Negative message, maybe? - Page 15

Created

Last reply

Replies

163

Views

9.5k

Users

38

Likes

309

Frequent Posters

hey.bhaggu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
I know right!! Arre we are toh still teens...kids like 8 years old too watch these shows! Ask me...Remix's season 2 was very intimate btwn Tia-Ranveer (One of the reason y i started disliking them😛) and Starone was banned in mumbai coz of this for a month! I mean fine, we teens might understand few stuff but kids totally get influenced by this since its their age of learning...they grasp everything quickly! And by just show eye-locking stuff and useless stuff just makes love as an attraction...nothing else!! Not even infactuation!

You know what's the problem with indian creative minds...they can't put their original ideas...they have to copy and ruin some film's corny storyline...i ask why?? This just ruins the whole story!! And another problem is india's public...all they want in the shows is ROMANCE! That's all!! No wonder why most indian shows lose charm after 4-5 months after it started!! I mean, yes even we want love to happen btwn our favs. but not at the sake of butchering the story coz we started loving the couple because of the storyline...we started watching it because of the story! But public don't understand that yaar...all they want is romance, romance, romance! I say, GET A LIFE! Life is seriously much more than love and romance!!

And well its not that there were not any single youth show that didn't portray 'realistic' lifestyle! Two shows that come @ the top of my mind are definitely Hip Hip Hurray (old zee show...it was a youth show) and Remix's season 1!!! In fact both of these shows had love story but the shows were beyond just love stories! It depicted real life's problems and relationships w/ parents, teachers, friends!! I love MJHT! But then its going off track now and frankly speaking don't want that coz after remix...this is the only show that really got me hooked! SaJan's life and love story still shows real emotions and could be believable (w/ gunjan's heart-break and samrat infactuated by sheena) but MaYur's love is seriously looking lust and i don't want that coz they were the first ones i liked when i started watching MJHT!

Oh creatives...humpe yeh torture kyun?????? Seriously please start showing sensible stuff btwn MaYur too...and bringgggggggg all the characters bk...Ms.Tamanna aa gayi toh sab teachers ne college se resign kar diya hain kya? Dramatics ka class shuru ho gaya toh students don't have any other classes?😲
Edited by -YaRa-Forever- - 16 years ago
Dangelz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: roxthefox



@Danglez, my problem with the MN track is exactly what Ipshitaa so articulately stated in her post above. 👏 But nonetheless, it's great to see a sensible fanboy. You almost always seem to change my mind to the contrary. 😆

Yes I do agree that there are loopholes in the MN track ,especially the ones people have mentioned or stated.
Sensible fanboy? If you are referring this to me...I'm a fangirl 😆 not fanboy.
I almost always change your mind, good to know I tried! 😆
missing Vmars thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
18 pages of discussion 😲 whoa zainu not bad 😉
neways will drop in later ( try n read all da comments as well ) ... i dont think deres nething much left 2 add ..... most of it must have been covered already
incandescence thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
''shocked''.......WOWW.....this 'negitive' topic is still surviving in this 'positive' forum....i m disappointed with the 'positive' crowd.....

now first to all those who think that MJHT was never supposed to give any MESSAGE.....i AGREE.....its a pure fictional show....i surely do not watch it to get any kind of MESSAGE from it......but the problem here is that it IS giving out a MESSAGE.....a pathetic one....a show...a college based show......gives us PASSION filled scenes.....teenage kids with their over active harmones r gonna like it...proof: this forum....its actually facinating for them....they start equating these scenes as love....with the limited 'sex' education v get here teenage girls will not understand the concequences of being in a room alone with a half- naked guy......on the contrary they will actually fantasize about it.....i have a teenage sis who will b getting admission in a college soon....she sometimes watch MJHT with me....but trust me i will not let her watch MJHT anymore.....but oh well.....what can u expect from the creatives who use the term SEX GOD for a character in an open forum full of teenagers....joke or no joke.....

and plzzz if its a fictional show with nothing whatsoever to do with the reality....the only purpose is entertainment then atleast the creatives should give us some decent entertainment.....or does entertainment means PASSIONATE scenes with no story to speak of......or is the 'oh so hawt' skin show supposed to entertain us......or seeing our favourite characters getting twist up due to their LOVE keeps our entertianment alive.......y r v forced to accept a half-baked story....sorry a totally un-baked story.....just in the name of entertainment......

i have vent out enough about the mayur current track to write more on it......and u all have written everything that could b written about the current mayur track......do not want to repeat it all again......


