-#::: Hiranyavarma Radheya - Aham Sharma - AT 29 :::#- - Page 26

Poll

The suitable time for revealing Karna's birth secret to public was?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

68.1k

Users

25

Likes

1.5k

Frequent Posters

Brahmaputra thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ...Diala...

Now I want to believe Karna was not Kunti's son at all.. she knowing Karna to be Adiratha's adopted son and also because he thinks himself to be a Kshatriya, said a lie to soften his heart towards her sons..

I'm no one to object Karna's mother.😆
Brahmaputra thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ...Diala...


🤣 🤣 🤣


I wish he killed a Tigress.. My cub among babies

Baby Karna killed one, while he was a student of Drona, in Mrityunjaya.
Sanskruthi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago
I voted first option it was the right time for her to blurt the truth
koi extra drama nahi hota 😛
kumki thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Brahmaputra

That is why I'm saying the curse part is a later addition. Also the part when Karna forgets Brahmastra. Not only that, Karna used Brahmastra thrice actually, one time before he 'forgot' Brahmastra and twice after he 'forgot'. How sensible is that?😆
If Karna's dialogues in VH can be a later addition, why these curses and forgetting weapons can't be?😆
I also don't believe the curse of Brahmana. It makes no sense that all of a sudden earth began sinking only because of the bitter, angry words of someone told before many years. How did earth know it was the last moment of Karna? Is that ever possible? Plain nonsense written to mask the reason behind his death.
I'm having an almost filled head now. Can't think anymore. I'll write something on this that looks sane & sensible to me, sometime later.😆


But Jamy., u stil didnt answer my question.. If its a later addition., how do we explain Karna's education?! How did Karna manage to complete his education without getting cursed.. 🤔

I had always thought., this brahman's curse was just a folklore 😆 like bhoomi's curse until I read KMG., I will read all your citations on this in later pages and come to this..
kumki thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ...Diala...


If Karna is Jarasandha, me n Riti are Bheem.. tearing him apart 😆


Dii you both definitely don't sound like mommies now 😳 I can understand if some Karnali had said this 😳., but you 😲😡
Brahmaputra thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: swathi.priya

But Jamy., u stil didnt answer my question.. If its a later addition., how do we explain Karna's education?! How did Karna manage to complete his education without getting cursed..🤔
I had always thought., this brahman's curse was just a folklore 😆like bhoomi's curse until I read KMG., I will read all your citations on this in later pages and come to this..

I've posted a lot of stuffs in previous pages. I'll reply after you read all and give some work to my brain.😃
kumki thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Brahmaputra


The curses of Karna can surely be blamed for causing his death. Because Karna being almost invincible in war, he could be killed by unfair means only; which will make the killer (more his advisor) be called forever cheater, wicked and coward. When there are curses that he will forget his weapons while fighting with someone of equal strength & the earth will engulf his chariot's wheel at his time of death, makes his death already fixed by some unknown forces, and that in turn sets Arjuna & Krishna from being accused as both of them were unknown to the curses & they only acted as the situation needed which cannot be questioned given the background of curses as Karna's fate was already fixed.


yes., more than anybody in epic., Karna's death looked sealed very early going by the texts..

But., I still feel with or without curses., it was sure a death which was brought upon him unfairly.. He was killed when he was unarmed., while he was removing the wheel., this was sure killing a person unfairly though it was the oppurtune moment for Krish/Arju to kill him..

Without curse., if his wheel was never struck., Karna would have went on and on fighting., probably just prolonging his death with Krish creating a pothole like u said or someother kinda chal..

Sanskruthi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Brahmaputra

Baby Karna killed one, while he was a student of Drona, in Mrityunjaya.


he just captured it for the sacrifice alive
Edited by .Sanskruti - 10 years ago
kumki thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Brahmaputra


My answers will not be sensible at all., but I will still answer 😛😆

My doubts.
1. How did the intelligent and attentive Karna kill the cow 'without witting it'?

he didnot do it on purpose., there could be many reasons for this .. probably he was hunting which popular theory...

2. When the circumstances leading to killing the cow was not clear, how could the Brahmana curse Karna's cart wheel would sink in the earth? Did Karna do euthanasia of the cow which was engulfed in some quicksand?😆

I suppose Brahmans really don't think before giving out curses., do they?!., I guess he just cursed Karna on impulse., loss of his cow.. like how kshatriyas take vow without a thought in mb.. aren't Brahmans known for giving curses for anything and everything ?!

euthanasia 🤣

3. Cow is not a small animal for to be killed so easily. You need to chase it and kill unless it is not tied to something. No person is a fool to shoot a harmless cow. Moreover, one can recognise a cow even from behind. Isn't it impossible to kill a cow 'unknowingly'? So how can Karna be cursed for getting beheaded? It is not told whether the cow was beheaded which was impossible without seeing it. Had he seen it, he would never have killed the cow.

Probably the it was night time of the day 😛.. Karna could not have seen properly.. and here., it is not mentioned how the cow was killed.. but lprobably that was how the brahman wanted Karna to get killed 😳😡

4. When Karna told none of his personal matters to the Brahmana, how did this man know there was someone who Karna always challenged, for the sake of who Karna strived everyday?

me too

5. As the Brahmana said - "thy foe, putting forth his prowess, will cut off thy head, thyself being stupefied the while!" - & also - "even so wilt thy foe cut off thy head while thou shalt be heedless!"; isn't it clear that this man already had Poorvabhasas of Parashurama's curse which was yet to happen.😲.😲.😲???

🤣 probably he was some super brahman with supernatural poorvabhas powers., maybe Vyasa just forgot to mention this like many other things


The cow didn't know Karna was coming to attack it so that it didn't try to escape. Neither it was confused seeing him.

One more possibilty., it was sleeping or sitting facing in other direction.

Okay. I shall assume the cow got 'stupefied' by Karna's beauty (he was the bull among men, wasn't he?) and was 'heedless' thinking 'let me die with the hands of this hawwt bull among men!'.

what happ to u Jamy., u even made cow blush looking at Karna 🤣

The curse appears to be only a fabricated version of Karna's death. Nothing more. Karna neither killed a cow, nor any Brahmana cursed him.😆

maybe., this story always looked like a folklore story types to me..


...Diala... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: swathi.priya


Dii you both definitely don't sound like mommies now 😳 I can understand if some Karnali had said this 😳., but you 😲😡


Kidding ma.. 😳 I meant we would be troubling him so much..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".