Originally posted by: shani88
Hypothetical question -
If Arjuna hadn't panicked before the start of the Kurukshetra war, would the Gita have been narrated at all? Or was the narration of the Gita pre-destined that in the event of Arjuna remaining calm and composed, Krishna would've "created" a situation that would've caused Arjuna to panic (He is Krishna, He can do anything!), thereby resulting in the narration of the Gita? Or was the narration of the Gita simply a consequence of Arjuna's personality flaw of letting his emotions get the better of him?
Also, on the Kurukshetra battlefield, why was Arjuna the ONLY person who panicked and wanted to back out? Did anyone else also have second thoughts about fighting the Kurukshetra war just before the start of the battle?
Well, if Arjuna hadn't panicked, then maybe Krishna would have provoked him by saying, "Will you kill you relatives?" And then contradict Himself.😆
OR he could have manipulated Yudhishtira the Satyavadi to get sad and all that.😆
Answering Qn 2. I don't think so. Everyone were so bloodthirsty and ready to kill that this just didn't strike them. maybe Arjuna is the "Nallavan" as they say. Meaning, very good person who thinks about everyone. But howcome Yudhistira never had such thoughts?😲