Madhu's marital status...Married or Unmarried? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

60

Views

5.5k

Users

31

Likes

150

Frequent Posters

Forever_Komal thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
Married

They signed official documents stating that RK and Madhu are husband and wife until Madhu or her father repays the 40 lacks

Until they both sign official documents terminating the first contract they are married.


But I would love to see them get married fully traditionally with all the rituals!! 😳
ennishet thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: vmpy

they r indirectly bashing them.



It doesn't make any difference to me; if they're happy saying RK and Madhu are living in sin, so be it. AND Radhaji allowing it???? Impossible 😊
jyothi- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
She is not married.
Saath phere pura nahi hua.
-anoshka- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#14
Seriously, I don't know😕

Even I had four pheres ( married a punjabi guy ) ..pheres are not the issue for me but the vows and all seemed quite wrong...so I don know
Edited by Wicked-Anoshka - 12 years ago
butterfly15.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#15
By Hindu rituals I guess they are unmarried.

RK however isn't very traditional or religious, so I guess to him it doesn't matter whether he has 4 pheres or 24!

To Madhu I thought it would matter, but it didn't which was confusing.
To Madhu she was married, so I guess it doesn't matter whether she took 7 or 4 pheres.

But even by Hindu rituals, peoples opinions vary. Some on the forum who are Hindu say they would accept a marriage based on 4 pheres, whereas some say you should do 7 and go completely by the book. So I guess both are right in their own ways. I'm not a Hindu, so I won't say I think one way is correct and the other is not.

People are saying they are legally married because RK made Madhu sign a contract. As far as I know such a thing does not exist in law. You have to specifically register your marriage. RK making Madhu sign the contract has no bearing on the legality of their marriage. They are legally unmarried. Such a contract would never be enforceable in law.

But I don't think we should really bother with this. When the writers want it, RK and Madhu are married and when they don't want it RK and Madhu aren't married. The writers are happily mocking marriage and making a joke of their own show!




Edited by butterfly15.. - 12 years ago
-Narnia- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16
THEY'RE MARRIED and madhu khud apne apko Madhubala Rishabh Kundra mention kar chuki hai already
bhanu_rekhag thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
if throwing mangalsutr on face n poring sindoor on floor ..comes under marriage yep she is married...

coz I don't know phersa but magalsutr is main in any hindu tradition ...n they r shown Maharashtra'ians in show so as per them they r unmarried...

n legally..they didn't sign legal papers..n just a thumb impression from shammu which is invalid as per law coz no court consider physically oir medically unfit person's sign or thumb impression is invalid...so not legally wedded

n lastly he announced b4 whole world they r unwed which in reality never was a wedding

hence in any way they r unmarried...as per any tradition...

only CVs know how they r using nay of the aspects as either marriage or no marriage...
psk08 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: bhanu_rekhag

if throwing mangalsutr on face n poring sindoor on floor ..comes under marriage yep she is married...

coz I don't know phersa but magalsutr is main in any hindu tradition ...n they r shown Maharashtra'ians in show so as per them they r unmarried...

n legally..they didn't sign legal papers..n just a thumb impression from shammu which is invalid as per law coz no court consider physically oir medically unfit person's sign or thumb impression is invalid...so not legally wedded

n lastly he announced b4 whole world they r unwed which in reality never was a wedding

hence in any way they r unmarried...as per any tradition...

only CVs know how they r using nay of the aspects as either marriage or no marriage...


Sorry to disagree.. if you have followed MEIEJ closely... they are not shown as maharashtrian..they are staying in mumbai..but RK a kundra is a Punjabi and MB's mother ran away from a place called Madhubani..thats in BIhar.. and in both the culture Mangalsutra is not the main thing...
and they were legally married , if you go in flashback where reporters asked MB whether they were married she clearly confirmed to press that yes hamari shadi ho chuki thi lekin ab hum alag rahte hai...
So its very clear and there is no doubt about it that they are married couple
bhanu_rekhag thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: psk08


Sorry to disagree.. if you have followed MEIEJ closely... they are not shown as maharashtrian..they are staying in mumbai..but RK a kundra is a Punjabi and MB's mother ran away from a place called Madhubani..thats in BIhar.. and in both the culture Mangalsutra is not the main thing...
and they were legally married , if you go in flashback where reporters asked MB whether they were married she clearly confirmed to press that yes hamari shadi ho chuki thi lekin ab hum alag rahte hai...
So its very clear and there is no doubt about it that they are married couple



she is still feeling bcoz CVs showed her a sentimental fool..but in reality they were never married in any tradition b it legal or illegal...its more like watching a show where girls live in their own mindless life supporting the man whom they love n feel they r married...but in reality which society accepts this as marriage except in MB show...also if mangalsutr is not main thing wht is main thing in that marriage? n why paddy wear it untill she wanna move on???

ok leave bihar or any other place just tell me 4 pheras or smacking magalsutr on face n pouring down sindoor n thumb impression of a almost dead patient who is foster father of the girl comes under marriage...its just we being the fans of their romance accepted it but CVs gave a seriosu reality check only after marriage n then only this question araised... if u c even b4 all this there r lots of people here who ariased this question which fell in deaf ears coz of the romantic hearts of we people...which include me...

psk08 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: bhanu_rekhag



she is still feeling bcoz CVs showed her a sentimental fool..but in reality they were never married in any tradition b it legal or illegal...its more like watching a show where girls live in their own mindless life supporting the man whom they love n feel they r married...but in reality which society accepts this as marriage except in MB show...also if mangalsutr is not main thing wht is main thing in that marriage? n why paddy wear it untill she wanna move on???

ok leave bihar or any other place just tell me 4 pheras or smacking magalsutr on face n pouring down sindoor n thumb impression of a almost dead patient who is foster father of the girl comes under marriage...its just we being the fans of their romance accepted it but CVs gave a seriosu reality check only after marriage n then only this question araised... if u c even b4 all this there r lots of people here who ariased this question which fell in deaf ears coz of the romantic hearts of we people...which include me...


Indian culture is so diverse that you can't say that if one place Mangalsutra is important than in every other state the same marriage rituals are followed in the same way.. from kasmir to TN n from west to east ..customs, traditions , rituals are very different.. lets not get into it... 😊
I agree that the way they married was not right but that does not mean that legally they were not married ...
Edited by psk08 - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".