Episode Discussion: 26th Oct 2012 - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

263

Views

15.6k

Users

24

Likes

1.4k

Frequent Posters

0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#81
Hima,

Even if I try to relax around Madhu in the manner you want us, it still doesn't go down logically. Impalatable.

By your way of Madhu who sees good in people and does things as situation demands along with her ego in place...

1) Fine. She is thinking of guests and fine she is ordered by Dips to change the saree. I give her a point there as Madhu showed in her face that she was a tad reluctant to accept the saree. Only that the TIME-SENSITIVE MATTER made her remove her hesitation and accept her Bhabhi's word.
So what was weighing on her mind ...Oh! I ruined my Saasu ma's saree and now guests are coming ...what I am supposed to do. So sort of apprehensive mind ...upset at the mishap/Dips ordering + need to show up downstairs.

2) Then she changes. Her husband happens to see and instantaneous angry reaction. Madhu dear is INTELLIGENT enough to notice that. And SHREWD enough to jump at the opportunity to know why the saree affects hubby so much. There is a tad jealous reaction from her side. Madhu is not that innocent about her feelings for her hubby and what Dips was to him.
So what weighed on her mind ...Oh! why does it affect him so much ? Can't he ignore ? I need to go downstairs ...so sort of cranky mind ...upset in jealous feeling + need to show up downstairs.

3) Then she becomes adamant and argues. We are shown Madhu is actually sitting opposite RK and arguing. This is where the direction went wrong. The continuity from the above is lost. But then she becomes the screw-loose that she always is and especially when RK stands before her. She just needs to answer him back without weighing to what he is saying or what she is saying. Its sheer destiny and her fortune that somehow RK ends up having issues where she gets cankerous that he gets touched by her, and she makes a mark on his soul. If only that history with the saree was not there, RK would have handled her in a much more easier manner. But that's where my heart goes for him. The moment he stops giving reason, its already known to us that something deeply is affecting him and he hides it. And we know a time will come when he has to spit. Now its the story's requirement that Madhu has to be apparently idiotic for creating the rage, bad consequences and to get the secret out of the closet.

But seriously, is this the way the CVs will show a character growth in Madhu ...like zilch ??
In contrast, we have RK's growth when he says...Biwi mujhe lagaa tum mujhe jaanne lagi ho.
That just hurts. Did the CVs really mean it that way...for us to heart RK ? I don't know. But that contrast between RK and Madhu, clearly allows me to rant at her for her lack of depth.
For what is the fun if the characters cannot grow in each other's influence.

4) She then loses focus of her hurt...just argues and wants to go downstairs.

5) But in all of this...if she is jealous about his regard for Dips, then what about her regard for him ? And what about his regard for her too. He honored her with an answer. Right ? I don't like you in this saree. I don't like the color. So change. Its not that he is not capable of eyeing her. Won't you then as a person of better judgement save the curiosity in knowing the true answer for another day? You mean something to your husband and yet something about him bothers you...you can always talk later. So how does your ego get affected ? And how come he appears to you as showing Nakhre ? Which man would like his wife draped in a saree given by a woman he scorns. Doesn't he provide enough for his wife to have her own stuff ...they are so many intricacies here that Madhu fails to understand. If in Mukund's accident all she sought from RK was an apology to the victim's family, then how come that sense of courteous regard fails her. She just became obtuse selfish character who just wants her way of things with RK. Then my dear why did you allow Dips to cloud your judgement in the first place.

I am starting to think that RK has a certain electro-magnetic field around him that charges Madhu and she gets zapped of her original character. And that is another woe, as two days of romance don't make any sense with this explanation. 😕

6) On Monday, if they do not continue the conflict and do not resolve in a proper manner of denouement of the argument, all of the explanation that we are giving for Madhu's actions will be lost. And it will just come out as trash-bin episode.

hence I ranted today. Monday...I will see if Madhu can be attributed with any of the perception that I had for her when watching today's episode.

