becoz life is so complicated
but i m strongly believe that they will get rid from this situation.

Edited by fariaa70 - 15 years ago
430105 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
Edited page 1. I've written a long speech I feel, but I didn't realize it's this long while I was writing🤣
-Preeti- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: nikki028

preethi....i cant n i wnt blame ny of d four.....coz sab apne apna jagah sahi bhi the...aur galat bhi the...so storywise i wil blame situations for makin d lifes of four lik this..

bt if i think beyond story...i will blame CVs for creatin this track at the end of season 1 vich resultd in all worst things in show as well as in forum



Nikki
CV's are the 1st person i would blame be it good or Bad as they are the master Mind behind it ..... But what do we see Story wise? Character wise

The 4some are in a path where they cannot moveahed without correcting thier past and to rectify the past is not possible


Originally posted by: style14

Lovely post Preeti..
No one is to be blammed actually. Everyone is correct in their own way although I think Samrat had to face to much of wrath from Mayank and Gunjan for no fault, I really wanna see how the CV's will handle this situation. Hopefully without their "LOGIC". Now the story line should be strong otherwise viewers will loose interest.
3 yrs all four lived separate lives in sadness. We want them to now forget what happened and to move on. But the confrontation between the four will be worth the wait, I hope. Lets see what the CV's have planned. Hopefully they wont ruin the characters.



Right .... For the first time we have a Track in MJHT that would basically move just around the Central characters without getting any 5th person involved. So I am surely excited about this Track and am also hoping that the CV's give proper justice to this
I wont say Samrat had to face the maximum as I believe all had to go through a lot of Pain in the last 3 yrs of thier lives. They knew none was to be blamed for all that happened but still ended up in the blame game as they felt by doing this would not find themselves guilty of all that happened.

About Ruining the characters i cannot predict on that *fingers crossed*

And about all those reserved posts .... i hope it gets unreserved soon😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".