*Season 2, Week 27* Analysis Thread - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

210

Views

21k

Users

32

Likes

2.2k

Frequent Posters

cscs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: Shaavi


Awesome post Chaaru. 👏 . I think the reason for that scene was the bold blue. When Ishwari landed in hospital eating all those sleeping pills,, Dev was also in a panic situation where his brain stopped working. The only thing he could think about was "what if" he had not found her when he did, or if she had died or some other bad thing had happened to her. And he took a decision he otherwise wouldn't have taken. And said things that he otherwise wouldn't have said. I feel all these scenarios are for Sonakshi to understand Dev's dilemma's, his actions which she couldn't understand at times.

Just my pov. not intended to hurt anyone.

Bingo Shaavi, during sleeping pill track, Dev was scared of losing his mother as he thought she tried to commit suicide because of his relationship. N there was no way of thinking anything rationally at that point.
Although i doubt Sonakshi will relate this situation with it. But yes during Bijoy's hospital track, she did got a fair chance to understand what Dev went through.
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#52
Great episode analysis, Charu! I think these days, you have to take the episode as a whole unit and consider all of the characters equally important to the movement of the story. If you are looking for some one element, you might not see it, but sequence of events has a lot to say. Yesterday's episode, for example, was structured around the theme of violence against women. While Sona was facing dubious behaviour from strangers outside, Dev was protecting Elena from one such situation inside his own home! While Sona found herself in a sticky situation because of lack of communication, Elena found herself endangered because she tried to initiate it, so it subtly, without preaching or beating us over the head with it, shows a lose-lose situation for women unless the structure of society changes significantly.

Reading the spoilers made me quite happy, thinking along these lines. In essence, this week seems to be centered around the debate between the idealist, Sonakshi and the realist, Dev. Dev will argue for methods through which to remain safest in society as it is, and Sonakshi will envision an equal society as it should be, where her "no," matters more than her being already "taken" by some other man. As always, they work best together in balance, but first they will have to understand where the other is coming from.

Sona has to see that Dev's fear comes from a past which has shown him a lot of ugly things that she can only imagine. Her reaction to Ishwari's vague description of her humiliation was so intense -- Dev had to face the reality day in and day out, that too as a helpless child. He was the one who watched his mother walk through the alley with a knife every night, and so this issue cuts very close. His intention is to keep his loved ones safe at all costs, idealism and independence be damned, and seeing Sona in this position would have triggered that extra-paranoid, protective side of him. She has to be more careful not to trigger this hyper-emotional reaction in the future with clearer communication.

Dev, on the other hand, may learn just what a woman's independence means to her, in a world that is still male-dominated. Women have come this far and gained this much freedom because of women before them who chose to uphold certain ideals, and fight for space and a voice. So every woman who defies restrictions placed on her to achieve on par with men, every woman who makes choices for herself even if they are against the norms of society is furthering that cause. If all women only cared about safety, we would still be confined the household space.

Both of their arguments (according to spoilers) might be valid and right, but just as Sona has to understand that independence can't be the ONLY priority, Dev has to understand that safety can't be the ONLY priority -- they have to enter a complex discussion and figure out where their middle ground lies as two people with such different backgrounds. I am looking forward to those discussions. Fingers crossed!
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#53
@ Charu @ Shaavi
Awesome. Agree with you both. Both the protogonists should be given a fair chance to justify themselves in crucial situations. Shaavi. You said what I felt by applying the 'dumb' thing to Dev. If only his behaviour is rightly understood with concern so much damage would not have happened in their lives. Let it be. Atleast now he may be seen in a different light. I just hope for that.




Lakshmi



gmgi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#54

Yesterday it was again a lovely episode. Though terrifying it was endearing to see how much both of them have realized what they mean to each other. Though I feared for Sona I felt for Dev the whole time. He is just getting back to normal. They were slowly building everything back, bringing the lost family together and relaxing slowly into their family lives. It is still a dream come true stage where the reality has not seeped in to their soul as of yet. And to lose everything in the blink of an eye because of one carelessness. It would have killed him. Though he was worried for her safety the moment he saw her terrified and vulnerable with those men for whom she was just another face but was the whole world to him, he just lost it. His khargosh terrified and at someone's mercy? They were lucky to go from there alive. He would have skinned Sona alive if she was not scared and was relieved to see him there just like he was. He had just promised their daughter to bring her mother back and this was the scene that waited for him. The fear of losing each other yet again is not something that they want to feel again. Yes the journey to the Naye rang has kick started and how.