Edited by 0-SD-0 - 12 years ago
0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#82

Originally posted by: PreetD


@ice dagger - the whole thing is beyond ridiculous.. How in the world is that thing going to be of any use?
I'm going to go off topic a bit here and share a little story - I was watching with my mom last night and when he was making it my mom's reaction to the whole thing, why is he wasting the bottled water, he should've just used tap water... This just made me laugh. He wants RK to die but with a hygenic/clean ice dagger, he is afterall a superstar, only bottled water ice will do lol

@bold - I didn't even think about there being a possibility of some moments between them on Monday where she's getting changed. Perhaps this was a big elaborate way to set up another dori tying scene in which we have RK more comfortable helping his biwi out (this will be in contrast to the scene so we can see how their relationship has actually progressed). Excellent thinking Siri!!


Oh! finally I have Siri...coming with her ALREADY ! I am so relieved and happy.

And Preet, your MOM's reaction is RFOL !!!!!

And guys to disappoint both of you ...She is wearing the same blouse. Hence no ...dori-tying scene.


0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: applenpeaches

I agree. In protest I will be retreating from the forum at the end of this month..


hey Peach! come on. You should take that as a compliment. No crying. And no leaving. Pls...else you who is gonna cry buckets.

PreetD thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#84

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0


And guys to disappoint both of you ...She is wearing the same blouse. Hence no ...dori-tying scene.


Recycling the same blouse!?! That's a travesty! Preet is not impressed!
Siri22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#85
QUOTE=0-SD-0]

And guys to disappoint both of you ...She is wearing the same blouse. Hence no ...dori-tying scene.




@ bold - What the?


Edited by Siri22 - 12 years ago
Siri22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#86
@ Sri - Wow. brillaint analysis Sri. I have to read again to understand.

Will be back after a couple of hrs.

Just wanted to add looks like this is the norm.

Male lead's character is so well etched out ( I have noticed the same in IPK too) and cv's just play around with the female lead character just to fit in some clunky (in FQ's words) plot..

Not sure why.

Just to justify Malik's action madhu's character growth has been compromised.

I don't even care about the saree anymore.

I need a proper explanation for madhu's actions on Monday.
Edited by Siri22 - 12 years ago
PreetD thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#87

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0


Did the CVs really mean it that way...for us to heart RK ? I don't know. But that contrast between RK and Madhu, clearly allows me to rant at her for her lack of depth.
For what is the fun if the characters cannot grow in each other's influence.


@bold - Exactly!!! That was my biggest issue with today's episode. Although I have cooled a little bit from this morning, and reading's others responses has helped, I can't help but still be upset with the way they wrote Madhu today.

Perhaps it is like you said earlier, lazy writing for a Friday. Are they that comfortable in their rankings now that they think, Friday, KBC is on, they're going to get the ratings anyways so we'll just phone it in instead of putting some thought and effort behind it, we'll save that for another day.
Edited by PreetD - 12 years ago
PreetD thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#88

Originally posted by: Siri22

@ Sri - Wow. brillaint analysis Sri. I have to read again to understand.


Will be back after a couple of hrs.

Just wanted to add looks like this is the norm.

Male lead's character is so well etched out ( I have noticed the same in IPK too) and cv's just play around with the female lead character just to fit in some clunky (in FQ's words) plot..

Not sure why.

Just to justify Malik's action madhu's character growth has been compromised.

I don't even care about the saree anymore.

I need a proper explanation for madhu's actions on Monday.


@bold - I couldn't agree more Siri... I was hoping this show would be different, that Madhu's character wouldn't be comprimised, instead it would grow in a positive manner, but it doesn't look like that's happening. My biggest issue, they didn't have to comprimise her character at all, the desired results could have been achieved without that. I need Monday to be better than what we saw today. There needs to be some logical resolution to this ridiculousness.
Edited by PreetD - 12 years ago
zoya_naziya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#89

Originally posted by: PreetD


@bold - I don't think I could stomach any sort of romantical type scenes between those two, that little scene in the hospital alone had my stomach protesting! I would like to maybe hear about it, in not so much detail mind you, but not see it. And that too only so that Madhu can get an understanding of what happened and he can let go of it and we can finally move on.


@bold: 👍🏼 I just would not be able to tolerate any sort of a cheesy mushy romance of RK-Deepali... Wish RK just narrates in a few lines as to what sort of a lovey-dovey relationship they had
applenpeaches thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#90

Originally posted by: PreetD


Please don't threaten us like this! 😲

I'll take care of anyone you've got issues with 😉

@bold: Hey.. I wasnt threatening.. I was just making a statement.. 😊

@Blue: Thats very sweet of you Partner.. 😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".