Content deleted - Page 74

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

96.4k

Users

65

Likes

1.8k

Frequent Posters

naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
And draupadi her feelings expressed so well even if it was common then her anxiety of how they would behave with her is so real.
Edited by naq5 - 10 years ago
DharmaPriyaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: naq5

nice update trying to justify the division of draupadi.

was yudi really Rishi Mudgalya in previous birth? written in MB or is it a folktale. Also is the boon that lord shiva gave her also mentioned in MB.

but whatever the justification what i dont still understand is if kunti said something unknowingly n if she did not want draupadi to be divided why couldnt she just take it back. it was an order not a opinion or something that couldnt be taken back n would be held against her like a lie. what if she had said kill someone in a misunderstanding, wud they have followed that too😕. that is why i found the gyan given to Bhishm by krishna in ⭐️MB very apt. Its not necessary to follow your words if they are not doing good to anyone. It is not necessary to follow what u do not feel is right just because you said it. Unless she herself wanted it to keep the unity in her sons intact. This is the most confusing part of MB which i fail to understand . that is why i fell the boon given by shiva to be though little the most convincing answer for this.
And well she could have married only yudi too. if arjun was so concerned about the elder marrying first. if bhishma could win princesses for his brothers why cant arjun for his brother? it was a normal norm during those days.
And i haven till yet come across of citations from MB showing draupadi being pained or uncomfortable regarding this decicion 😕. Or kunti repenting for what she said in jest. Was it just a common thing during those days & we in this yug trying to find reasons to justify it because it is not considered right in this present society. it must be controversial for us but not for them




Actually in those days, words did play an important part in human life. It was Dharma to obey one's elders. You are right. Obeying elders' wrong activities is not Dharma (example: dice hall). But here, Pandav-Draupadi had a last birth connection so they were destined to be united again. Rishi Mudgalya took 5 bodies in next birth and that was Pandavas. I will explain the story in next updates. It's not a folklore, it's found in Southern version of MB which is supposed to be more authentic and detailed. Vyasa himself has narrated this. Now, Pandavas were no such people who would want to do such thing, so God had to arrange that situation to make Mudgalya-Nalayani reunited. Pandavas indeed had one soul in 5 bodies, rishi Mudgalya's soul.
I know this is very controversial part, but see, Krishna happily accepted it so there must be something good in it, and He knew it. If following Kunti's order ended up a painful life for Draupadi then only it could be adharma. But in the epic, Draupadi was never unhappy with this. And Draupadi was always respected as a great Sati, none blamed her for this polyandry. So I don't think it was any adharma.
ltelidevaralak thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: naq5

And draupadi her feelings expressed so well even if it was common then her anxiety of how they would behave with her is so real.

i want your readers to enjoy your epic with a proper knowledge of what happened as per Vyasa.yudhi was maudgalya in previous birth and the way it was given not true.Dear readers,never did Draupadi interact with any of her husbands on that fateful day.Always keep it in mind.Another point to be noted here is because of placing the garland round the neck of arjun,as per the rule of the contest,she is officially the wife of only Arjun.of course the garlanding part is omitted perhaps to show Yudhi and Draupadi as a couple.The epic Draupadi never crossed her limits
ltelidevaralak thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ltelidevaralak

i want your readers to enjoy your epic with a proper knowledge of what happened as per Vyasa.yudhi was maudgalya in previous birth and the way it was given not true.Dear readers,never did Draupadi interact with any of her husbands on that fateful day.Always keep it in mind.Another point to be noted here is because of placing the garland round the neck of arjun,as per the rule of the contest,she is officially the wife of only Arjun.of course the garlanding part is omitted perhaps to show Yudhi and Draupadi as a couple.The epic Draupadi never crossed her limits

she completed her work and slept at their feet Kunitz also slept in that room only.so read the ff enjoy it but don't go with allthat
varaali thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
^^^ What is your problem if I may know ?
We have repeated innumerable times that this is a story / an FF / a creation of our interpretation.
We are entitled to our creativity and imagination.
We have no where claimed that this is a translation of the epic as it is, hence there is no question of misleading
If you have objections please stay away.
Our readership is restricted to a our friends here. However the market is inundated with several other novels which have made a mockery of the epic. Amongst the ones you have mentioned is another one as well.
First please correct them and then come here to correct us.
If you do want to share your knowledge, do so by opening another thread and talk about the Prati Smriti or the Shata Rudriya - which were special incidents in Arjuna's life.
varaali thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ltelidevaralak

i want your readers to enjoy your epic with a proper knowledge of what happened as per Vyasa.yudhi was maudgalya in previous birth and the way it was given not true.Dear readers,never did Draupadi interact with any of her husbands on that fateful day.Always keep it in mind.Another point to be noted here is because of placing the garland round the neck of arjun,as per the rule of the contest,she is officially the wife of only Arjun.of course the garlanding part is omitted perhaps to show Yudhi and Draupadi as a couple.The epic Draupadi never crossed her limits

