Originally posted by: amail1601
Ok..so we have some people who agree, n some who disagree..
The point I want to raise is, ok, it's a fictional story...but still, if they are using the Army's name, they should try to show it in a more positive light.
The issue here is not RN...the issue is whether Raj's failure is justified or not..
I admit that in real life many try n fail, but here we are talking about the impression given out to the general public.
The public does not dissect things like we lrlfians do..they accept whatever is shown at face value. If Raj fails, it will simply mean that the system, and the justice he trusted so much failed..
Is this the thing we want to tell people at a time when public confidence is already low????
Lrl is depicting the Army as a weak entity with flaws galore...In real life everything has flaws, but not like this..
Someone asked why they showed RN if it wasn't to be..I guess that's because you don't get everything in life.. Agar sab kuch mil gaya, to phir life thodi na hui..
I agree that now Naina should be shown as a stronger personality, who's not dependent on Abhi or Huda..
It's time for the cadets to grow up too..
Keep up the discussion...It's going well!!!
ofcourse raj's failure is not justified. but if he needs justice then we need more of capt. rajveer which of course was not possible. like i said dj's have goofed up raj's exit. if this was the way it was supposed to end they could have finished his role long back rather than showing him as a victim of a corrupt system
but we must also not forget that naveen was the best officer in the academy and extremely intelligent guy. he nearly got to the traitors but was trapped. compared to raj's trial naveen's trial was long and even after four years nothing has been done yet to prove him innocent.
raj's end has to be justified but for that naveen's mystery has to be solved first because only then the real culprits will be caught and then only every one will know that these same guys trapped raj also. but that won't be for a long time i guess. the mystery of the redbox will go on and on till god knows when. raj had a chance to see its contents but asusual the dj's changed the plot and redbox and its contents went missing. because if naveen mystery is solved toh serial mein bachega kya?
all i wish that raj had never been dragged into this red box problem. his end is not logical, not happy, not justifed - the whole thing is a big disappointment.
as far as the real Army life is concerned - there is no question of justice. even the slightest mistake or accident though unintentional makes the officer liable for suspension. there is no room for long unnecessary trials.
i am saying this because my cousin was an officer in the army. he accidentally fired a shot while cleaning his own rifle. the bullet got wedged in his leg. the army suspended him on the grounds that the bullet could have hit somebody. the poor guy tried for justice but no was the firm answer given to him. it became a black mark on his career and it was a very long time before he got another job to support himself and his family.
Edited by anujkpjk - 18 years ago