Accountability for 3 Years .... - Page 3

lovley post Preethi di 😊

I dont think some is responsible or needs to be blamed.Its just the circumstances in life.
Now no one can be normal with each other atleast for a while n as Gagan di said may be now its Nupurs turn to feel the pain.One incident changed thier lives to such extent that now they cant face each other n in all this I feel most bad for Sam because without any mistake he had to bear the guilt of his best friends death n also the pain being away from his GF.
I really wish that Cvz handle this situation in a proper way.Hope they convince us

Originally posted by: sumonetolub

i actually think this could be a really good track cuz they can show the emotional turmoil each character goes through when they find out why nupur stayed away for so long.....nupur will still believe the 3 of them left her alone......and gunjan, mayank, and samrat will be upset at her maybe for taking away 3 years.....for making them hate samrat......and for feeling guilty for "killing" her.........i just wanna see nupurs side of the story now!......naina

Originally posted by: Shilpa.Agarwal

greatt post.....all of dis so unfortunate.......n d reason i guess is COMMUNICATION GAP.....all 4 were physically away frm each other n there was no way to contact......funny situation but very unfortunate

for gunjan......i would like to add she even lost herself.......nups was a shield b/w her n d wrld, after dat got removed she was for d first time exposed to d harsh realities of d wrld n dis tym even sammy wasn't there so she lost her own identity n tried to behave like nupur as she once said lukin at her photo...sooooo sad

its a rely complicated n intense situation n its difficult to say whether these were reversible changes or not......can things ever be back to normal??? it is a test of our 4some n their relationships.......but one thing sure is things r getting rely interestin lol.......cant wait 2 see how d story unfolds.....i wanted amnesia real bad but now i guess its not happening.......wtvr happens cant wait

Originally posted by: Mysterygirl_me

Wonderful topic preeti di, i think each one of them is right in their own way and did what they could in accordance with the circumstances. Mayank blamed himself and samrat for the accident he lost the soul reason of his existence and lived with this guilt for 3 long years but than he became friends with samrat once again and is now ecstatic with just the news of nupur being alive. Samrat on the other hand tried to destroy himself and torture himself for all what happened which was partly due to him and couldn't forgive himself and this is how he spent these 3 years i don't think he can reunite with gunjan now only because nupur is alive. Gunjan lost her sister and blames herself and samrat for the same and that's why she wants to hurt herself and samrat by not reuniting and repenting on whatever happened. If this isn't a case of amnesia for nupur, i think she's right to think that they abandoned her because he doesn't know the whole story about the other nupur chaudhry. She must have been shattered to be left alone there and deal with trauma centre and everything all by her own. So she decided to start life a fresh forgetting the past. Now as she'll come face to face with mayank and SG I am sure she'll not want to be back but they'll all reunite and manaofy her. So one one is at fault they did what they had to cuz it was the circumstances which paved way to feeling this way. They cannot act like these 3 years meant nothing and it would surely take time for all four to recover once again but they will for sure.

Originally posted by: shruti.nil

@preeti youre post is lovely...something we didnt quite think about amongst the happiness of having Nupur back......this will be an intresting track...PROVIDED the Cvs handel it well....and thier reputation well you know...they may just show Nupurs return and show everything hunky dorky after that...
i DONT want that to happen....
as for who is accountable to what happened well none of them are...it was just a cruel game of destiny.....
Mayank moved on with line and even forgave Samrat realiseing that its wasnt really his fault
Samrat undoubtedly suffered the most-not only he lost his good friends but also lived under the gulit of being responsible for Nupur's death..not to forget the seething words that Gunjan had for him...
Gunjan,i think the accountablity factor surprisingly fits her....she became bitter to such an extent that her each word crushed Samrat inside out,id love to see how they handel her track after she comes to know Nupur is alive and realises all the hurt she has caused Samrat...
i really hope the Cvs do touch upon this part of Nupurs comeback...cos i think this track has all the potential for not only development of the show but also the development of the charecters!!

Originally posted by: yash.dilse

lovley post Preethi di 😊

I dont think some is responsible or needs to be blamed.Its just the circumstances in life.
Now no one can be normal with each other atleast for a while n as Gagan di said may be now its Nupurs turn to feel the pain.One incident changed thier lives to such extent that now they cant face each other n in all this I feel most bad for Sam because without any mistake he had to bear the guilt of his best friends death n also the pain being away from his GF.
I really wish that Cvz handle this situation in a proper way.Hope they convince us

Thanks guys for the respone
and yes .... it would be the Testing point for all and not just one ....All have lost something and gone through the same pain. And now after the confrontation there definately wont just be Happy Moments fr them but this would give rise to New Questions ....Kuch Kahe Ankahein Sawaal .... which would have no answers ....
Even if they try to explain the 3 yrs or try to live a normal life ... it would take time for each one of them to get adjust to this new path of thier life.

