Episode 251 Discussion: 20th April 2013

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

cardio21

@cardio21

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#71

Originally posted by: blacklambo

Point 1 - True that...revenge for 4 slaps does not equate to living a lie and breaking a heart.

Point 2 - Can you clarify which statement you are referring to?

Point 3 - What RK is hearing from Madhu and seeing are two different things...hence his suspicion. The mannequin scene seems to have been engineered right after RK witnessed Madhu trying to contact Sultan, who is a gun wielding person. I don't believe he will kill but he is showing Madhu the mirror of what might actually happen should this fiasco continue any further. He is just creating more drama to attain his desired outcome. Add to that, he has seen Madhu's reaction to his hand cutting scene. By taking a step further and putting a gun to his head and firing, he is ensuring that Madhu initiates a full stop to her relationship with Sultan. He might be using extreme language to stop the Sultan problem from developing into a crisis. He wants Madhu at RK Mansion completely devoted to him and is getting that next week with the new promo out.

PS - Agree.

Point 2.. When e said that whether he loves her or not, she s only supposed to love him.. I think this statement, even though annoying implied the post revenge times. He was not talking about the present, he would never say that he doesn't love her knowingly or unknowingly. He just doesn't say it properly.

And if u felt the same as mentioned in PS, it's clear that they didnt desire to show any kind of physical abuse but were unable to express the passion without bordering into an uncomfortable zone..

Quote

Charu

@Krinya

Trailblazer

+ 8

Posted: 12 years ago

#72

I'll be very honest with my review..it took my some time to absorb what i saw...before that, time for some appreciation..

@Soundarya, When I opened this thread the first time and went through the reviews, your review was the one which completely matched my thoughts toh I'm a fan of yours from day 1 😃 Even today, it was the same...

Pnars, Shri, awesome analysis 👏 pleasure reading your insights (which i usually miss)

coming to Sat. episode, I was joyful that one of my predictions turned out to be true 😆 that RK will confess...and he did 🥳 but it was so much twisted ke very few cud understand (guess Madhu also needed an interpreter like Shri and Soundarya, she was acting totally mysterious) ..i came across a few posts which said that RK equating his 4 slaps with Madhu's heart breaking was unjust? 😕 we're forgetting that they are two unique characters, OUR judgement do no imply on them..how we wud have reacted if somebody slapped us? or how we wud have reacted if someone took revenge, blah blah blah ! it's useless...two, he trusted Madhu..if he did not, as he said, he wud have killed her for betraying him..i said this in the META thread once, ke he thinks ke irrespective of what he does, irrespective of his revenge, his love or no love, Madhu loves him toh she has to continue loving him 😆 n he said exactly the same dialogue to her on Saturday👍🏼 all in all, some progress in their convo 👏 had Madhu thinking 😆

Thank you cardio for his dialogues, I dun remember the actual scene and the dialogues..but the way he enacted this whole drama , gave me immense satisfaction that at least Sultan is out of the picture..not out of the serial but out of Rishbala story..

my fav. scene was the last one in which i was laughing like mad n my mom was 😲 looking at me "aisa kya hai hasne wala?" 🤣 when RK came marching in the chawl, i was amused with Padmini's reaction..wasn't she holding her smile? i dun know why...she's not concerned /worried for Madhu even after hearing she's missing?😆 i thought she was happy ke Madhu is not with RK ! RK was so right, this is not the first time Madhu bhaagi hai...on the studio night, he came to chawl looking for her, again when she went missing in the jungle and aaj phir se ! it's a regular task for him n Madhu's family know ke it's RK's headache to search Madhu , not theirs toh they don't bother to react now ! 😆😎

precap , he can give acha pati banne ka gyan to RK without "agar Madhu meri biwi hoti" blah blah 😆

Edited by _charu_ - 12 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Shridevi Gaddam

@0-SD-0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#73

Originally posted by: zoya_naziya

Why can't it be the Holi moments?

Because his Holi moments follow his "maine bahut socha...aur tumhe chaahne, choone ka haque sirf mera hai...

After that sochna Holi happens.

Go on reading.

The dialogues are always logically and sequentially constructed, especially if it happens to be a KHULASA special episode for VIEWERS

Quote

war_is_peace

@war_is_peace

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#74

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0

Because his Holi moments follow his "maine bahut socha...aur tumhe chaahne, choone ka haque sirf mera hai...

After that sochna Holi happens.

Go on reading.

The dialogues are always logically and sequentially constructed, especially if it happens to be a KHULASA special episode for VIEWERS

i was rather thinking that by uss din he meant the holi moment (after all the romancing part...all the ugly part m talking abt) and then

"Par Phir socha, kyon karoon mein yeh sab ?