KaSuAlways thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: mashaal

''shocked''.......WOWW.....this 'negitive' topic is still surviving in this 'positive' forum....i m disappointed with the 'positive' crowd.....

now first to all those who think that MJHT was never supposed to give any MESSAGE.....i AGREE.....its a pure fictional show....i surely do not watch it to get any kind of MESSAGE from it......but the problem here is that it IS giving out a MESSAGE.....a pathetic one....a show...a college based show......gives us PASSION filled scenes.....teenage kids with their over active harmones r gonna like it...proof: this forum....its actually facinating for them....they start equating these scenes as love....with the limited 'sex' education v get here teenage girls will not understand the concequences of being in a room alone with a half- naked guy......on the contrary they will actually fantasize about it.....i have a teenage sis who will b getting admission in a college soon....she sometimes watch MJHT with me....but trust me i will not let her watch MJHT anymore.....but oh well.....what can u expect from the creatives who use the term SEX GOD for a character in an open forum full of teenagers....joke or no joke.....

and plzzz if its a fictional show with nothing whatsoever to do with the reality....the only purpose is entertainment then atleast the creatives should give us some decent entertainment.....or does entertainment means PASSIONATE scenes with no story to speak of......or is the 'oh so hawt' skin show supposed to entertain us......or seeing our favourite characters getting twist up due to their LOVE keeps our entertianment alive.......y r v forced to accept a half-baked story....sorry a totally un-baked story.....just in the name of entertainment......

i have vent out enough about the mayur current track to write more on it......and u all have written everything that could b written about the current mayur track......do not want to repeat it all again......


Well said!😳
403365 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
LOL we all may have exhausted this topic. *Pats us on the shoulder. *
Thank you everyone again for having an insightful and thoughtful discussion without any displeasure.
x.sonia.x thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
theres not much left to say..
nd there is way too much to read..

good job zainu! 👍🏼
Shipra_S thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
hi Zainab😊.....dear i agree with u partially😊.....i will mention where i agree with u and where not😊.....
Disagree---1)First of all dear,the show is for our entertainment.😃....it's not airing on Discovery or Astha channel😆.....so it is not meant to give any moral msg😉.....the show is meant to cater to our entertainment.....which it is doing.....rather doing very well!!😊......so i think it is not proper to expect getting any msg from such shows which are based on College Dramas.....they are meant to entertain and not give moral lessons😊.....
2)We watch show to unwind our self...this is coz our personal life is full of tensions and works,so we watch the show to get rest for some time😊.....any show(not only MJHt) can fulfil this purpose(of entertaining us) when it is away from reality😊.....hum apne personal lives mein itni problems se ladte rahte hain,toh agar show bhi full of problems hoga,toh show dekhne ka fayda hi kya😕.....problems toh hum waise hi apni personal life mein face rahe hain.....so it is appropriate that the show is far from reality😊.....rather a show should be far from reality.😃...kyunki uss 1/2 hour mein toh hum atleast apne din ki sari problems ko chod kar thodi der enjoy kar sakte hain😛.....ab agar show bhi real life ki tarah hoga,i mean full of work,tension,hurdles,etc. toh kya vo hamein enjoyment/rest pohcha payega?!!......i think "NO".....so there is absolutely no harm ki the show is away from reality.😉....par aisa bhi nahin hai ki it is purely fictitious.....MJHt is a proper mix of reality and fiction.😊....
Agree--
I agree with ur third point.😊....no friendship was indeed shown b/w Mayur.....they directly jumped to loving each other from being strangers......this was a little awkward!!.....what we can see b/w them is attraction/infatuation but no true love(i mean full of emotions).....i completely agree with this thing😊.....