Mayank has to face Nupur and Samrat. Gunjan has to get her relationship right with Nupur as well as Samrat whom she has hurt the most. Samrat would come out from his inner guilt but would still be left with Questions as to Why Him?
And Nupur ..... she would be not just questioning the 3 Important people of her life but herself too? 3yrs in that Trauma Centre alone might not have been a good life for her. And When she comes out she does'nt find THE People expected there to be. In a way life would be different and Tough for her too.

I really dont find there is any one responsible for it.Gunjan and Mayank was in a situation where mind stops working..and bcoz of tht thy all blamed poor sammy for this......even sammy blammed himslef for all this....And the main thing which make him to think like tht is mayank and gunjan.......thy all have sohwn so much hate towards him tht he find himslef guitly abt the incident....
But the one who suffered most is Nupur........Its totally sensible whn a person is in pain at tht time the person only need the love ones to share the pain.........but whn nupur was going through this she wasn't lucky to get that.....And deep down in her heart its only pain left....she is angry but afraid also....She feels that wht if the same happens again to her??she is now no more capable to go through the pains again........
Its only my POV........btw preeti dee fantastic topic...... 👍🏼

Hey thats a very interesting post, Preeti and one of the most sensible around on the forum after agessssssss! I am really tired of drooling posts hehe! Okay not so tired.

Gagan, Rach very well said, I didn't get a chance to read everyone's response in here. I would go bit by bit.

Coming to the target point, who is to be accountable for what happened. My answer is kind of ironical, each of them at one point and at another none, just the circumstances.

Mayank: Well he has lost the love of his life and deep down always blames himself for not being able to save Nupur considering that she is no more. He only superficially blamed Samrat but deep down he knew that it wasn't Samrat's fault but circumstances. But he promised Nupur to always take care of her and be there for her but he couldn't. He let himself down and her down, ultimately causing to have lost her.

The tiny fault of his was to not go in the depth of the matter and inquire more about the deathl body and causes. He just accepted the report, not bothering to look at it as well. Then again he was so upset at that time but what about later he could have and now at last he did. Things are not so clear here and neither do i think that they would be really made clear. He thought she is dead and decided to go along with that.

Gunjan: Well the same goes for her as Mayank that she went ahead with what the doctors said and he didn't bother to think that there could be some mistake as the reports clearly was faulty. So she didn't read the report as well. About her loss, ofcourse she has suffered alot and loss not just Nupur but Samrat and a part of herself.

Samrat: Here he seems to be a chap who has been gone through hell, as he not only was blamed by Mayank and Gunjan but he blamed himself the most and tried to kill himself early on as well.

I don't know how to take it ahead, i have just dwelled into the present situation, future would be much more interesting and dynamic to watch than this hopefully if the writers put forward a sensible script.

Nupur: The one suffering the most out of the three is her. Imagine in a place like a trauma center and waiting, waiting waiting that someone would come to take me, ask for me, inquire about me. But no one came and no one bothered, thinking she is dead, in her opinion they have moved on and so has she decided to do so. She i agree didn't have to live with the guilt that someone died because of her but neither did she have anyone to blame, get mad at besides her isolation and emptiness to fall back on.

very nice and interesting post preeti.. i feel that it would be different yet nice to see a track where as how nupur has developed over these 3 yrs . we have seen mayank and gunjun and samrat problems related to the sudden death of nupur so all these questions do arise how all these 4 will be able to deal with situtions and the questions arise when they find nupur and how will nupur confront all 3 of them and what sort of questions will she have for them .. interesting track however like gagan di said the memory loss track could have been extended more so lets just wait and watch !

Originally posted by: utfracks

You know, there's this axiom I always believed to be true. "Injuries are healed but the scars remain."

And in this case, it fits perfectly. I'll go character wise (Including SG, but I do not want anyone bashing me for the same.)

