Too much Too soon? - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

88

Views

7.9k

Users

29

Likes

306

Frequent Posters

rpmenon thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: Armu4eva


totally agree.. i cant find any reason.. which even remotely indicates as to why he is called 'Dr. Hardstone' 😕


That name was coined when the show started.With the original script,before the change in script.They had plans to show a serious Ashutosh,probably.Hence the name Hardstone.But then they changed everything and now the name doesn't sound so apt.
rpmenon thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: vaishalini



The jokes that Dr. A cracks or laughs at are just so silly. Dr. Irfan's jokes were awesome. I dont understand much urdu but it was so funny.
Dont see any of it in KTLH. They have matched the motuness of Solanki to Daddy, wit of babas and loudness of dadi bua & faseelat.


I am replying tonight.I am so nostalgic now!! 😊
ozone1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#63
great constructive criticism going on...

read some of the thoughts... some made sense.. some could not gel with...

DK was original which was coined as classic. original has no SET RULES to go by..so EVEN if it had missed on it's story telling we accepted it. .Where as KTLK is ADAPTION not a REMAKE... it has previlege to experiment with it's character. lot had to say about kk's character. how Nidhi is not Zoya. Nidhi belongs to Generation Y. youth of today is more vibrant, outgoing, independent and OF COURSE more confused when it comes to LOVE AND CAREER. And why do we have to stereotype a profession can't a doctor be goofy or exuberant like Nidhi?? about not being a responsible intern..she had been irresponsible only one time...she has best bedside manner (which many doc. miss in real life), sharp on diagnosis.and she Challenges egoistic seniors does not make her a bad doctor.
IF DK was stretched to 200+ episodes we would have found some LOOP HOLES too. it's a challenge to hold on to a story and characters beyond 100 episodes...

Look at brighter side of KTLK, we got some mind blowing bonding anji-nidhi, anji's mom- nidhi.rangnath is better, so is mallika, more romance and passion, KK is holding good, and of course

Icing on the cake MR. MB...undisputedly the best. (Sorry dr. Ahmer u can take 2nd spot). and KK-MB chemistry..a visual treat.

despite of flaws (marriage track, , shenshah) i am enjoying the show. i am more open to changes as long as they not irrelevant or too crazy.

Edited by soccer - 13 years ago
Siddu246 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#64
I don't want to compare this show to DK..I think that is a classic on its own..I did feel this show made a place for itself along the way.But Yes I do agree with you 100% that they have lost the story some where along the way...everything happened way too fast. I know most people are enjoying it..don't get me wrong so am I..But it really does bother me that we never really saw them falling for each other especially considering this was suppose to be a different love story. Where are the moments between them in the hospital? Dr. Nidhi was there for barley 3 days. They hardly had any interaction with each other. Weren't we suppose to see a more strict and headstrong Dr.Ashutosh?? I mean he has already melted towards her.😕..This all would have been more believable if they had shown interactions between them during the hospital.

Also I really don't like the fact that Dr.Nihdi has joined the hospital because of Dr.Ashutosh...A profession like this you are there for others not for your own self. I was highly disappointed to see that they made her go back to this profession because of to see if she loves Dr.A or not. This show is much more then about the love story between Dr.A and Dr.N...Anyways I don't think much can be redeemed now so I will enjoy whatever I get because I think MB is just fabulous...I love him in this and this show has made me in to a Krithika fan. I never use to think anything of her before but this role has given her a chance to grow as an actress.
It is a overall nice show if you don't think too much about it and I guess go with the flow...😊
Edited by Siddu246 - 13 years ago
lidvin thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: Siddu246

I think MB is just fabulous...I love him in this and this show has made me in to a Krithika fan. I never use to think anything of her before but this role has given her a chance to grow as an actress. It is a overall nice show if you don't think too much about it and I guess go with the flow...😊



me too both are fabulous infact everyone is good. just go with the flow and you will enjoy the show to the core. A big thanks to Mr.Rajan for giving a wonderful show, myself i am loving it.
rpmenon thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#66
Well,I watched the Friday's episode and I have this sinking feeling that I might not watch this longer with the same enthusiasm. Absolutely didn't like the way Nidhi reacted through out the episode.I can relate to Ashutosh,but not Nidhi.I am forced to dislike her character day by day.If I write too much abt what I disliked abt her in last episode,I will get many jhoothas.So,I will just keep quiet,and let you guys enjoy the show. 😆
Infofan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: rpmenon

Hi there,wonderful people. 😊


I know most of us are just loving this show,me too.But when I pause and think that this is Dhoop Kinarey remake,I am utterly disappointed.So very much disappointed.With all these lovey-dovey promos flowing in,and Dr.A melting faster than a candle, I just had to make this post,just to find out if there is anyone out there who feels as I do.

This show has a superb cast,MB,KK,Ishiita,Dr.Ranganath,Nidhi's father,who are casted exactly as in DK,they are all doing their job flawlessly.BUT,why did they have to re script the entire thing??? Now,all I can see in KTLK,is just another love story,no depth to it.I can't help comparing it to DK,and I have to say that they have made this show a sad caricature of DK. Dr.Zoya and Dr.Ahmer were so different in DK,and they slowely fell in love.There was no need of a rain scene,or a broken leg,or a fever to make them fall for each other.Zoya joined back the hospital because she wanted to be a doctor,not just to be around Ahmer.Though it was a MAJOR part to the decision,she was not starry eyed as Nidhi is shown to be,They worked with each other,and there was a certain dignity to it.