But again overall,i m loving the current Mayur track 🤗coz i watch the show for enjoyment and don't put much head into it.😊.....if i dislike some sc. or dialogue,then i take it with a pinch of salt and continue enjoy watcing the show!!😊....
-madhvi- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
well college romances are meant to be based on physical attraction. And moreover its a fiction show. Moreover its kind of closer to the real world compared to other shows; they showed exams, talent parade, play and all these things happen in most colleges.
Moreover they show true friendship also. Like benji and samrat friendship. There are many other friends as well.

now coming to what 19 yr olds think, 15 to 21 all the people i kno think of there dream man/woman. Some have boyfriends/girlfriends too. So its real even there.
Ya shirt less mayank thing is weird but under certain circumstances its possible. But dont think it will give a wrong msg.😊
its my opinion i dint mean to hurt any1 😊 😊
Bazinga thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
Hi Zainab

You opened a wonderful topic and a much needed one 👏 👏 👏 . I don't have anything else to add to this discussion about the so-called blush worthy 'passion' between MN as most of you have reflected my thoughts through your posts. I completely agree with yours, Anu's and Mashaal's posts.

It was certainly not pleasing to watch a 19 yr old gal ogling at a shirtless guy in his changing room and the 19 yr old guy trying to corner her in such a situation is in a really bad taste. The promo is definitely indecorous considering the target audience of this show. Like Mashaal, I also wouldn't let my teen-aged cousin watch this show for I would never want her to fancy that ogling at a semi naked guy or letting him corner her in his changing room qualifies for love.

About my feelings regarding the college romance theme of this show and MN track , I will just copy n paste what I wrote in one of my earlier posts.

I confess I am a love ignorant in the sense that I have never been in love myself. Probably because I have never been on Valentine Ac-Meet trips with a hot guy where we end up getting locked in some stranger's house on valentine's day and my wet hair brushes across his face coupled with his wild imaginations about us result in him falling in love with me. 😳 😳 😳 Also I never took part in PnP DTPH crossed play adaptations or inspirations with the same guy by stalking him n forcing him to play my hero , running around trees like tom N Jerry thrusting roses on him on Rose Day, assuming that he is on drugs n confronting him (despite knowing him inside out) just to be left hurt by him so that he can apologise to me in the sweetest manner possible n come to my place to rehearse on our terrace only to give me his shirt when my dress gets torn leaving me all awestruck , besotted , smitten etc mouthing cheesiest dialogues like "dil main ghanti bhaji". However, from whatever few books I have read on love and learnt about it seeing my friends who have fallen in and are still in love, I gather that love does not happen instantly or abruptly. I would like to believe that love happens over a period of time after people begin to bond, connect , know each other better and reach a certain level of understanding with mutual respect between them (I assure you that all the love stories I know of, have begun during college days only). I understand this is an entertainment show so one should not expect too much of reality in it which is why I enjoyed MN's eye locks, M holding N whenever she tripped , their Salsa rehearsals, TP Salsa, beach scenes, barn scenes etc coz these are things that one cannot expect to see in reality however I also appreciated the fact that all these scenes were shown with a realistic touch to them neatly embedded into a story during the initial episodes, not to forget the decency and class with which they were brought onto the screen. Hence I fell in love with Mayank and Nupur 😊 😊 😊 and assumed that this unique flavor that made Mayank Nupur , THE MN would be maintained throughout the show and we would get to see a beautiful (if not beautiful, at least a sensible) love story that is a perfect amalgamation of fact and fiction which didn't happen at all, much to my dismay
Edited by Kavya_KraZQueen - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".