Please stop putting forth your views here
This is our FF. We will portray as per our interpretation.
If you want your views to be known, please do so in another thread - not here.
I am repeating for the umpteenth time, we are not claiming this is an authentic reproduction of Neelakantha / Kumakonam / BORI- so the question of misleading doesn't arise
You have appreciated other novels which have killed the spirit of the epic,... it should not be problem for you to at least stay away from here.
Edited by varaali - 10 years ago
varaali thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Brishti_Sarkar

Wow!!! So the magic is back again.. I have nothing negative to say about this chapter... Its just so beautiful.. How confidently Yudhishtir says about kunti never uttering untruth.. I can understand what he will feel like at the end of the war when he gets to know of the brutal truth.. The decision making part waa factually and emotionally beautiful!! Loved every explanation and every word.

Draupadi's thoughts are also so wonderfully displayed.. Its becoming like a journey.. Yudhi and Drau speaking together.. The choice of worda is so wonderful.. Spothing and it gives a feel of literature and it has auch a after effect that I feel good reading it. For both Yudhi Pov and Drau pov.

Please continue soon... And from now will all the updates be Yudhi and Drau pov collaborated? :)

Thank you for reading and commenting
Yes, indeed a journey has commenced...ad Drau will speak wherever necessary.
Please keep reading
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: ltelidevaralak

i want your readers to enjoy your epic with a proper knowledge of what happened as per Vyasa.yudhi was maudgalya in previous birth and the way it was given not true.Dear readers,never did Draupadi interact with any of her husbands on that fateful day.Always keep it in mind.Another point to be noted here is because of placing the garland round the neck of arjun,as per the rule of the contest,she is officially the wife of only Arjun.of course the garlanding part is omitted perhaps to show Yudhi and Draupadi as a couple.The epic Draupadi never crossed her limits


we do read the FF keeping in mind tht is is not everything as per MB. the writer has taken creative liberties to show the feelings of the characters, what the character would feel like. That is why from time to time i do keep asking if some instances are folklore or as shown in the real scripture. regarding the feelings of the character well that is always the writers interpretation. so do not worry we are not getting misleaded here.
reg misleading BRC MB was the one of the main misleader people at tht time watched it thinking that it same as the book. Many not happened instances have been embedded in people's mind because it was shown there. At least during ⭐️MB we knew where the distortions were.
Edited by naq5 - 10 years ago
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Urmila11



Actually in those days, words did play an important part in human life. It was Dharma to obey one's elders. You are right. Obeying elders' wrong activities is not Dharma (example: dice hall). But here, Pandav-Draupadi had a last birth connection so they were destined to be united again. Rishi Mudgalya took 5 bodies in next birth and that was Pandavas. I will explain the story in next updates. It's not a folklore, it's found in Southern version of MB which is supposed to be more authentic and detailed. Vyasa himself has narrated this. Now, Pandavas were no such people who would want to do such thing, so God had to arrange that situation to make Mudgalya-Nalayani reunited. Pandavas indeed had one soul in 5 bodies, rishi Mudgalya's soul.
I know this is very controversial part, but see, Krishna happily accepted it so there must be something good in it, and He knew it. If following Kunti's order ended up a painful life for Draupadi then only it could be adharma. But in the epic, Draupadi was never unhappy with this. And Draupadi was always respected as a great Sati, none blamed her for this polyandry. So I don't think it was any adharma.

yes obeying elders was considered imp i understand that. i do not blame the pandavs much for the division as they had to obey what their mother ordered them to do. but what about kunti. mostly her feelings are described as being aghast on what she had ordered he sons to do, worrying about draupadi, thinking it would be adharma etc etc. well then take your order back simple. It was an order not an opinion. Your word does not become untrue if you take an order back which was given in misunderstanding
see for an hypothetical example if kunti's forgetful daughter was cooking, she asks her to add salt thinking that she must not have added it . but on tasting she knows ki she has already added it would she still ask her to add it just because she had ordered something😲. Does she become untruthful if she says no to adding salt later. Compare it to Kunti taking an oath of doing something or giving her sons an opinion on say eg running away from lakshagriha. if she changer her oath or changes her opinion later then she could be considered untruthful. So i actually do not understand her telling yudi "do something that my word is maintained & the dignity of draupadi is also intact. i do not understand the thinking that they listening to her order was so imp even when she felt that her order was wrong. unless she believed that her order would benefit her family i do not see reason. Pandavas being rishi Mudgalya & hence them,kunti n draupadi accepting this situation has more reason than kunti making them do it just to keep her order intact.
Magadh_sundari thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
such a lovely update..always wonderful to read! 👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".