Feedback to CVs thread- Story distortion#1 - Page 84

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

120.9k

Users

113

Likes

2.4k

Frequent Posters

...Diala... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
@Gowri... me too done with watching tear filled eyes of Karna.. I could not enjoy Aham's presence because of this in that flag hoisting scene .. Most of us are much awaiting the Swayamvar to see him change.. I wonder where else they can bring in that..
If the CVs are interested in showing him as a tragic hero they will have to wait until Krishna opens the secret to him.. in-between should only be the fierce and frustrated one one who develops hatred towards almost everyone around taunting him on his caste..
Edited by ...Diala... - 11 years ago
gowri122 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
@Gowri... me too done with watching tear filled eyes of Karna.. I could not enjoy Aham's presence because of this in that flag hoisting scene .. Most of us are much awaiting the Swayamvar to see him change.. I wonder where else they can bring in that..
If the CVs are interested in showing him as a tragic hero they will have to wait until Krishna opens the secret to him.. in-between should only be the fierce and frustrated one one who develops hatred towards almost everyone around taunting him on his caste..

my fave Karna scene was definitely the rangbhoomi one. his eyes were full of fire & shone truly like the sun. that is how Karna shud be, fierce & witty, tit 4 tat young man with not that much respect 4 elders. this eternally sobbing righteous Karna doesn't fit the bill 4 me. aham also seem to excel in greyness shade of the character. rangbhoomi performance by him was unforgettable, all my hair stood in attention wen i watched it. unlike many, i always luv an actor who can pull off villainy, comedy etc. aham shines in all these genres😛
Edited by gowri122 - 11 years ago
...Diala... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
exactly!!!! he was nothing less that a Roaring Lion those two days 👍🏼
then he changed to a cutie cutie puppy pug 😆😆😆
Ashwini_D thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
In their attempt to whitewash Draupadi, they ended up showing her as being ignorant/disapprover of the caste system when she is having this conversation with the dasi and her daughter.
That goes against her act of preventing Karna to participate in the swayamvar, by calling him a sutputra (Not if they follow the BRC version though, which shows Krishna as having urged her to do this)

Another jewel of shoddy writing in the CV's crown.
DAMZLS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Star Bharat's portrayal of Arjun as Maha Nayak is crossing all limits. Would want to list the attributes/achievements of this Maha Nayak Arjun for the kind info of CVs;


1. Arjun defeats Dhuryodhan during the Pratiyogita in an uneven battle in which he uses bow and arrow of which he is a master and not with mace.

2. Finds himself equal to Karna and was unable to defeat him during the Pratiyogita.

3. Dhuryodhan achieves as much as Arjun in the battle against Drupad, and it is because of Krishna's help that Arjun manages to win.

4. Wins Draupadi, but with Bheem's help manages to leave the hall with Draupadi against the onslaught of other kings.

5. When in Indraparasta, he goes on exile only to enjoy the company of Uloopi, Chitrangada, gandharva kanyas and finally to get one permanent wife for himself.

6. During Vanvas, spends a lot of time in Swarg lok enjoying dance and music. Yes, helps Indra to defeat Navata Kavachas.

7. During Agyat Vaas, enjoys life in the company of young girls in the pretext of a curse. Why couldn't he join as an assistant to Sairendri in serving Sudhheshne?

8. At the end of Agyat Vaas, gets Uttara married to his son Abhimanyu and not the eldest son (Prati Vindhya) of Pandavas who is about 7 to 8 years elder to Abhimanyu.

9. Defeats the entire Kaurav sena by using Sanmohini astra during the battle at the end of Agyaat Vaas.

10. Kills Bheeshma after he gives up arms seeing Shikhandini in Arjun's chariot.

11. Avoids battle with Drona.

12. Kills Jayadrath as per his oath by Krishna's help.

13. Kills Karna when he was engaged in pulling his chariot out of mother earth. Gets help of Kunti, Indra and Krishna in accomplishing this.

On the contrary, Bheem's achievements are:-

1. Single handedly kills Hidimba, Bakasur, Jarasandh, Kirmeera and Keechaka along with all his brothers.

2. Kills all 100 sons of Dritharastra without anybody's help. This despite Dhuryodhan's vajra Kaay blessed by Ghandhari.

3.Provides empathy to Draupadi during 12 years of Van Vaas.