Mayank- He lost the love of his life. The ONLY girl he ever loved. The same girl who turned is black and white life into a colorful, cheerful life. He owed his life to Nupur. He owed her all the happiness in the world, in return to the happiness she gave him. And at such a time, when life snatched her away from him, he began blaming life. He blamed himself, that he couldn't reward her with the same happiness she'd given him. At times like this, the person who's going through such a loss, needs someone to throw all his burden upon. And that's what Mayank did. He threw that burden on Samrat's shoulders. He took his friend for granted, put the blame on him, so he could mourn on his wife's death, because somewhere he held himself responsible for Nupur's death, and he himself knew it that Samrat wasn't at fault. So when he comes face to face with Nupur, that guilt will resurface, this time, double the guilt. So it'll be a turning point in his life as well. That's what I feel it will be.

Gunjan- Like Mayank, she lost the most important part of her life. For her, Nupur's loss was like the loss of her mother. She couldn't bare the loss of her mother all over again. But yet, like Mayank, even Gunjan ended up taking Samrat for granted. She felt, if this could reduce her pain, she'd do it. She stayed away from Samrat, only because she didn't want to come to terms with reality, and in the process, trying to move on. Yet, when Nupur will return, that guilt will resurface. And her real challenge would be to deal with the fact that she's actually guilty of nearly destroying a life, for no fault of his. And I think Gunjan does deserve to go through this guilt.

Samrat- He has suffered the most. He was carrying Mayank's as well as Gunjan's burden on his shoulders, combined with his own feelings of guilt. He felt he deserved this, and he was so burdened with guilt, that he did not once bother to contemplate that it wasn't really his fault. He tried to punish himself, yet his punishment was to live alone the rest of his life. But with Nupur's return, unlike the other two, Samrat will be relieved of the guilt he'd been carrying since the beginning. But ofcourse, he'll be facing the guilt of not trying to inquire about Nupur. But how could he, when he couldn't even think for once that he wasn't guilty of her death? And for once, I feel Samrat needs to be selfish, and throw all his burden on Gunjan and Mayank. They do deserve it to an extent.

Nupur- The most suffered one. She was in trauma centre for 3 whole years, she'd suffered a lot. All she expected was to meet her loved ones once she came out of that place. But she was hurt beyond words when no one came to look for her. There was no one to hug her and free her from her sufferings, the mental trauma she'd gone through. And in such a situation, she blamed them, and decided to live life all on her own. But ofcourse, when she meets them, that hurt and pain and that trauma of 3 years will haunt her. So it'll be a real challenge for the other three to actually relieve her of her pain.

As for the relationship between the four, maybe it'll be back to normal later, but it won't be the same. Cause like I said, there may be instances when this could resurface again.

very well said n reminds me of dis doha(couplet) by hindi poet rahim "rahiman dhaga prem ka mat todo chatkay, toote se phir na jure jure gaanth par jaye" meaning that if d thread of love breaks it maybe tied again but the knot remains

I think u r right..
Nice post preeti...
Hope everything should be as good as before....

This was one of the best topic i have ever read on this session 2 .beautifully described main charactrs current situation.I am eagerly waiting what will be the reaction of Majan of after find out about Nupur.I hope Samrat should not forgive soo easly Majan for blaming him with out knowing The truth properly.I am eagerly waiting to see Nupur s intensions also.It seems to beintresting very intresting track.

in my opine mayu n sg can still move on 1ce nupur 4gves dm. Bt the big qs is will nupur ever move on in life??? True, she may cme bk 2 mayu n sg will always b dre 4 her bt will she ever 4gt those yrs spent in trauma center? Nupur's pain cnt be cmprd 2 d rest. Yes, dy cried alot but dy had smebdy 2 fall bk. Though sam dsnt share gud rshp with his mom bt atlest she was dre. Dse ppl were just emotionally disturbed. Nupur was nt only emotionally bt mentally disturbed. Mb nupur will never bcum bubbly n carefree agn. Mayur rshp will change drastically. Smtng will b missing in dr rshp. Nup may nt let mayu gt close 2 her often. She may nt be dependent on him. Basically, she will nw try 2 figure out what she wnts in life. Dy may decide 2 part ways on gud note. Bt 1 thing is 4 sure v shld nt expect cochi cooing mayur love anymore. Dis is an intrstng trk. V cn expect mayu's frustration, nup insecurity. I wnt a scene where nup gt a nitemare of her in trauma center n starts crying. Mayu shld jst pull her into his arms bt still she dsnt feel safe. And yeah, i want original mayur new song 2 b cmpsd agn. V cm c mayu taking nup 2 beach, jungle trip 2 relive the moments...to make his nupur once again normal n enjoy life! He will mk her say by, god! 1ce agn.