Nidhi is joining back just because she wants to be around Ashutosh so that she can make up her mind if she loves him or not!?? Really??? This is a Doctor's profession we are talking about.We don't just opt out of it,and go in it,just based on emotions like this,or to be around a certain someone.I would love Nidhi to come back to earth,not saying that she should not feel the love,but the least she can do is to be serious with the profession and her real intentions behind it.Also,what have they done to Dr.Ashutosh? Where is the parallel between Ahmer and Ashutosh??

Previously,MB mentioned that they are re scripting the entire show.To take the TRPs up?? While they do that,don't they realize that they are ruining the essence of the show AND the characters?
Though I admire Mohnish Bahl,I am disappointed with Dr.Ashutosh and I can't blame him,I have to blame the people who write the story.The 2 characters that have stayed true to the nature,are Anjie and Dr.Mallika.Thank God for that.

Sorry for the rant,but just had to,because I hate to see a classic being butchered this way.

Please if anyone from the show is reading this,could you please take it slow,stop putting too much sugar into the scenes please??? I agree MB shines in romantic roles,but please,this is DK we are remaking.Please don't make a DMG out of it. (Sorry,DMG fans,but just saying what I really feel).

So now,if anyone from the PH tells me... "Hey,stop comparing this to DK,this is an entirely a different show,with MB as the lead,nothing to do with DK.." Then I shall zip up my mouth and close my laptop.

Thanks for reading,feeling better after posting this.😊



Great post. I agree with you. I must have seen DK a billion times😳😳😳😳 and was excited to hear KTLK was an adaptation of DK. I try very hard not to compare the two shows. But still am a little disappointed with what I see in KTLK.

I think it is the pace and characterizations of the leads. To me it seems a little rushed, the speed at which the leads are opening up with each other and getting attracted to each other. All the actors portray their characters well. My issue is with the way the characters of Nidhi and Ashutosh are sketched out, especially Nidhi. Her character seems to lack depth and a sense of responsibility.

Just my POV, did not mean to offend anyone. 😳
rpmenon thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#68
The more I see of Nidhi,more I dislike the way she behaves.She has nightshift,she doesn't call and let her dad know.He is worried,and when he calls,madam is disappointed,because it was not Ashutosh's call.Then she leaves in the morning,lands at his house,and decided to have breakfast there,not thinking about the worried parent.Well,it maybe just me,and maybe I am getting too old,but all this,even in the name of love,don't gel with me at all.To top it all,she decides to take the glasses from outside to create the barish wali situation inside his house.I give up!!!!

For God's sake,CVs,please take it gradual that all that look a little convincing!


leo4ever thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#69

Originally posted by: rpmenon

The more I see of Nidhi,more I dislike the way she behaves.She has nightshift,she doesn't call and let her dad know.He is worried,and when he calls,madam is disappointed,because it was not Ashutosh's call.Then she leaves in the morning,lands at his house,and decided to have breakfast there,not thinking about the worried parent.Well,it maybe just me,and maybe I am getting too old,but all this,even in the name of love,don't gel with me at all.To top it all,she decides to take the glasses from outside to create the barish wali situation inside his house.I give up!!!!


For God's sake,CVs,please take it gradual that all that look a little convincing!


totally agree with you, but sadly we are the very few, majority watch the soap not for the plot or story but for the chemistry between the leads and since the cvs have to keep the interest of the larger group as well asneed high trps they will keep giving us the scenes which get more cliched as doc astosh realises his love yet stops coz of age barrier, the soap will soon see a cycle between malika a regular plotting vamp, niddi the innocent heroine astosh the strong gentle romantic at heart protector of niddi !!
i always thought it was more than a average love story ;girl meets boy , girl falls, boy falls too a lil later woah boys best friend had always loved him trouble brewing!! the only diifference is that the background is a hospital rather than a college offce and the boy is a man!
I am totally dissapointed, heck she doesnt want to be a doctor , runs off at every minute to be with him , now is cooking just as he likes a particular food, yet complains she is not being treated as a doctor? why just coz she got a rank, kids like her, everyone made a big deal asking her to be back she assumes she should be treated like a doctor? when has she acted like a doctor anytime back at the hospital??
fine i get it she is sweet and confused and doesnt know why feeling so much for him i get it love happens in a minute even but the treatment doesnt appeal to me, had there not been any news that it would be different and a little mature than the regular hospital love soaps , am not even comapring it to DK , realised long ago it is way different but keeping aside the comparison, i still fiind it falling short.
but my solution is to stay away till doc astosh joins back , maybe then it will be less over the top situations, till then the forum and updates should suffice. the cvs are lucky they have sucvh awesome acotrs, mb and kirtika had it been some other maybe the charm would have long gone.
kirtika is an amazing actress had no idea she would be this good, it is coz of her conviction only that even now i feel only slightly irritated by niddi while fnding her cute too at times and not hate her!!
-Eris- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#70
i ve not watched dk but i love ktlk

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".