Episode Discussion: 26th Oct 2012

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

zoya_naziya

@zoya_naziya

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#101

@Peach: I don't think Ballu will be re-intro'ed till madhu is on the verge of becoming a big shot in the industry..

@separation: By now the producers and the channel know that Rishbala scenes is what drives us... So even if there is separation, am sure they will just throw in atleast a few scenes together, otherwise the story would not move forward..

Quote

Siri22

@Siri22

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#102

@Sri - Regarding VD as RK. If it were not for him I wouldn't even given this show a second glance. DD fans may disagree but he's the soul of the show.

DD as Madhu is good I like her in some scenes for example hospital scene. But sometimes I feel she's too chirpy and sometimes too mature. I'm not sure I get her. VD has always been consistent. I haven't watched Geet so don't know if she's into Geet but will take your guys word for it.

Edited by Siri22 - 12 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

zoya_naziya

@zoya_naziya

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#103

Shri, very true about the creatives putting in an extra effort at the beginning to draw in viewers and then once the loyal viewership base is formed, they know they can become lax...

@VD:I really admire VD for the effort he puts in portraying his character and I can't imagine anyone else doing this role...He is bang on as RK the superstar in every scene and every dialogue...For me, this show has just been about RK... It was RK's character that attracted me to the show... No offence to DD/DD fans at all...

Haven't seen Geet so can't really say if DD is shuttling between Madhu and Geet... For me what she portrays is entirely Madhu(no baggage of Geet).. I always presumed her character to be the way she acts... her character can be shown as adamant and stubborn but seriously, I have always seen this nature of hers only with RK/ issues related to RK... Otherwise, she(Madhu's character) can be easily manipulated by anyone and everyone...

Edited by zoya_naziya - 12 years ago

Quote

Manonidz

@Manonidz

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#104

Just scanned last few pages ...I so agree with the apt explanation that Madhu was carried away the moment RK instructed her to change the saree without giving any reason except it was Dips Saree, which she knew pretty well. I disagree on what 0-SD-0 said about actors. Actors are puppets of directors, so they are tend to do what is being told to them. RK's character being of a superstar has a lot to do in terms of creative freedom, even from the side of actor too, but Madhu's character being at the centre stage and of a normal girl needs to be explored to the level that it pushes the story forward. I believe that once they will start with stardom track, they would have to add stary element in Madhu's personna too. As far as separation track goes, I kinda of feeling it to be forced at this stage since Shamsher being the attacker would be wide in open, so there is no point of putting any sort of misunderstanding bw RK and Madhu unless RK feels whatever Madhu did for him was out of guilt for Shamsher's act.

Edited by Manonids - 12 years ago

Quote

Shridevi Gaddam

@0-SD-0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#105

Originally posted by: zoya_naziya
Shri, very true about the creatives putting in an extra effort at the beginning to draw in viewers and then once the loyal viewership base is formed, they know they can become lax...

@VD:I really admire VD for the effort he puts in portraying his character and I can't imagine anyone else doing this role...He is bang on as RK the superstar in every scene and every dialogue...For me, this show has just been about RK... It was RK's character that attracted me to the show... No offence to DD/DD fans at all...

Haven't seen Geet so can't really say if DD is shuttling between Madhu and Geet... For me what she portrays is entirely Madhu(no baggage of Geet).. I always presumed her character to be the way she acts... her character can be shown as adamant and stubborn but seriously, I have always seen this nature of hers only with RK/ issues related to RK... Otherwise, she(Madhu's character) can be easily manipulated by anyone and everyone...

Zoya,

In Geet, Maan Singh Khurana was a tough guy like RK, the difference being Maan was INNOCENTLY ANGRY guy and an extremely tough to please boss who just wants to work without any fun. Geet with her soft nature and chirpy and playful attitude changes Maan into a character who learns to laugh. She is mature, intelligent and a very forgiving woman with zero adamance (does this word exit ...never mind😕) in her character which earns Maan's respect for her.

Here VD when he acts tough in the hospital and Madhu has to take care of him, DD slips into her role of Geet and takes the chirpy attitude. Madhu is not that chirpy as Geet. Madhu is shown serious types when dealing with family around her. Madhu here is adament and acts heroic unlike Geet, who is more down to earth.

Definitely Madhu has lot of grey character than Geet. And hence her chirpiness which brings out her innocence doesn't gel with me. Madhu seriously is not that innocent and willing to sacrifice herself as Geet would do...so I wish DD play Madhu differently from Geet and not muddle this character. RK is not looking for any good in Madhu. He is just looking for someone who is not like his mother and does not fall for his superstar status. And yet when Madhu gets affected by him, it is noticed by him. So just as RK should not go all mush. ...so does Madhu need to keep her seriousness in tact and not go chirpy. She can take care even without being chirpy like she was handling Shamsher and Trishna earlier.