Tum to mujhse pyaar karti ho, Tumhe chaahne ka, Tumhe choone ka haque, sirf mujhe hai. Aur kisi ka nahin.

Toh main kyon chinta karoon jab mere alaawa tumhaare Dil mein kisi aur ke liye pyaar aa hi nahin sakta ?

Kyon Chinta karoon??"

was abt the knife scene confession from madhu...🤔 becoz dat was wen he got the surity that she loves only him...not before dat..

Edited by war_is_peace - 12 years ago

Quote

zoya_naziya

@zoya_naziya

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#75

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0

Because his Holi moments follow his "maine bahut socha...aur tumhe chaahne, choone ka haque sirf mera hai...

After that sochna Holi happens.

Go on reading.

The dialogues are always logically and sequentially constructed, especially if it happens to be a KHULASA special episode for VIEWERS

You are very right and I get where you're coming from...

Ok.. This is why I told Holi moments...

He comes a lil nervous,pensive only to the chawl... He then witnesses a few happy moments b/w them... He drops the hand full of gulaal and goes away in anger... And then this phir socha can come(as in he reminds himself) ... so he returns with the dhol and gulaal colored face...

Do you think this cannot be taken into consideration as well?

Edited by zoya_naziya - 12 years ago

Quote

war_is_peace

@war_is_peace

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#76

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0

Par Phir socha, kyon karoon mein yeh sab ?
Tum to mujhse pyaar karti ho, Tumhe chaahne ka, Tumhe choone ka haque, sirf mujhe hai. Aur kisi ka nahin.
Toh main kyon chinta karoon jab mere alaawa tumhaare Dil mein kisi aur ke liye pyaar aa hi nahin sakta ?
Kyon Chinta karoon?

[ME]: So that was your subconscious thinking over abroad shoot schedule - The Buck Tooth Painting Day episode on 30th March
Then you returned to India, and were thinking all of it over Woh Lamhe Song and decided to go an color Madhu on Holi

but actually the woh lamhe song happened after holi n before the kidnap...the day he called pack up at home...same evening he went n got her home...

Edited by war_is_peace - 12 years ago

Quote

Angeena

@Angeena

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#77

Originally posted by: war_is_peace

but actually the woh lamhe song happened after holi n before the kidnap...the day he called pack up at home...same evening he went n got her home...

The Woh Lamhe song was first played the night before the Holi celebration .. 2nd April episode I think.

Quote

Shridevi Gaddam

@0-SD-0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#78

Originally posted by: Angeena
The Woh Lamhe song was first played the night before the Holi celebration .. 2nd April episode I think.

Woh Lamhe song happens twice for him.

Once with Sultan and Madhu included on 2nd April and then only RK on 8th April.

As for the Maine Bahut Socha Debate...the intensity of passion...and resolution was played on 30th March - the Buck toothed painting day...with song..."Is Lamhe kya Kar jaaon main...Chod doon...Cheen loon" from the Rock Star

Quote

Shridevi Gaddam

@0-SD-0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#79

Originally posted by: zoya_naziya
You are very right and I get where you're coming from...

Ok.. This is why I told Holi moments...

He comes a lil nervous,pensive only to the chawl... He then witnesses a few happy moments b/w them... He drops the hand full of gulaal and goes away in anger... And then this phir socha can come(as in he reminds himself) ... so he returns with the dhol and gulaal colored face...

Do you think this cannot be taken into consideration as well?

NOPE

Phir Socha Debate...the intensity of passion...and resolution was played on 30th March - the Buck toothed painting day...with song..."Is Lamhe kya Kar jaaon main...Chod doon...Cheen loon" from the Rock Star

Zoya, Read this and refresh your memory.

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/80670369

We just have to add this saturday's dialogue to that repository I created and you will get what CVs are trying to tell you for RK's character.

Edited by 0-SD-0 - 12 years ago

Quote

zoya_naziya

@zoya_naziya

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#80

Re. the difference between confession at the farm-house and the one on Saturday's episode...

Apart from what Shri has told, the difference is that in the farm house confession , he was very cleverly honest to the point that he touched upon her traits, behavior, craziness that attracted him to her..

But Saturday's confession was all about himself, his feelings , etc... It was intense, crude and basically explained how she is ingrained in his every cell...

In the farmhouse confession, he mouthed a dialogue

"Tumhi meri chahat ho, tumhi meri dhadkan

Tumhi mera ishq ho, tumhi mera junoon"

In Sat's confession, he demonstrated these very words clearly and hence was more impactful...