So....IF members don't matter.. eh??

-Rinky- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Hey guys and Gals,
Read this, its PD's farewell note-

guys this forum isnt for me...

i refuse to be subjected top rude talk and slandering from time to time...
to tell you the truth and sorry to have to put it this way most of your opinions technically dont matter... becasue you guys dont even feature in the metered zones from where trps come...
but ive enjoyed taking feedback and doing what ever is possible...
but, sorry, now my ego has come in the way...
bye- bye...
enjoy venting your frustrations... becasue rather than discussing the show that is what this forum has beocme today on every topic...
just a mode of venting out frustration...

@red- so our views really don't matter... what matters?? TRP.... i wonder how they calculate it....

I was just wondering if we really didn't matter why did PD come to this forum at all??

According to her we've hurt her and insulted her.....well as much as i know, we simply told her the truth....

@blue-yes we were venting our frustration because we loved this show... for what it was for what it could have been.. for actors like ArTi who are a gem........

So, a thread which was to be a creative thread made for honest feedback has to be turned into a "Pleaders Jannat"... only pleading fans are allowed to post there so that someone who really doesn't care about our posts can feel happy....

I simply don't get it..... If we really don't matter why come here and get so agitated...I smell a Rat my dears...

At the end of the day I also find this post pretty insulting and the CJ thread getting closed immediately..

Who are we protecting?? someone who has no headache no respect for our time and intelligent feedback?? do they even know how much effort it goes to suggest good things, search for images,songs on the internet..post them here.....

Why are we all getting treated like second grade citizens...If we criticise we get warnings if PD does that she gets protected by moderators..... wow.....

P.S- Moderators please don't close this topic.... i found the last post on CJ thread extremely insulting.....I assure you I will keep my tone controlled and polite....just give me a chance to put my POV forward.

Thanx
Rinky

Created

Last reply

Replies

147

Views

7.4k

Users

47

Likes

537

Frequent Posters

ImmaculateDream thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
TRPS TRPS TRPS!!
showing c***ches.. songs ...sets, situations inspired from Bollywood 70s... LIPS .. almost kisses ... keeping a situations away from real as much as possible ..
thats how trps form ...
if thats all we get to hear from the creative hearself .. n still i follow this show n DEMAND then i would be making a fool out of myself .
had enough ..
nimrah thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Dude, thats how it has been always! As long as we praise PD, everyone is happy. Once, we give her our opinions regarding what went wrong.. we're being rude!

I found the last post really insulting as well. We don't matter eh? Well, we'll see when this show just goes down and won't pick up because I surely am quitting on this buffoonery. Will only watch the show if I need to laugh or something. Lets see how long the others will last. Frankly I have only one suggestion for PD: Please get rid of MN somehow and if not MN then ArTi. Then tou pakka I won't give a damn as to what happens in this show.

I don't think I made sense in this post.. and I don't even care. Just wanted to vent out my frustration.
FreeBird03 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: nimrah

Dude, thats how it has been always! As long as we praise PD, everyone is happy. Once, we give her our opinions regarding what went wrong.. we're being rude!

I found the last post really insulting as well. We don't matter eh? Well, we'll see when this show just goes down and won't pick up because I surely am quitting on this buffoonery. Will only watch the show if I need to laugh or something. Lets see how long the others will last. Frankly I have only one suggestion for PD: Please get rid of MN somehow and if not MN then ArTi. Then tou pakka I won't give a damn as to what happens in this show.

I don't think I made sense in this post.. and I don't even care. Just wanted to vent out my frustration.



u said whatever i wanted to say! thanks! 👏

if PD gives a damn abt us....
so do we 😆

yeah get rid of ArTi then i will never bother with this show...



psycho_angel thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
^^rinky,dude,first of all edit the quote part of the post...just let the topic remain for a while on the forum....

i know neha had opened a similar topic which was closed and no action was taken whatsoever....so keeping fingers crossed for this to remain open


as for ur query,surely u have realized by now the amount of "freedom" we are allowed on this "free" forum?

i was rather shocked to see gagan resigning ...and she was one of the sensible people who took an unbiased approach to posts.i didnt know one post would evoke such strong reactions.i hereby refuse to comment on any creative jannat from now on.i dont know how someone draws a line between criticism and bashing,but i can assure you,no show can survive without accepting criticisms gracefully.

i never really cared about mjht,coz i treated it just like any other daily soap,so unlike any MN/SJ fan i have never posted my undying love for any couple.but that is a prerequisite of posting on the CJ.its not a suggestion thread at all,its a drool thread.simple suggestions and even mild spoofs are considered offensive there.some people have zero tolerance level.i refuse to communicate with such people in the future.

i dunno about quitting mjht,i guess i will eventually.at the moment its my timepass,and unlike some shows i feel really bad to quit halfway,ill wont be sorry to give this one a break.


430105 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
reserved. me have a LOT to say on this.

*Edited*
Rinky, i love you for opening this topic. I wanted to open one too, but didn't seem to have the guts to do so for fear that i may get warned for being "offensive."

Seriously, We don't matter AT ALL to them! That's how it is with them! Her post was really insulting. More than insulting, what exactly is she trying to get at? As far as i know, a show ain't anything without viewers, right?

Sure, MJHT has had good TRPs, but can it survive on TRPs alone? The answer is a plain no! What i don't understand is, why do these people fly so high that their show is doing so well on TRPs? Heck, we viewers decide the show's success, NOT TRP'S! Let's see them manage without viewers.

And our opinions never mattered to her? Sure it didn't. If she cannot accept criticism, she does not deserve to be working in this line! (no offence to her.) If she can't stand negative feedback, i'd rather she do her work! Why the hell did she have to come on this forum? She ain;'t doing us a big favour by giving us scoops on the show, since 99% of the times, that never happens!

Basically, if people are praising her, her ego doesn't come in the way, but the moment we criticise, her ego seems to be getting in the way? Yeah sure, sach hamesha kadwa hi hota hai! Maybe that's exactly why she decided to leave..she didn't have the guts to face the truth.

They'll soon realise our importance once the show loses out on viewers, and begins to fall. That's when they'll realise that if viewers can make a show, they can very well break it too! Then they'll realise that shows CANNOT STAND ON TRP'S ALONE!

And honestly, i want ArTi to quit, for all you know, she doesn't bother about them either. At least once they're gone, i can finally disconnect myself from the show!

P.S- i'm unhappy by the consequences PD's one post has led to. Gagan resigned, man, she shouldn't have! I really hope PD never returns in the near future! She's gone for the good. Now maybe this forum will be a happy place again, without her so called "scoops"
Edited by utfracks - 15 years ago
Bollywood_chic thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Your topic title says it all, we don't. Clearly.

I thought creatives come to these forums to meet with the fans, talk to them, see where they can improve the show, take it to a new level.
But, it just seems as if we're supossed to like everything that's placed before us. Is there not anything like CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM?
i think not, again keeping the creatives in mind they obviously don't want to know what we really think of the show, nor do they care. it's all about the publicity.
It's not fair to the actors, the characters, and the fans. We have to watch 3rd class shows which startd out with potentional and now has dropped.. then again nothing new there?
DMG, MJHT, just another list to the TV shows which were popular but then fell over the ledge..
sumonetolub thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
sorry i never knew this but who is PD?.....what does PD stand for?.....naina
430105 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sumonetolub

sorry i never knew this but who is PD?.....what does PD stand for?.....naina


PD is the creative member of MJHT. we don't know her name though. She used to provide us with scoops on the show.
saher_90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
Ahh i'll miss the scoops...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".