And I haven't watched her taking care of Mukku..so don't how it went there. Her giving him a shave is as OTT as today when she refused to change the saree for RK. Extremes...and it creates doubt on her womanly instincts. Where does she get these wierd extreme ideas ? Atleast Padmini scolded her in case of Mukku. Even Mrs Dixit scolded her for getting so close to Mukku. Just that no one is scolding her when it comes to RK and how she should behave. Pathetic.

Now as I write all of this...I am tempted to blame the story writers. Seems they could not agree on what sort of character should be Madhu. And they might have left it purposefully unresolved so that they can change her character per the need of story...as RK is supposed to chart her destiny. In the story snapshot too...she is called mesmerizingly beautiful and nothing else ..

Edited by 0-SD-0 - 12 years ago

Quote

hansa22

@hansa22

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#106

OK, I don't know why I'm spending so much time analysing yesterday's episode. I think the episodes before had lulled us into a utopian Rishbala land. Which may or may not exist for the CV's!! Everybody is upset at being taken for a filler episode ride😡.

My last comment for the day hopefully, being that ...Madhu also got a bit irritated when RK told her the colour does not suit her...so there's ego as well.

Quote

zoya_naziya

@zoya_naziya

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#107

Have not seen too many Madhu-Mukund scenes but was she not chirpy even then?

And her character has to be left open as it has to be molded by RK... Remember the scene where RK actually does the pot-making thinking of Madhu..

Quote

Siri22

@Siri22

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#108

Madhu today failed to deliver IMO. I mean I never get irritated infact I love when she stands up to him. But today sth. was off. Can't put my finger on it.

Her rolling of eyes when he said change and her expressions when she said "If you don't like it then don't see me" was completely off putting.

I never disliked RK this much even on his worst days.

And like I said in my above post she's either too chirpy or too mature. I liked her in shirt change scene. He was calling her angrily but she didn't mind did she? She understood that he wants help but too proud to ask. I want to see that kind of portrayl of madhu.

Agree RK had no business yelling at her to change but he's always like that na. Not sure why she took offense. Instead of trying to understand him the minute he said change she crossed her arms in defiance and said she wouldn't. Where is the maturity here?

Ofcourse totally blame the writers and director.

I honestly don't like chirpy heroines. Talking all the time, pulling on pranks a big no no.Seriously I want women to be portrayed as mature,smart and strong.

Hopefully the cv's will redeem her on Monday.

A HOT eye lock would do for me.😊

Edited by Siri22 - 12 years ago

Quote

zoya_naziya

@zoya_naziya

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#109

Hurray!!! I think the new promo is out... Thankfully the Shamsher thing is going to be out... Am so waiting for it to get over and see how the separation is going to be played out and how the dynamics of Rishbala relationship gonna change..

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/madhubala-ek-ishq-ek-junoon/3259110/new-promo-rk-caught-shammu-red-handed

Edited by zoya_naziya - 12 years ago

Quote

Shridevi Gaddam

@0-SD-0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#110

Originally posted by: Soundarya22
OK, I don't know why I'm spending so much time analysing yesterday's episode. I think the episodes before had lulled us into a utopian Rishbala land. Which may or may not exist for the CV's!! Everybody is upset at being taken for a filler episode ride😡.

My last comment for the day hopefully, being that ...Madhu also got a bit irritated when RK told her the colour does not suit her...so there's ego as well.

Soundarya,

Me too thinking the same 😆

But I can't seem to stop myself as I find this company so interesting. 😛 And its Friday night for me. So its relaxing here ...

Originally posted by: zoya_naziya
Have not seen too many Madhu-Mukund scenes but was she not chirpy even then?

And her character has to be left open as it has to be molded by RK... Remember the scene where RK actually does the pot-making thinking of Madhu..

Zoya,

Remember the pot-making. 😆 Anyways I was always analysing RK as he interests me. But then what intrigues this man has to be given due attention. So I started to add life to Madhu. So can we call ..it the story of Pygmalion. Afterall Madhu is a reflection of RK. And one day RK is going to fall in love with what he found and what he created of her 🤣

Siri,

The last post. Agree word to word.

Zoya,

SD goes to look out for the promo (over the forum).

@ ALL

updated End of day discussion summary for the thread so far. Over page.

Edited by 0-SD-0 - 12 years ago