Discuss: Is lrl right?????????

amail1601 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

As we all know, Rajveer's character is coming to an end, and it is reported that he's not going to have the ending we expected him to have..So basically, that means that most probably Raj will not be able to fulfill his promise to Naina, and that will be because the system which Raj trusted so much failed to give justice.

This brings us to the main point of this discussion..."Is the portrayal of the Army in lrl justified, and should Rajveer be killed???"

See, the Army academy, KMA has been shown as a place where cadets enjoy themselves all the time...no drills, no studies...they just roam around(wearing sarees at their will!!!!!!!!!!!!), party, and basically, KMA has been portrayed as a dating-service provider cum marraige bureau cum party hall cum a hostel for college students...

Faculty n students break rules alike.

An officer who is working against the country is suspended at the whim of the students(I mean without investigation), and then made the Principal..Ok, so maybe it was Gehlot's working, but still, kisi ne bhi notice nahin kiya??????????

Similarly, Ritu ka bhi background check nahin kiya..Psychologists ya counsellors ka b/g check to sabse zyaada important hota hai..

Baaki sab chhodo, lekin agar Raj ko apne mission mein fail hote hue dikhaaya then it would mean ki Army aisi hai ki kisi ke bhi efforts se kuch bhi change nahin aa sakta...It would mean ki system bas fail ho gaya..

Is this what should be shown?????????? Especially at a time like now jab Army se related sab log demoralised hain..roz Army related suicides ki itni news aati hai...

Shouldn't someone protest at what misleading things Djs are showing??????

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.4k

Users

11

Likes

4

Frequent Posters

SecretKhabri420 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Ammu, u r right, I too think that DJ made the academy to lovers point insted of showing some army life style, etc....
Edited by farislove - 18 years ago
amail1601 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Thanks for agreeing di, and a greater thanks for replying 😉 .. 😊

I hope no one found this topic offensive..


-skylark- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
jo dikhaya jaraha hai wo ghalat hai...main jab bhi lrl dekhti hun koshish karti hun ki bhul jaon ki ye army show hai....army ppl ki life bahut tough hoti hai..
raj ka exit itna kharab hoga ye mainne socha nahi tha..
😭
anujkpjk thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
what i don't like abt lrl is
too many love angles. only rn need to be shown as both have a common link naveen. and ofcourse the relnship that raj and naina have is interesting.
secondly rajveer character was very strong - i think it would have been good if he had solved the naveen mystery. but for that raj has to stay longer in the serial but he's left - so that means his character thought strong at the beginning was a failure in the end. i don't like it b'coz this was not the way i wanted his character to end. plus the rn love track is a big question mark.
thirdly no proper army training is shown. the cadets have not improved in any way. they r still acting childish and immature for their age.
and lastly abhi's character has still not shaped up which leaves everyone wondering what exactly he's upto.
i think when raj announced his exit the dj's did not know how to end his character so they goofed up.
and as far as the naveen mystery is concerned it is very complicated and lot of people are involved in it and as i said earlier it is still too early to solve it completely. it did drag for a year but slowly it has gained pace. i think it is naina alone who can solve it as it was her sole and own mission. but how her life is going to be after raj's exit is again one big question mark. her character is shown to be strong , focussed and independent last thing i want is to again link her up with that huda or abhi. it will ruin her character.
i want her to prove herself as an army officer rather than being shown as a helpless girl who can't even think for herself or getting into silly love angles.
i had high hopes for rn but it seems the dj's have taken us for a roller coaster ride. why did they show the rn love angle if there was no proper ending to it?
also the cadets r in their second year and it is useless to drag the serial for another three years.
the best possible soln was to show the cadets being trained to become good soldiers under the guidance of raj and then wind up the serial in a few months. maybe then raj would have stayed back and solved the naveen mystery too.
friskysam thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
LRL is afterall a fictional story,we cant expect it to be real .
Aur serial main sab kuch hota hai aaj kal 😆 ........i think we shld see serials like we see a david dhawan movie-forgot abt ur brains n just see the serila/film for time pass 😆 😆

and ammu,after a long while i have seen u posting something.kya hai jee 😉 😆 .Regularly aaya karo 😳
aarsow thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: anujkpjk

what i don't like abt lrl is
too many love angles. only rn need to be shown as both have a common link naveen. and ofcourse the relnship that raj and naina have is interesting.
secondly rajveer character was very strong - i think it would have been good if he had solved the naveen mystery. but for that raj has to stay longer in the serial but he's left - so that means his character thought strong at the beginning was a failure in the end. i don't like it b'coz this was not the way i wanted his character to end. plus the rn love track is a big question mark.
thirdly no proper army training is shown. the cadets have not improved in any way. they r still acting childish and immature for their age.
and lastly abhi's character has still not shaped up which leaves everyone wondering what exactly he's upto.
i think when raj announced his exit the dj's did not know how to end his character so they goofed up.
and as far as the naveen mystery is concerned it is very complicated and lot of people are involved in it and as i said earlier it is still too early to solve it completely. it did drag for a year but slowly it has gained pace. i think it is naina alone who can solve it as it was her sole and own mission. but how her life is going to be after raj's exit is again one big question mark. her character is shown to be strong , focussed and independent last thing i want is to again link her up with that huda or abhi. it will ruin her character.
i want her to prove herself as an army officer rather than being shown as a helpless girl who can't even think for herself or getting into silly love angles.
i had high hopes for rn but it seems the dj's have taken us for a roller coaster ride. why did they show the rn love angle if there was no proper ending to it?
also the cadets r in their second year and it is useless to drag the serial for another three years.
the best possible soln was to show the cadets being trained to become good soldiers under the guidance of raj and then wind up the serial in a few months. maybe then raj would have stayed back and solved the naveen mystery too.

