Whose mistake it is ??? - Page 4

What would Dev had done after knowing abt her pregnancy?? They would have a force patch up and then he would have kept her in I.N; and after such ugly argument; what would Sonakshi go through in Ishwari Niwas; GKB and Vicki constant taunts; Ishwari irritating behaviour; and surely Dev wouldn't have taken a stand for her even in such situation; imagine her plight; she would have been so mentally disturbed and would have gone through emotional turmoil; as we know during pregnancy a woman is supposed to remain happy and live a stressfree life; which Dev would have never been able to gv her; so I believe whatever happens it is for our benefit!!

Perfectly agree with u dear...Each n every word is true when i saw how todays scene played out...Dev couldnt take the responsibility of Soha then cos he was not made known ,he was kept in complete darkness...So there should be no GILA or SHIKWA on him in the first place?...Wat Jatin did,.Dev would have done 10000 timesmore if he was informed cos he was her dad !He would come back running to her...

Originally posted by: Devakshilover

And one more thing.Did dev ever try to find out about her that is she alive or dead.No he was busy blaming her and flirting with random girls

I was thinking the same when Sonakshi was saying all that.
I t was all Sona's fault.

Hey guys dont worry. All this is gonna be much ado about nothing when both of them come back together again and it would be revealed that dev was an angel investor in sonakshis company since beginning and his flirtatious ways was just a show to misguide his family😉

Originally posted by: Sky21

Dev was the one who taunted her inability to be a mother and said he is glad she can't become a mother or she would have been a bad one. After this you expect her to tell him about the pregnancy? She went to his house to give him rights as a father but was not even allowed to enter , it's not her fault . Why this vehemence against Sonakshi

Yeah absolutely right and u expect sona to go and call and cry in front of dev and his mother telling that she is pregnant pls save her...

At least she had the guts to come to the house see how she was treated by her mother in law

Just like dev sona is also totally confused about her feelings. Hope they remove the cobwebs from their mind soon. Either sona should decide if she wants dev in sohas life or not. If she wants honestly no man will tolerate any other person even if its sweet natured gud guy like jathin taking his time with his child. Especially when he is taking all the pains.

I think Sonakshi is logical and practical enough to understand that Dev could not possibly have been present at the time of her delivery or thereafter to take care of Soha as she herself has not informed Dev about it, except for the one visit that she paid him which was quite unsuccessful. But behind all those questions that she asked him, there was only ONE question, I believe, that she as well as the audience desperately need an answer for - "why did he not care to make any attempt to find out what happened to her or her family ( pregnancy or no pregnancy) knowing that they were practically thrown out on the streets.?". He clearly has the means to find out , should he take the trouble to do so. Just my POV.

Originally posted by: cscs

I will not say that she shouldn't have given birth to the child as it was her child too. She had full right to go ahead with the pregnancy and delivery.

They had a bitter separation, agreed. She didn't tell Dev bcz of her hatred, fear etc etc reasons, agreed. She tried to contact Dev after 6 months (i seriously dunno now what pushed her to do so), but was returned back, agreed.

Then why after 7 years, there was an urge to tell Soha about her father?

Was there any need to bring back Dev's equation in their life again?

From her back drop story i don't think Soha was missing any father figure in her life, Jotin was perfectly filling that gap. So what is the need of Dev in their life and that too on mercy. She is doing no ehsaan on Dev by making him meet his own daughter. Its his right and if she thinks the other way around, she should bang court doors and they will definitelysupport her.

As far as I am concerned, breakup was both of their faults and Sonakshi's story is very contradictory to her previous and current statements. Its not Dev's fault that he was not with her during that phase, its circumstantial if we like to believe.

My only issue is the dwindling nature. Either stay firm with your decision or let go. As off now Dev is like surrogate father to Soha, trying to fit in his daughter's life with no help.

I don't understand how Jatin was a father figure to her .If he was then why was Soha missing her father and was curious to know him .When the teacher asked to draw the family pic she did not include Jatin in it .Children don't understand anything about legal relationship they understand love then why didn't Soha include him in family pic .Golu on the other shows through his action that his BigCha is his family .I doubt Sonakshi understands her daughter's feelings .She could never realize Soha missing her father until recently