*Season 2, Week 3* Analysis Thread

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

preethik

@preethik

Voyager

Posted: 8 years ago

#171

I wonder where that remark came in for a guy whose mother struggled to bring them up. It was a disgusting remark. Sonas reply was spot on without naming his mom.

I really don't like what the cvs are doing here. They are glorifying Sonas charachter at the expense of Dev. Where is Devs core qualities that Erica said would remain intact in S2. I have tried to understand this complicated charachter but such remarks show how bitter they have made this charachter so where is the question of devakshi in all of this.

Edited by preethik - 8 years ago

Quote

Shaavi

@Shaavi

Voyager

Posted: 8 years ago

#172

Originally posted by: sia.krpkab
Anybody analysing Dev's comment on Sonakshi today - pata nahi kya kya kia hoga paisey ke liye'.
What good intentions would explain this - mere provocation won't be enough for this remark.

I would like to relate a personal experience... Once my colleague was talking about words used or something one sees and how it relates to mind. He was saying that when someone sees a baby's butt, there can be people who thing it is cute, some might think the parents are careless, and there will be others who think about inappropriate things. All these depends on the persons outlook.

Dev did say those words. It is upto people to take it as they like it. One can just take it at face value and think that he was talking about how hard she had to work, that she must have worked day or night. Why should we always think it is meant to be something bad...

Sonakshi was wrong in calling Dev spineless in public. I think this was Dev's way of giving back. And the thing is he did not do it in public, but waited for just to be only them and gave her the answer.

I am not defending Dev. I am just saying that both Dev and Sonakshi are acting like kids and are just acting out...😆

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

preethik

@preethik

Voyager

Posted: 8 years ago

#173

Originally posted by: Shaavi

I would like to relate a personal experience... Once my colleague was talking about words used or something one sees and how it relates to mind. He was saying that when someone sees a baby's butt, there can be people who thing it is cute, some might think the parents are careless, and there will be others who think about inappropriate things. All these depends on the persons outlook.

Dev did say those words. It is upto people to take it as they like it. One can just take it at face value and think that he was talking about how hard she had to work, that she must have worked day or night. Why should we always think it is meant to be something bad...

Sonakshi was wrong in calling Dev spineless in public. I think this was Dev's way of giving back. And the thing is he did not do it in public, but waited for just to be only them and gave her the answer.

I am not defending Dev. I am just saying that both Dev and Sonakshi are acting like kids and are just acting out...😆

Yes they are acting like kids shaavi but that one sentence did not have any kiddish connotations to it.

Yes people see things differently even about our show. I had no problem of him sleeping around. He's an adult & the other lady was consenting too. Today's dialogue was truly below the belt. I understand he's trying to get a reaction from her but for me when he questions her charachter with such words it becomes difficult to support his actions.

Quote

sia.krpkab

@sia.krpkab

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

#174

Originally posted by: Shaavi

I would like to relate a personal experience... Once my colleague was talking about words used or something one sees and how it relates to mind. He was saying that when someone sees a baby's butt, there can be people who thing it is cute, some might think the parents are careless, and there will be others who think about inappropriate things. All these depends on the persons outlook.

Dev did say those words. It is upto people to take it as they like it. One can just take it at face value and think that he was talking about how hard she had to work, that she must have worked day or night. Why should we always think it is meant to be something bad...

Sonakshi was wrong in calling Dev spineless in public. I think this was Dev's way of giving back. And the thing is he did not do it in public, but waited for just to be only them and gave her the answer.

I am not defending Dev. I am just saying that both Dev and Sonakshi are acting like kids and are just acting out...😆

It's all about perception.. And this perception is some serious deception. Thanks for responding to my post - this thread is definitely all analysis, no matter how hypothetical it is. I am a researcher by profession, but sorry I am not capable of understanding your analysis. I love Dev's character but I will still call him a total loser - that's what he is proving to be day in day out.

Quote

gmgi

@gmgi

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#175

Originally posted by: sia.krpkab
Anybody analysing Dev's comment on Sonakshi today - pata nahi kya kya kia hoga paisey ke liye'.
What good intentions would explain this - mere provocation won't be enough for this remark.

There was nothing good in his intentions Sia. He said that to hurt her where it hurts most. He questioned her character and she gave it back in the same language too. He wants her out of that office asap. The more she resists and give him back he is going to do worse until one gets really hurt.
Just like her comment yesterday that Soha's father doesn't exist, this comment is also going to prick their conscience. Along the lines of what all she had to do to raise their daughter when he literally throw them out of their own house.

Quote

Jiyaaa.....

@Jiyaaa.....