u'r 100% rite,

thz wat even i need 2say,

Aarthi

lrllover thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
although i am a rajeev fan i think that i am the first person who dont seem to agree with this topic simply because we all knew that it is not a real academy moreover just because rajeev is leaving the show has made most of his fans behave in such a way but most of us were not complaining when all thosse romance scenes between various cadets and rajveer naina were shown the fresher ball episodes moreover i think no one would have complained if raj naina love angle would have continued just because rajeev is leaving the show doesnt mean that we will say that pull off the serial infact it is the right of the actor to leave the serial and it is also the right of the producer to change the plot according to thei choice just because rajveer will not be able to solve navins case(which i hope he does)does not men that the show must go off air.... this serial has other actors also (although none can match rajeevs standard right now) but it would be a great injustice to them if the serial is forced to finish just because rajeev is leaving because if this is the case then no actor would like to work with rajeev thinking the serial will go off air once rajeev chooses to leave the show
anujkpjk thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: lrllover

although i am a rajeev fan i think that i am the first person who dont seem to agree with this topic simply because we all knew that it is not a real academy moreover just because rajeev is leaving the show has made most of his fans behave in such a way but most of us were not complaining when all thosse romance scenes between various cadets and rajveer naina were shown the fresher ball episodes moreover i think no one would have complained if raj naina love angle would have continued just because rajeev is leaving the show doesnt mean that we will say that pull off the serial infact it is the right of the actor to leave the serial and it is also the right of the producer to change the plot according to thei choice just because rajveer will not be able to solve navins case(which i hope he does)does not men that the show must go off air.... this serial has other actors also (although none can match rajeevs standard right now) but it would be a great injustice to them if the serial is forced to finish just because rajeev is leaving because if this is the case then no actor would like to work with rajeev thinking the serial will go off air once rajeev chooses to leave the show

agree wid u. the show need not be taken off air as raj is leaving. according to the serial the cadets training duration is of two years. so the show can continue for another year or so. but one of the major reasons for the success of this show was undoubtedly rajeev khandelwal as he carried the show on his shoulders. the trp's might go down for a few days in his absence. but i will still watch lrl for gaurav. but will gaurav as abhi and the rest of the cadets who have been overshadowed by raj's presence be able to pull it off successfully is the big question. i think they can - as all of them r talented actors. all they need is a good storyline. this show is based on the training of cadets who become army officer and it is better if they r shown in their second year so than they can complete their course by next july. varna if they keep dragging the serial unnecessarily then the cadets will never pass out of the academy. woh 50 saal ke buddhe ho jayenge aur phir bhi cadets hi rahenge😆

i think the show should end in another one year. once the naveen mystery is solved all that is left is the cadets' training !!

Life_Is_Dutiful thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: amail1601

As we all know, Rajveer's character is coming to an end, and it is reported that he's not going to have the ending we expected him to have..So basically, that means that most probably Raj will not be able to fulfill his promise to Naina, and that will be because the system which Raj trusted so much failed to give justice.

This brings us to the main point of this discussion..."Is the portrayal of the Army in lrl justified, and should Rajveer be killed???"

Amail,the story is fictional.There is nothing which is called real.Actually,serial ko hatke banane ke liye army ko le aaye varna aisa kuch bhi nahi ho raha hai jo real army school mein hota hai. Aur aisa pssible bhi nahi hai b'coz as rajeev had said in one of his interviews that it's impossible to show the actual army training in a serial.But at least they r trying 2 some extent.

See, the Army academy, KMA has been shown as a place where cadets enjoy themselves all the time...no drills, no studies...they just roam around(wearing sarees at their will!!!!!!!!!!!!), party, and basically, KMA has been portrayed as a dating-service provider cum marraige bureau cum party hall cum a hostel for college students...

I agree with u & by showing this,the makers r proving that it is fictional.😆

Faculty n students break rules alike.

An officer who is working against the country is suspended at the whim of the students(I mean without investigation), and then made the Principal..Ok, so maybe it was Gehlot's working, but still, kisi ne bhi notice nahin kiya??????????

Similarly, Ritu ka bhi background check nahin kiya..Psychologists ya counsellors ka b/g check to sabse zyaada important hota hai..

In sabke peeche senior officer yani Gehlot ka haath hai.Jab senior officer hi sabse bada spy ho😡 aur uske baare mein abhi tak koi jaan nahi paaya to ritu aur nair ke baare mein koi kaise jaan payega.Even raj & abhi hv still not doubted gehlot.

Baaki sab chhodo, lekin agar Raj ko apne mission mein fail hote hue dikhaaya then it would mean ki Army aisi hai ki kisi ke bhi efforts se kuch bhi change nahin aa sakta...It would mean ki system bas fail ho gaya..

I think we should be optimistic regarding this.Raj ki mehnat rang zaroor layegi.

Abhi nahi,baad mein hi sahi.

Is this what should be shown?????????? Especially at a time like now jab Army se related sab log demoralised hain..roz Army related suicides ki itni news aati hai...

This should be not shown at all b'coz it will hv a bad effect on viewer's minds specially youth.They will hv a wrong impression abt the army.

Shouldn't someone protest at what misleading things Djs are showing??????

Definitely.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".