Abhemanyu was not killed by karna

aska123 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Abhemanyu was killed by Dushsan 's son Duseela.
Also It was drona who suggest to use illicit manner to kill Abhemanyu. During fight Abhemanyu also killed Dyroudhan 's son.

Abh has broken Duryodhan's chairot

Created

Last reply

Replies

122

Views

17.4k

Users

29

Likes

370

Frequent Posters

Juggaadd thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Abhimanyu was killed by Karna. Before dying, Abhimanyu manages to kill Duryodhan's son. It is true though that the Chakra Vyuh was Drona's idea. But it was to capture Yudishtir and not for the sake of killing Abhimanyu like in the show.
Edited by Metamorphmagus - 11 years ago
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
TM is right - Abhimanyu was not killed by Karna. Every serial has managed to get it wrong just for the sake of rationalizing the way Arjun killed Karna at the end.


Arjun was justified for killing Karna - but not for this reason. After all, Arjun had his revenge wrt Abhimanyu when he slew Karna's son Vrishasena right in front of him
daenerysnow thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
In making Karna do it makes up for his lack of involvement in the VH ep and his generally mild role in displaying more compassion:conflict with the Pandava, and it would also feed into the reason that makes Arjun deliver the final shot to Karnas life. That would seem befitting enough in the mind of the cvs, to tie all ends in this way.
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
no. he wasn't killed by karna.He was killed by a group of warriors and army.
because they couldn't kill him in one on one fights.he kept making them run away from him-- Karen,duryodhan etc.
moreover he killed a lot of maharathis.

so no.he wasn't just killed by karna -- it was a group effort. dushis son just happened to deliver the last blow.not like he could have killed him by himself when warriors like during,sushi,karn and ashwi couldn't kill him.
it was only after he was weakened,injured and ganged up on by the maharathis that he was killed-that too while he was trying to get up.

yes. drona suggested this method --- when? when karna asked him how to get rid of abhimanyu who they were unable to kill and had to run away from.
had these great warriors not given their own great contributions and worked together as a team -- the grand kill wouldn't have been possible.applauses.
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Not like if they had shown how it really happened and the kaurava army esp. during and karna celebrating his death -- then arjun wouldn't have a valid reason to kill karna-- "oh he wasn't the one who technically killed my son so I can't kill him for that"
now karna actually delivering the last blow and arjun killing him for that?
men,another chance to make arjun look like a brat for killing the person who stopped the torture of his son and killed him out of mercy and kindness.
--Royal-- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
when 8 MahaRathi are continue fighting with a Abhimanyu its really matter who attack first n who attack in the end????.🤔 just coz Dushi' son is d last person who final attack on him so thats means Abhi killed by dushi's son only???? 😕 Really???
bobbiswas thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
The worst part of this Star Bharat is they did not showcased the capability of Abhimanyu.
They should have showed that on a 1-on-1 he defeated everyone and then they jointly attacked with Drona's advice and NOT Duryodhan's AADESH.
Karna was part of the team who from back broke his chariot and broke his bow, so it justifies anyways Arjun killing Karna and Jayadratha. But the one actually whom Arjuna should have hated and killed instantly should have been DRONA. He is a son loving greedy Bhrambhin who in greed of money and power sold his soul to Kauravas. He is worse than Duryodhana
ElMystique thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: bobbiswas

The worst part of this Star Bharat is they did not showcased the capability of Abhimanyu.

They should have showed that on a 1-on-1 he defeated everyone and then they jointly attacked with Drona's advice and NOT Duryodhan's AADESH.
Karna was part of the team who from back broke his chariot and broke his bow, so it justifies anyways Arjun killing Karna and Jayadratha. But the one actually whom Arjuna should have hated and killed instantly should have been DRONA. He is a son loving greedy Bhrambhin who in greed of money and power sold his soul to Kauravas. He is worse than Duryodhana

@ BLUE this is not true Abhimanyu's chariot was destroyed by Kritiverman and kripa (abhimanyu's steeds and charioteers resp)
Karna broke his bow (which according to most of this forum members is a fair fight)
Basically Karna and abhimanyu had a duel in which Abhimanyu peirced Karna and injured him Karna trembled and fled away later he came back said that he is staying in the battlefield because he is a warrior otherwise he was badly injured and then requested Drona to suggest him a way to kill this boy this is when Karna broke abhimanyu's bow ...
and in weaponless state all the warriors I mean MAHARATHIS showerd Arrows abhi picked up the wheel this was exactly when he became incapable also his armor was cut off by Karna and this was followed by Dushyasanas son's BLOW..
So it is a combined effort of All the Maharathis their sons and relatives not to forget the respective armies of each warrior which lead to the fall of Abhimanyu that too in a chakravyuh...
So final verdict this was a combined effort of a ocean of Soldiers warriors and Maharathis headed By Dronacharya and Karna...

Edited by frappie - 11 years ago
...Diala... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Not according to forum members but according to KMG and also Dutt's translation he broke the bow with fair fight..

if the last blow would not count as the killing act then no one was killed by any 'one'.. no one should be credited for killing a warrior.. it was a war and everyone was tired and exhausted fighting other warriors and finally killed by someone else or one among them in a head on collision.. Abhimanyu was not killed by many.. it was only Dushasan's son..

if there was someone who was killed/defeated by many warriors attacking him it was Bhishma.. no way it was Abhimanyu..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".