Loved Vicki Elena scene. Looks like they are also on the verge of starting a new journey. The first time Vicki deliberately hurt Elena when he reminded her that she has not achieved anything when compared to Sona. It was one of her deepest hurts being compared to Sona and one which she had shared with him, which actually had enabled her to understand Vicki when they fell in love since he was in that same position of being compared to Dev. That time the attack was too sudden for her to react but yesterday when he tried the same saying she was never a good wife though it shook her to the core she retaliated. Vicki is making himself alone by pushing Elena away. This same scenario played 8 years back with Dev pushing Sona away with the company of only alcohol. He is on the path of self-destruction. It is ironic that he triggered the destruction of Dixits by making Sona leave and her coming back in itself triggered the reverse ie his own destruction.

sjain thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#55
Just - Sometimes Negativity hating bashing pushes you to think and find positivity around..and It happened with me today..So thank you to all the haters around who are badmouthing about show actors characters..you encouraged me to think and ponder better

HAHA DQ thanks to you too Usually Its difficult for me to write as when you watch episode..thoughts are quite fresh so writing is more comfortable but then I decided to give it a try again and for that I re watched the episode


Firstly..keeping aside the hug & last few minutes of yesterday's episode I will talk about what happened before that..

The sequence had much potential but it was faulted in terms of editing continuity and compilation..Sonakshi was coming back when her car broke off..she was on highway late night in a deserted area she calls Dev informs him..Dev tells her to stay inside car and lock it even roll up windows properly..She while sitting inside car notices 2 strangers and gives them impression as if she is talking to someone by fake calling action and that was one smart move because thats what even I have done myself it makes the other person little alert and conscious of their actions..so that was *thumbs up*..But what happened after that totally messed up the whole thing..She comes out of the car goes and stands with the lady and climbs the bus..this while move of her didnt make much sense to me ..if she had been helpless or hadnt contacted Dev then I would have understood it but why she got down then why she went in bus was quite a confusing thing for me I found quite a few reasons around even Charu too explained me one but honestly nothing satisfied me as such..Then even while sitting in bus she was saying come soon Dev I need you..But the location she sent him she wasnt present their how was Dev suppose to locate her he himself was in such a panic state..On the contrary I felt she wasnt in any problem at all no gunda or anyone would have troubled her if she had been locked inside her car..but by doing this bus stunt she invited trouble for herself..which was not required at all..I will only blame Sonakshi for this

I expect Sonakshi to react and behave sensibly because she is one grown up smart educated lady and a mothr of 6 year old..If she will react so rashly and without thinking then what is she suppose to teach her daughter..I myself stay in big metro city in North India and I know how to travel around in day time or in night..Also by removing whole of SBS portion the execution and meaning of it was hampered..This probably was one major reasons why the sequence couldnt have that impact which I expected it to have It was flawed..Also I felt they could have given a bit of built up before Dev rescuing her..and could have stretched till tuesday (no not by showing molestation and all) to wind up this sequence in a better and convincing way..Any ways sometime it happens But just want editors or the ones who see or check the episodes before its final airing to be more alert careful and should themselves watch it from the POV of a random viewer if possible because it has to be convincing

Anyways I will look past it and wont hesitate in appreciating the last bit right from Dev's entry in bus literally withering with anger and thrashing goons..to hug part..It was impactful one could feel the relief fear satisfaction in their faces their eyes..I could feel their emotions..It was very real and relatable moment..Infact Dev scolding and their multiple hugs were very apt and suited the situation quite well..All credit goes to the 2 actors involved here..They are such fine impeccable actors I am short of words..KUDOS..Love them for making Dev Sonakshi so real and beautiful for me..Thank you guys..Their chemistry that spark is simply LIT

Now coming to other parts well Vicky is on his worst and till now he has always boasted himself but this time he is on the verge of blasting and harming others..so This looks scary

Considering all the latest spoilers ..This week looks quite interesting and Dev's "possessiveness" will be intriguing..Looking forward to it

No offense My POV





DreamOfEndless thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#56
Hi folks! 😳 How have you been? Sorry for my long and unexpected absence, especially after writing about holding on... I have been down with really bad viral fever all this while. Now I am much better... I feel so bad about not being able to fulfill my analysis promise.