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#176

I may be minority here...What I thought was that he was referring her business practices how she became so successful in business from nothing.

The reason for me to saying this ...If we look at the way the conversation started, Dev wanted Sona to leave the office and he says that he deals crores of business in his office and he can't risk her leaving alone in the office. Then Sona says "Do you think she and her employees are thieves?" Then Dev says "who knows"...what all she did to gain this success?

Even Sona replied the same...He was also poor and struggled and who knows what all he did to achieve this success?

I don't think, if he questioned her character, Sona wouldn't have kept quiet. Again, it depends on how we perceive it? I felt the way conversation started and ended, thought it was more related to business practices rather than saying Sona is characterless.

Edited by Jiyaaa..... - 8 years ago

Quote

timbarucha83

@timbarucha83

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

#177

Actually I am not supporting any one not dev and not sona

But if am not mistaken the same words was used by bijoy in the slapgate for ishwari . so thease kind of words has been used 3rd time .

Honestly they both want to heart each other if dev is saying any inapporate thing sona is replaying back. Honestly they both are same . kiddish rembermbeing the previous things and replaying

Back each other. Some how I am having a very different theory which is related to amritmathan . when amritmanthan stated first element which come out was the poison and then all the valuable elements. In the same way after 7 years when they are infrount of each other samething is happing. What is, happening we are taking very serisly and honestly if you ask me day before in the, previous episode sona was, saying that dev doesn't exist and in yesterdays, episode, she is, rembering dev is, soha's father. I am following an wise adivise we should never come between an husband and wife sorry I forgot ex . if I am not mistaken this relation is the most strange relation in the word they both can kill each other while, fighting but they both make sure that they both get medical help. And another logical point this conversion stated for business matters, not for personal point

And chill guyes sona has given the answer . and dev has accepted it. After that they both are alive.

And ever ready to fight

Edited by timbarucha83 - 8 years ago

Quote

_Payalj_

@_Payalj_

Voyager

Posted: 8 years ago

#178

Originally posted by: thedramaqueen

I am not trying to be controversial. I often wonder this about couples in joint families. Why was the Bose house any more Sona's home than the Dixit's house? I would have stomped to my room in the Dixit house. Or am I being unreasonable to women who live in joint families?

There is a one line answer to this. Because she was never made to feel as if it were here home. It was Ishwari's home.

Regarding today's episode Dev made aspersions on her character which was purely unethical but then maybe this was an offshoot of the spineless comment. The way Sonakshi had called him spineless in public almost equated with impotent and so Dev hit her under the belt in return calling her characterless.

Both of them are creating new definitions of rock bottom.

But yes Dev locking her and going home to play was very wrong. I would have called it a funny prank if he had stayed somewhere near after locking her so that he could be there if some mishap happened. This was plain insensitive and cruel

Edited by _Payalj_ - 8 years ago

Quote

Danseuse

@Danseuse

Inactive

Posted: 8 years ago

#179

Originally posted by: Jiyaaa...
I may be minority here...What I thought was that he was referring her business practices how she became so successful in business from nothing.

The reason for me to saying this ...If we look at the way the conversation started, Dev wanted Sona to leave the office and he says that he deals crores of business in his office and he can't risk her leaving alone in the office. Then Sona says "Do you think she and her employees are thieves?" Then Dev says "who knows"...what all she did to gain this success?

Even Sona replied the same...He was also poor and struggled and who knows what all he did to achieve this success?

I don't think, if he questioned her character, Sona wouldn't have kept quiet. Again, it depends on how we perceive it? I felt the way conversation started and ended, thought it was more related to business practices rather than saying Sona is characterless.

I had the same views and hence chose to ignore it. The comment was not about her character, else Sonakshi would have slapped him. She gave it back immediately, using similar words and meaning so Dev didn't have any answer. Forumites have gone berserk because there is lot of animosity towards Dev's character. Dev knows for sure that what he has done is wrong, else he wouldn't tell Golu,"Mujhe bhi koi daat padne wala hain!" He is thinking this is all a game for him, as he doesn't know about his little one waiting for Sonakshi at home!! When Suhana unfolds and the father-daughter meeting happens, all these incidents would be in FB mode for Dev to regret.

-Rekha

Quote

LiveLife321

@LiveLife321

Voyager

Posted: 8 years ago

#180

These two even know what they are speaking and how rudely hurting each other. They should really watch their words or may be each other's presence is giving them needed outlet to bring out all the bitterness piled up inside them. He is insulting her about her professional efficiency and she is throwing insults on his personal efficiency. How long this mud slinging is going to continue? Either lock them in a room or push them in to a boxing ring.