One may recall that in Krith Yug, every time any misdeed by Indra caused empowerment of Rakshasas,it was always Vishnu, Shiv or Durga who had to come to his rescue. And Arjun is born to this Indra. And Bheem was born to Vayu with an illustrious elder brother Sri Hanuman ji. Hanuman ji is an epitome of Bhakti and Bheem an epitome of Shakhti. As we all know, Hanuman ji is worshipped by most of us, and in Northern India there are temples for Bheem which are visited by the newly weds where in the groom prays to Bheem to give him strength to protect his wife from all evil forces.

Knowing the above facts of Mahabharat, it is simply irritating to watch Starbharat portraying Arjun as Maha Nayak and Bheem as a comedian.

I have decided to stop watching this Starbharat!

Edited by DAMZLS - 11 years ago
guenhwyvar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
Well the first three are Star Bharat's fictitious additions so they don't count (since everything else from the MB and not SPs MB). That being said, Arjuna was Krishna's best friend. further it is because of Arjuna that we have the knowledge of the Gita.

It was because of Arjun (and Krishna ofc) that the Pandavas won, otherwise Bhisma, Drona, and Karna could have easily won the war. Bhim played an important role no doubt, and I also hatethe CVs portrayal of such an amazing person

Nonetheless, we each have our respective opinions, just wanted to post my two cents.
Wistfulness thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Banner Contest Winner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 years ago
What if the CVs would have been obsessed with the character of Duryodhan? 😈

"Ye gaatha hai MahaKhalnayak Duryodhan ki"
🤣

Maybe they would have used the particular term for his character.
...Diala... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
Khalnayak 🤣

Duryodhan ke sat hua anyaay ki
Duryodhan ka Apmaan ki
Duryodhan ka Pratishod ki
Suyodhan ka name change ki 😆
Edited by ...Diala... - 11 years ago
...Diala... thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
Draupadi to get married.. What about Sikhandini and Dushala?😭

Did Drona get the news of Pandava's death? Did they show him mourn? Even Drupad seems to be unaware.. He was asking for a son who can defeat Pandavas
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: DAMZLS

On the contrary, Bheem's achievements are:-

1. Single handedly kills Hidimba, Bakasur, Jarasandh, Kirmeera and Keechaka along with all his brothers.

2. Kills all 100 sons of Dritharastra without anybody's help. This despite Dhuryodhan's vajra Kaay blessed by Ghandhari.

3.Provides empathy to Draupadi during 12 years of Van Vaas.


One may recall that in Krith Yug, every time any misdeed by Indra caused empowerment of Rakshasas,it was always Vishnu, Shiv or Durga who had to come to his rescue. And Arjun is born to this Indra. And Bheem was born to Vayu with an illustrious elder brother Sri Hanuman ji. Hanuman ji is an epitome of Bhakti and Bheem an epitome of Shakhti. As we all know, Hanuman ji is worshipped by most of us, and in Northern India there are temples for Bheem which are visited by the newly weds where in the groom prays to Bheem to give him strength to protect his wife from all evil forces.

Knowing the above facts of Mahabharat, it is simply irritating to watch Starbharat portraying Arjun as Maha Nayak and Bheem as a comedian.

I have decided to stop watching this Starbharat!



Also, note that Arjun had Hanuman & Krishna in his chariot as well - for all who want to point out Arjun's superiority over Bhima due to divyastras. Bhima was usually in the thick of things - not just fighting Gandhareyas during the war, but also doing things like saving Dhrishtadyumna from Drona, Abhimanyu from Shalya, and along w/ Satyaki, supporting Arjun in destroying 8 of the 11 Kaurava akshaunis on day 14. In the current period that they are showing, it was Bhima who was staying awake @ nights & protecting the rest of the Pandavas, so that the rest of them could peacefully sleep.

Also, the Pandavas did not have their weapons, which is what helped in their disguise. Here, they've reconstructed their favorite weapons and are continuing - who wouldn't recognize them? And w/o his bow, Arjun was nothing. He only got the bow @ Draupadi's swayamvara, which he could then use to protect Drupada & Dhrishtadyumna from the irate kings who were furious that a Brahmin had won this.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".