Amazing analysis Charu and Sam. And I am so happy to see Shaavi back. 😊


The only thing that touched my heart yesterday in a way no other scene could was Dev-Golu scene. I just could take my eyes off the adorable duo of Chacha-bhatija. (I don't mean other scenes did not, but this one did the most...)


I am feeling really worried seeing Vicky at his current state. And the actor playing Vicky is really doing a great job. 👏


The problem is that Vicky always seeks validation of his capability or importance in comparison to his brother. Such comparisons are of no use, because everyone has their own role in the family, nobody can take anybody's place, no matter what.


Vicky is getting confused with his motive: between using Dev's love for Golu to get his property and being more important to Golu than Dev. Whenever he says that he handled everything, had been a support for the last 7 years when Dev and Ishwari were broken, he easily forgets his role (and his mom's) in bringing that misery to their doorstep, and a thousand more misdeeds to keep them at their misery.


A thin line between truth and false, right and wrong in his mind is slowly getting blurred (even hazier than before). One should note that when a lie is repeated 100 times, one starts believing it as a stated truth. Till the time Dev was in misery, Vicky took undue advantage of him. Now when Dev is relatively settled, Vicky is starting to feel that Dev is unfair and he is a victim of circumstances. I see Vicky gradually reliving Ishwari's obsession for her son and if Elena separates from him, he would relive Dev's pain of the last 7 years. It would be interesting to watch RR and Mamji's stance in the entire journey.


Even though I love Mamaji, I too somewhere feel if Mamaji were more attentive and compassionate dad to Vicky, instead of just berating him for his mistakes or constantly comparing him with his cousin, then Vicky would have been at par with Dev. He would have learnt healthy competition. For Vicky, his dad's opinion matters a lot; and his constantly calling Vicky "nikamma" and constant comparison to Dev, has left a deep mark on him; so deep that he still measures his success in that scale - his Dev bhai.


At this juncture, I remember the portion of Pride and Prejudice where Mr. Bennet realizes what kind of husband he had been and what kind of father he had been to his daughters, except to his two eldest daughters.


The memories of Nirbhaya's case just haunted me back with yesterday's Sonakshi's scenes. I did not want to know what would have happened if Dev did not come in time. I think those guys were trying to get uncomfortably close in the pretext of getting down. Like many, I too felt Sonakshi acted somewhat foolishly. Also, it makes me realize the importance of learning self defense - for both boys and girls. Boys too, because what would have happened if anyone of those guys were armed, with gun or knife? (And ye Delhi mein possible h) The situation is potentially unsafe for both boys and girls.


No, not for Dev Dixit.. wo to Superman h 😉😊


BTW, did I share my mom's hilarious reaction to the new haircut? She was like ajkal ke bacche baal bhi adha adhura katwa ke aate hai 😆😆


- Tia


EDIT: I just caught up with the entire thread of this week. Amazing writing everyone. 👏 I am really proud to be part of this thread!
Edited by dreamy.tiara - 8 years ago
thedramaqueen thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#57
My major takeaway from the episode last night

Originally posted by: Samanalyse

...so it subtly, without preaching or beating us over the head with it, shows a lose-lose situation for women unless the structure of society changes significantly. ...

Edited by thedramaqueen - 8 years ago
sjain thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#58
3000 views ans 57 comments already..7 pages and its just Tuesday..wow this time make it 30 guys please
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#59
After watching tonight episode I found myself quite clear in my understanding of the way Dev and Sonakshi love each other. Whatever I felt before emerged just true and my perception of the difference between them in feeling the universal emotion is very apt. Others may agree or disagree I don't mind. Every one can not think alike...
Dev loved Sonakshi and Sonakshi loved Dev but how?
For Dev Sonakshi is his life. For Sonakshi Dev is a part of her life.
Dev can not live without Sonakshi. He will become lifeless,without her in his presence. That is why we could see Dev come back to life with the entrance of Sonakshi in season 2,

Sonakshi can live without Dev. But she also could not bear to be away from him. We could see her realisation of her love for him more in season2 than in season 1.

