*Tolerance; Hypocrisy; Humanity aur MB* - Page 12

Created

Last reply

Replies

267

Views

14.1k

Users

80

Likes

1k

Frequent Posters

Basilisk thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
Awesome post jules!!
I said this in Meenu's poll yesterday also that what Madhu is doing is called HUMANITY which some people might have forgotten!
I'm appalled at the hypocrisy of these bashers! It was ok for Madhu to give blood to RK and walk barefeet to Sidhivinayik even after everything RK had done to Madhu but its not ok for Madhu to take care of an injured man when he has not done anything to Madhu!! Has Sultan destroyed her life? NO!!! Has Sultan insulted Madhu in front of the whole world? NO!! Has Sultan used her and threw her for the sake of a so called revenge? NO!!
Seriously, some people just make me laugh!
-brokensoul- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Cassie..

Commenting again... coz one of my posts got ignored. [not by you Jules, pls don't mind 😆]

From the beginning, I used to ask for character development of Madhubala.. But I have understood, if the makers have to carry the show to 1000+ epis, they'll narrate this story in their style. The viewer can only decide to watch or not...The tweet of ST in this respect "Story telling is not democratic process.. Its only one vision..."

If they have established the character of Madhubala in this way, it must be for some reason. Up to now, Madhubala's character has been consistent [she acts with her heart always]... so, does she merit bashing for some actions that she takes and then be lauded for some others when both have been stemming from the same characteristic trait of hers. [Siddhivinayak, loving Rk so much more than herself - would anyone be ready at all to leave her entire world/family and go away only for reassuring Rk that she'll always love him despite his insecurities; These have been appreciated on the forum (not by me 😆).]

I say, thank God, past wounds hasn't scarred and handicapped MB to the extent that she cannot open up her heart any longer. She has smiled for the first time with Aryan post-revenge drama and has bonded with him. She is showing concern for Sultan in his capacity of Aryan's papa only... [Another thing is, she may have learnt after all not to meddle with the justice system from the Rk debacle. It didn't do anything but wreck havoc the first time round.. 😵😆 ]

Madhubala acting with her heart, may be a flaw and she has to smarten up - people say so - but would she be the same Madhubala that she is right now? She'd become calculative in all decisions - she'd never go back and accept Rk after the un-wedding or whatever. I'm glad she still believes in herself and lives her life in the way she wants to...[much better than wallowing in self-pity.] The bashing Madhubala has been subject to, for following her gut feeling and make sure that Aryan is safe, is not warranted at all.



To make Rishbala happen in the end, wouldn't the same Madhu who still thinks from her heart and who is compassionate enough to forgive is needed.


Otherwise forget it there won't be RISHBALA if she tries to act on her experiences all the time.

Because forgiving RK and loving him has been the biggest mistake she has done if we see the current situation she is in and if we just remember what happened a couple of days back in mandap, chawl and at RK mansion and even on the set.


So people who want Rishbala in the end, should we root Madhubala to change and think calculatively and take every step of her life?? Will there be Rishbala then??



mehwish134 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
👏👏👏wonderful post dear and i want to thanks dear...forum need this post...every track i will appreciate and full support to madhu because this show base on madhu life's...not rk and sultan...
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: mehwish134

👏👏👏wonderful post dear and i want to thanks dear...forum need this post...every track i will appreciate and full support to madhu because this show base on madhu life's...not rk and sultan...


@Bold -- This is the topmost fact.. its Madhubala Ek Ishq Ek Junoon .. neither RK nor Sultan or X y z
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: fia21



Regarding all the "Sultan is a criminal" chants. I seriously feel like banging my head against a wall. Everyone who thinks that ONLY Sultan is a criminal here should grab a dictionary and learn the meaning of that word. Anyone who breaks the law is called a criminal. Now I don't know if people don't see it or are deliberately ignoring it, but RK has committed enough crimes too.

1. Hit and run with Mukund -> Madhu herself got him to jail 😊
2. Drunk driving -> No one has caught him/ is a witness ..so who will punish him? 😕
3. Bribing the Police -> Which also helped to take Madhus father Shammo out of prison
4. Beating another person to death -> He din beat.. Bittu did.. n he talked to Shammo n they both (tho i dun approve) CANCELLED OUT EACH OTHERS WRONGS...
5. Blackmailing -> Madhu din bow down to it..!

So why should RK be spared of being tagged with this amazing title? We all know Sultan is a gangster and has his fair share of bad in him, then why be so biased when it comes to RK? If after all his bad deeds Madhu still fell in love with him, why can't she help Sultan when he needs someone?


Talking of Criminals.. even Shammo is one .. then..! 😆 [attempted murder not once. .but TWICE]

The discussion is not ..if RK is wrong or not..WE ALL KNOW HE IS WRONG .. .what he did to Madhu was inhuman...but what Madhu is doing is putting herself in RISK all over again..! She should have approached the law ..!

I have a problem with just that bit..!

And being Smart doesnt mean being Calculative. . .its called learning from experience. !!

Edited by Armu4eva - 12 years ago
Taiyo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
The story would not have moved towards the so called, fake or real, R.K and Madhubala love story if R.K had not put a condition of marrying him in return for saving her foster father's life. It was so wrong at so many points. He did not do so out of sympathy or empathy but purely to avenge the four slaps received from Madhubala. But, then that was accepted because of dark character and his dark, multi-layered ways.

There is no wrong or right characters in a story but all are characters and it's just that some characters are sketched more influential than others. In a story, there is nothing wrong to have a Don and make the female protagonist display her human concern for him. Plus, this show is Bollywood inspired and we have stories of underworld dons and their love for Bollywood divas.

Madhubala is not a real person but a figment of a writer's imagination and she will not behave according to the norms of our society but according to the norms set for the fictitious world by the writer. Getting the Don arrested may happen in the real world because there is no story to take forward but if that happens in the fictitious world, the story may not have its twists and conflicts. Our lives are not that interesting and that is why we are not characters in a world of fiction.

P.S.: The story cannot stop moving ahead because of one of the leads absence. Blame the demands of the daily story telling and not the characters for showing what you dislike.


Edited by an12345678 - 12 years ago
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: an12345678



P.S.: The story cannot stop moving ahead because of one of the leads absence. Blame the demands of the daily story telling and not the characters for showing what you dislike.



😔 satyavachan
bestlover thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
nice post
first time ase log dekh rahi hoon jo kisi character ko uski humanity ke liye bash kar rahe hai
Edited by bestlover - 12 years ago
Cassie.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Shahisthi



To make Rishbala happen in the end, wouldn't the same Madhu who still thinks from her heart and who is compassionate enough to forgive is needed.


Otherwise forget it there won't be RISHBALA if she tries to act on her experiences all the time.

Because forgiving RK and loving him has been the biggest mistake she has done if we see the current situation she is in and if we just remember what happened a couple of days back in mandap, chawl and at RK mansion and even on the set.


So people who want Rishbala in the end, should we root Madhubala to change and think calculatively and take every step of her life?? Will there be Rishbala then??





That's what I wanted to convey Shahi. You said it better... 😊
Taiyo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

but what Madhu is doing is putting herself in RISK all over again..! She should have approached the law ..!

I have a problem with just that bit..!

And being Smart doesnt mean being Calculative. . .its called learning from experience. !!


Why will she go to the police now? It is neither the right time nor the right thing to do when her bond with the Don still has to be explored.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".