Discussion: Naina....Right or Wrong?????? - Page 2

i think wat naina did waz rong
& there waz no need 2 shoot rajveer ( or kick him)esp coz he had alwayz helped her
& naveen waz da 1 who waz pleadin wth rajveer 2 shoot him

Nice topic ammu dear.. 👏
well being unbiased.. I still feel her reaction was wrong... 😡 😭
Rajveer had clearly mentioned dat naveen wanted him2 kill.. whereas rajveer nvr intended 2 do soo..
she let her hatred overpower her emotions and feelings 4 the nation... she wants 2 be a best cadet in such circumstances is it..???? 😭
I dnt think her actions are justified anyways...
she tells rajveer that once she finishes the task of saving the triggers she wud kill rajveer herself..
Thats soo mean.. 😭

Nice topic.. 😊

naina was wrong..completely wrong.But sometimes in our life v make immature decisions right??so naina made one and for the first time she seemed to me like a normal human who makes mistakes..she failed in her test for recognising the right and wrong..no doubt..she shot rajveer instead of getting back at ritu..she is just a first year cadet but considering that she is shown to be so mature and brave she shud have not shot rajveer and then kicked him.. 😡

so in short,what naina did was wrong but it wasnt disgusting or nethng like that..she is a human with feelings.every human has a reaction for a particular situation so this was hers..

tata
tc
dhwani 😊 😊

well she is not going to gain anything by killing raj
she will be courtmartialled if she does and suspended. thereby hurting her parents. think wisely naina. u r not a kid anymore. grow up. if u want to be best cadet stop acting dumb, stupid and immature put the past behind u and move on in life. anyways she will never prove her bro's innocence without raj's help.

nice topic 👏 👏

naina was compl. wrong 😡 😡 ...how can she blame raj fr everythng n shoot him.....its naveen dumbo who forced raj to shoot him then how cum its raj's fault ...he wanted to sve hm but navin himslef wnted to die...aur ye naina she is just irritating me...how cn she even thnk of like this....tape ko properly suna kyun nahi....n she totally forgot the help that rajveer did to her..itni bi courtesy nahihai ise...bng known rajveer so deeply she did lke this what kinda grl is she.....aur rahi baat soldier then she wn't n cn't becum a good soldier....she hlpd ritu to escape frm the spot alongwth triggers....isme deshbhakti to kahinparbi nazarnahiaati....

man i wnna kll her

Originally posted by: angelic eyes

Nice topic ammu dear.. 👏
well being unbiased.. I still feel her reaction was wrong... 😡 😭
Rajveer had clearly mentioned dat naveen wanted him2 kill.. whereas rajveer nvr intended 2 do soo..
she let her hatred overpower her emotions and feelings 4 the nation... she wants 2 be a best cadet in such circumstances is it..???? 😭
I dnt think her actions are justified anyways...
she tells rajveer that once she finishes the task of saving the triggers she wud kill rajveer herself..
Thats soo mean.. 😭

It was Saara di who suggested it............😊

My god!!!!!!!!!!! Everyone seems to have such strong feelings about this!!!!!!!!!
What do you think that Naina should do now????? Besides the obvious that is....
How should she go about putting it right???????

What Naina did was absolutely wrong. She should have listened to Rajveer. He said in the end the country should win and not a traitor.One who has come to a military academy to get training to become a soldier cannot do such an act. It is sending a bad signal.Poor Rajveer

well firstly, thanks for bringing this up ammu and saara 😊

okay .... as far as naina being right or wrong ... this is a really hard decision to make ...

- if we say she is wrong ... then we must also agree that rajveer was wrong in shooting navin (i'm sorry i love him too so don't take my view personally ... i'm just trying to rationalize all of this) ... there are other ways that each could've handled their respective situations (i'm not going to get into that right now ... i'll discuss it at the end) ...

- if we say she is right ... then what about the things that her brother said to her about the country coming before yourself ... but we also can't say that she purposely put her country at risk (although she did put it at risk) as she was not aware that the truck had the nuclear triggers in it ... correct me if i'm wrong but rajveer only gives her the "vasta" of the country by telling her that ritu is a spy before naina shoots ...

- now, the interesting thing to consider is the fact that we as an audience and naina are both confused about what aspect of her mission is important to her ... when she came to the academy her mission was to find the people who had falsely declared her brother a traitor ... we now know that the person was ritu as her testimony decided his fate at his trial ... her mission was to find the people who compelled her brother to shoot himself ... if you ignore whose hands the gun was in ... we can say that the person who made him out to be a traitor is the person who is responsible for navin's death ... hence again ... ritu is the culprit here ...

- naina shot rajveer ... and in doing so ... she reasons that she shot him because he shot her brother ... well when she thought that her brother had committed suicide she only wanted to punish the person who compelled him to do so ... technically you could argue that raj did not shoot navin ... he assisted him in suicide ... navin wanted to die ... if she wanted to punish the person who was behind the conspiracy against her brother ... she should have shot ritu ...

- alright, now that my circular reasoning has confused you all, i'll give my opinion:

- naina was wrong in shooting rajveer ... AND so was rajveer in shooting navin ... BUT two wrongs do not make a right ... however i can accept the story this way ... we've always seen naina as an impulsive person ... and in the state of mind that she was in when rajveer told her the truth, her character traits justify her actions ... during her trial maj bhargav accused her of being calculating ... i disagree ... a truly calculating person would have shot ritu in the leg ... gotten the necessary information out of her ... and then maybe took a shot at rajveer ... but she put her own safety into jeopardy by shooting rajveer

- now as far as figuring out how the story should go and how these two wrongs can be corrected ...

- i think that dj's is trying to show us that there are often things that happen between two people that just cannot be resolved ... i really think that this is why rajveer and naina's jodi breaking is right ... we can't expect her to easily forgive the man who shot her brother (no matter what the circumstances were and no matter how sweet the man is😳) ... in real life there aren't always happy endings ... at the same time ... we also shouldn't expect rajveer to be with the person who reminds him of his guilt ... i agree that he loves her ... but honestly i think that his love is based around his guilt for what he did to her brother ... as he said part of him wants to save her so that he can lessen the guilt he feels for not being able to save navin ... maybe the entry of his ex will help him realize whether or not her truly loves naina or he just wants to be the hero to her damsel in distress

okay wow that was long ... sorry 😳 ... and once again ... please don't take my words the wrong way ... i'm only trying to rationalize why this story is correct ... honestly i would have loved to see the r-n love story blossom ... but that isn't realistic ... i know someone will argue that tv doesn't need to be real ... but even keeping reality aside, this new twist is justified by their character traits ... it isn't just some random googly

She is completely wrong!!!! she isnt a kid... mana k academy k first year main hay... pr achi khaasii sensibility ajati hai yaar.... she helped the spy...!!! chalo raj ko shot kar k.... ritu ko pakarnay ki try hi karletii... bt no..... she let her go!!! or rahi baat raj ko marnay ki..... how could it be justified?.... raaj ki hii waja say naina aj academy main hai....how many times he helpd her... didnt she know?
naina to apnay ghr b jachukii t... or wapis anay ko tayar b nhi t.... tab b raaj ki hi koshishon say wapis ayi.... tb kahan thaa bhai ka pyar???? or ik chotiiiiiiiiiiii si baat uski samaj main nhi ayii k.... naveen ko marnaa raj ki intention nahin thi... naven nayusay force kiyaa thaa.... agr intention hoti to wo khud batata naina ko k maiany naveen ko shot kiyaa!!!!
😕