Shaimak changes Last week winners... - Page 3

Originally posted by: bandicoot

actually my favorite part in this mess is mayuresh maintaining his composure..

neither did he look heartbroken/depressed/angry last week nor did he look too excited(jumpy, in-ur-face laughing) today...he is a nice guy genuinely

So that means.. Shamak could admit his mistake but remo cant??? if I am not wrong..remo and Shamak had given the marks similarly..and felt similar..and now when Shamak the contempropary expert is changing remo isnt??? as he doestn want to go back to his words??? hmm

Originally posted by: jeffmish

One thing.

Last weeks scores were Josh-137 and Jalwa-138.

This time when Shiamak changed the scores for both Punit(-1) and Mayuresh(+1), the scores for last week should have been:

Josh- 137+1=138

Jalwa- 138-1=137.

Now how was it that both teams were tied?

Originally posted by: bhoomikauttam

So that means.. Shamak could admit his mistake but remo cant??? if I am not wrong..remo and Shamak had given the marks similarly..and felt similar..and now when Shamak the contempropary expert is changing remo isnt??? as he doestn want to go back to his words??? hmm

i respect shiamak for doin dis but i think its unfair to change da marks post da particular competition. i mean umpires make hell of mistakes but dat doesn't mean da batsmen get a life line when they walk to bat da next time...

Originally posted by: pigbelly4myfeet

Word. That was the best part for me too. I have so much respect for Mayuresh. Ever since his elimination in DID 1. The way he showed maturity and composure in this situation was really touching. He really is a genuinely nice guy. 😊

I honestly don't get how people are calling Shiamak unprofessional for this decision. 😕 Unprofessional was what he did last week. Completely ignoring SUCH a huge blunder from Punit's side. But he seemed really genuine with his intentions in this episode, so I have respect for him for owning up to his mistake.

This isn't some intense competition that changing these scores will affect these dancer's careers or anything like that! It's a pretty low key, transitory show. Shiamak's decision showed that he had respect for Mayuresh as a dancer. It showed respect for Punit as well actually. Because it would be unfair to Punit as well if he scored higher when he didn't really deserve it. And Mayuresh too, reciprocated that respect.

It was a genuine and humbling moment between Shiamak and Mayuresh especially. I was touched. :)

Agree with both of you...Loved how Mayuresh handled it...this guy is so mature...he neither made a big deal out of not getting deserving higher scores last week and even this week when the score was corrected.

What I don't get is why STILL no one is mentioning that Punit FORGOT a whole 30 seconds of choreography due to which the sync in the last part of the takkar totally went off...did Punit himself make any mention of that even now when Shiamak changed the score?😕

And Remo had nothing to say on this?? How come?😆 I mean he doesn't need to change his scores but I would have liked to hear his thoughts on the fact that now it's proven that Mayuresh was better in that takkar.

I was thinking throughout this entire time that oh god now how is punit going to react cuz i always liked mayuresh even though im supporting jalwa but i never really liked punit. I now have respect for punit for admitting his mistake and praising the judges who took his points away! JALWA!!!!!

But where exactly did Punit admit his mistake??? Yes he praised the judges a lot for the next 10 minutes after Shiamak changed the score...lol...but I don't recall him owning up to the fact that he forgot so much choreography in the takkar...or did I miss something?


I still remember in DID-2 when Parvez cried because he felt Jack was much more deserving than him to make it to the finals...and in DID-1 during Mayuresh's eliminations when he said that Jai deserved to stay on much more than him...these are two ppl who showed true humbleness I feel.

2 normal people like that is people that watch 4 entertainment i wudnt hav known punit missed a part as 2me he didnt show it,and that is a sign of a gud dancer,mistakes happen while danceing its how the dancers carry themselves through that performance counts.

Everbody has different opinions. To each their own. In the footage that they showed today Remo Sir said that he didnt change the score because he judges creativity over technicality, and he thought Punit was creative while mayuresh was more technical. Thats all right on my part because that is his personal opinion. However, I really wish he would have mentioned the fact that Punit forgot a step after which the rest of his choreography went off beat. I dont think that had anything to do with creativity or technicality. Everybody noticed it but even up till now non of the judges or punit himself have admitted to it.