Posted:
wonderful analysis!!! i completely agree with you. the major problem with sultan's chr is its inconsistency. cvs shd have introduced him as another actor, they cd have had a terrific parallel lead. there wd have been no need for a bhai bhai track. another actor wd have worked.
introduced him as a dreaded gangster but made him so helpless that a woman had to hide him in her chawl n save him. it made him look ridiculous. first there was a hint of a sad past n that vanished all of a sudden n we got him look at our heroine who is still in love with her husband with loving eyes.
if the hero is completely bad, d golden hearted gangster falling for the heroine wd have been a triangular love story. but d cvs had promoted d story as eternal love story between hero n heroine. for all his faults, hero was shown always caring for heroine evn during his worst phase. so ppl though were upset with him, wanted him back with d heroine. so there were no takers for gangster romance.
so next step cvs made the gangster a repulsive villain who suddenly turns from loving guy to lusting villain. he manhandles the girl, threatens her, tortures her n hurts her husband - and all for love.
complete rejection of bhai - cvs are majorly responsible for the mess. they can't give such a faulty inconsistent chr n expect us to accept him.
very good analysis, enjoyed it.
0