Both have misunderstandings,quarrels etc.. But ultimately they both understood their desparate need to be with each other. Soha's presence helped them reconcile faster but she is not the sole reason for their reunion.Definitely their love for each other played a pivotal role in uniting them forever.


Fine. All is well that ends well. But now when they are living together the difference between them as lovers who are now husband and wife is glaringly evident.

Sonakshi did not change. She is practical. She finally became Mrs. Dixit. She always cherished to be Sonakshi Dixit. For her that satisfaction is enough to proceed with her life and it's perfectly articulated goals and achievements. Yesterday's incident proved the point. Sonakshi behaved like the business woman whose priority is to get the deal done. She just went out without telling Dev,without bothering about Iswari and her concern,without thinking about Soha who may miss her atleast while going to bed. She just raced ahead to meet with success in her deal.


The unfortunate incident that happened disturbed Sonakshi without doubt. But she is not emotionally disturbed like Dev. Strangely the person who played the role of the saviour got shattered. He could not forget the incident . He could not overcome his fear of witnessing a dreadful scene had he not reached in time.

Sonakshi asked him so frankly about baarish and chat. That is the way she perceived the incident that happened. As of now she is totally into her practical mode. Dev's fears and his perception of the incident is just opposite to what Sonakshi felt towards that.

I wonder how different they are in their expression of love.While Dev expresses himself so well Sonakshi doesn't feel the need to express it.

Why do you love her that much Dev? How could you be so intense in your love? I just love you for the way you loved Sonakshi. Take a bow.


Lakshmi





YASHO1997 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#60
If yesterday's episode had been rushed today's was completely on point and totally KRPKAB. As I had imagined whereas any other serial would have focused for weeks on the incident itself, our show brings up what happens after it. The devakshi scenes were love today!
How sensing dev's mood and the need of the moment sona suggested they go to a coffee shop.
And this dev yaar! How adorable he is! I wanted to pull his cheeks!!!!
How he held her hand and put his arms around her, then left her close while sitting, caresses her hair and kept his hand on her arms.
And sona understood his worry and need to be close. She may have been a little uncomfortable but didn't say anything. That look she gave him was worth a thousand words... I think the audience understood everything along with dev! The thank you, and I okay, I am here, the reassurance was all there!
Then again in the morning, also she woke him up with a kiss on the forehead, and could understand that he didn't want her to leave! Beautiful scenes they were!
So so far I think our prediction of them coming closer after this is coming true to see extent! This just has to happen once both reach a middle ground I. E some kind of assurance from sona and a little choot from dev!
Honestly everyone understands dev Now, and sona does too! See she didn't get upset for any other thing other than that call! For a personality like sona it was obvious on her part to act like that. Why would someone give her the contract because she is his wife! That investor irritated me today too along with sona.
But they car scene was just a difference of opinion in my view not a jhagra! Sona understands why he is behaving like this...and that gave me hope that she will handle this sensbly and not shout at him. I dont want him to be shouted at for this. So sweet he knew he upset her so send her that cake to make her happy and then the decorations and suprise for tomorrow too!
Yess he seemed a bit overboard but again understandable and I want to see how sona handles it. I am sure even if she does get angry she will. apologise and make up for it later. Plus, they too have to fund a middle ground! Like reeling in dev from such extreme actions and sona understanding his fear of loosing him, his want for her and then they can come close!
Why do I feel this and Vicky issue will bring them closer?
As in Vicky is a fool so will make some mistake. Mama comes to know and maybe tells dev or he comes to know himself. This may somehow lead to exposure of that fateful night and realisation on sona's part which will push them even closer. I am not keeping any expectations and speculations now... Will wait for a few more episodes let the track unfold a bit to see where it's going
Surely but it will be devakshi ke new rang!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".