Discussion: Naina....Right or Wrong?????? - Page 4

thanka ..amail.. for allowing me to say my view.

although i totaly agree with ur views regarding wwhat naina did was wrong but still at one point i feel that whatever she did was quite expected by the character she is playing....i mean that since day one of this show , everything & every act of her directly or indirectly relates to her love for her brother. she didn;t jion KMA cuz of her love for her c**try...the main reason was her love for her brother..

Originally posted by: scorpiongal

thanka ..amail.. for allowing me to say my view.

although i totaly agree with ur views regarding wwhat naina did was wrong but still at one point i feel that whatever she did was quite expected by the character she is playing....i mean that since day one of this show , everything & every act of her directly or indirectly relates to her love for her brother. she didn;t jion KMA cuz of her love for her c**try...the main reason was her love for her brother..

No need to thank me dear...the forum is for discussion only.......😊

I agree with your view, but don't you think that when a person has been so close to someone for such a long time, and knows the truth, the true conditions, he/she should be a bit more humane????????? Even if it's a stranger, humanity is expected.....

You can't take the law into your own hands, no matter what the provocation...I think that this is what the whole situation is about!!!!!!!!

What do you think???????? (I am addressing everyone out here..😊)

as i said earlier that i too find her wrong & no doubt , anybody can't take law in his hands ...but all these r the practical views abt the situation.

whatever naina did was just far away from the limits of thoughts & judgments as she was completely completely ran by her emotions..which made her totally out of her sense to differentiate between right or wrong....
i m not defending her but just want to say that it happens with all of us that sometimes we do things which we've never thought as possibility..but our impulsive or our immense attachments to a thing puts us there..😊

Originally posted by: scorpiongal

as i said earlier that i too find her wrong & no doubt , anybody can't take law in his hands ...but all these r the practical views abt the situation.

whatever naina did was just far away from the limits of thoughts & judgments as she was completely completely ran by her emotions..which made her totally out of her sense to differentiate between right or wrong....
i m not defending her but just want to say that it happens with all of us that sometimes we do things which we've never thought as possibility..but our impulsive or our immense attachments to a thing puts us there..😊

👏 good point ... i agree completely with you that considering that naina has been impulsive and obsessed with her brother's death from day one ... her actions can be justified ... but as you said ... they were wrong ...

the way i see it (and correct me if i'm wrong but i think you see it this way too) is that what naina did was wrong ... but she's done things that were wrong (although not as much as this) before ... we've seen that with her impulsive nature she's gone against rajveer's advice a thousand times and gotten herself into sticky situations ... dj's has done a great job in showing how her impulsiveness has reached a new height here ...

now, ammu you brought up the point about taking the law into your hands ... but isn't naina "punishing" raj for taking the law into his hands? ... i know that there are other ways of going about this and i would never endorse her actions ... but i can see where they'd come from ...

i also have to say that i don't think naina was thinking of anything (humanity/inhumanity) at that particular time - she was acting on impulse .... however ... the fact that she is continuing with her attitude is upsetting me ... her attitude towards rajveer (and huda - who knows nothing about her situation yet is also on the receiving end of her tirade) is where i agree with you ammu ... she should have some humanity ... if not for the person who helped her (because as i said before ... that was probably out of his own guilt ... and naina may be thinking the same thing) but at least for the man who can help you save the country

Guys, I think you are right about the other points,but as Tashu said that Naina is punishing Raj for taking the law into his hands, tell me, is Naina a police officer??? Is she a judge???????? Who is she to punish anyone??????
Agreed that her brother is involved here, but it all comes down to ethics only....Who is she to decide what is right and what is wrong???????

Originally posted by: amail1601

Guys, I think you are right about the other points,but as Tashu said that Naina is punishing Raj for taking the law into his hands, tell me, is Naina a police officer??? Is she a judge???????? Who is she to punish anyone??????
Agreed that her brother is involved here, but it all comes down to ethics only....Who is she to decide what is right and what is wrong???????

she isn't anyone to decide anything ... what i meant was that in her mind and from her perspective she probably feels that she's punishing him for taking the law into his hands .... that's why i said that i would not condone her actions ... but i wouldn't condemn her either ....... you're absolutely right ammu she is no one to decide right from wrong ... but then she wasn't in the right frame of mind then even if she tried to figure out right from wrong ..... however .... the fact that she is showing no remorse for shooting another human being is what is making me want to reprehend her😡😃

navy1985 wrote:
i also have to say that i don't think naina was thinking of anything (humanity/inhumanity) at that particular time - she was acting on impulse .... however ... the fact that she is continuing with her attitude is upsetting me ... her attitude towards rajveer (and huda - who knows nothing about her situation yet is also on the receiving end of her tirade)

thanks tashu for lifting my spirits ..i really needed as i m new here...😊😊
i agree, naina's attitude is upsetting ...it's neither ethical nor rational..

Exactly Tashu.....The fact that she is not showing any remorse is what is upsetting us all..........

I'll compile the points so far:
1. What Naina did was unethical...
2. She took the law into her own hands...
3. She was in a highly emotional state, and quite upset that the person whom she had trusted so much was her brother's killer...
4. What she did was inhumane.....
5. Naina is a super-hyper, impulsive girl, who needs to tone down....
6. Naina's lack of remorse is the crucial factor here....
7. Ritu was right in assuming that Naina is likely to destroy all the people around her..
8. Most of us are very upset(an understatement!!!!) with Naina, speciaaly because of the way she kicked Raj..... 😉


Any other views anyone?????????????? 😊 Forgive me, and do tell if I have forgotten any point.........
😊

well...I tried imagining myself in her position...
and if I was in her position,the moment I came to know that raj shot naveen I wud've tried to strangle him...
I wud have thot-'maybe if raj hadn't shot naveen,he cud have gone into hiding and I cud look for evidence that naveen isn't a traitor...'
I know that's silly but can you explain that to a sister's heart? never....
even tho I wud know that raj only killed naveen because he begged him too,I wudn't be able to forgive him easily... because it's not about using ur brains,or being smart enuf, in a situation like dat I dont think my brain wud work....
I think what she did was wrong...but any person who wudn't do what naina did wud be using their brains..something that some people forget to use in a situation like dis....naina and I(most probably) are some of those people....
and to tell the truth,for me my family cums before my country...if I came to know that my mentor whom I trusted the most killed my brother(even tho it was mercy-killing) I wud think-'bhaad main jaaye nuclear triggers'....(yeah,I'm selfish)

well,every person has a opinion and this is mine...hope I dint offend anyone in any way....I was just being honest.

😊

No dear, you didn't offend anyone...we are here to share our views...Thank you for being so honest...


Now we have another viewpoint also... 😊