Doubt : Whether Neha's view was right?? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

2.5k

Users

20

Likes

173

Frequent Posters

mena_k thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: yyy

Neha has a point .She was comparing her husband's reaction to Dev .

It's amazing how Cvs have created similar situation between two couples .
Wife''s Issue

Neha feels her needs are ignored by her husband and feels like an outsider

Sona feels her opinions are ignored by her husband and feels like an outsider

Husband's Reaction

Ranveer tries to call Neha .When she ignored his calls he doesn't make an attempt to convince her or visit her at her home.Upon others insistence he visits her .

Dev tries to call Sona .When she ignored his calls .He sent messages , emails to convince her .When nothing worked he went all the way to her home to convince his wife and is ready to apologize .

If I am not wrong Neha never wanted to have a separate home .It was Ranveer''s family who insisted on this and later Ranveer decided to have a sperate home .Can we blame her for sperating him from his family ? Yes Neha should have waited for little longer till everything gets settled .




Was it Dev's decision to go to Sona or was it Mamaji's intervention and telling Dev he could go and get Sona If he is sad.
mena_k thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: vibg

sona is anything but lucky. we have all seen the insults, taunts, outsider tag she has been handed. and, she has taken it all in her efforts to fit in. sona would have been kicked out of the house by Ishwari & Dev if she behaved like neha.

Ishwari has still kicked Sona (by her master manipulative technique) out of the house though temporarily for she didn't like her interaction and involvement in Neha's business. So that's what Sona get in Dixit house being lucky.
Edited by mena_k - 8 years ago
mena_k thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: vibg

sona is anything but lucky. we have all seen the insults, taunts, outsider tag she has been handed. and, she has taken it all in her efforts to fit in. sona would have been kicked out of the house by Ishwari & Dev if she behaved like neha.


Well said and the sad part is Dev her husband himself tagged Sona as an outsider.
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#14
Absolutely right.

Neha wants to have every happiness, all the luxury, even love handed over to her on a silver platter without lifting a finger to deserve them. Why? Because she had a rough childhood. This sense of entitlement is really evident in pretty much every member of Dixit family.

Did she have a hard life as a child? Yes.

But that does not entitle her to make demands on her husband as she makes on her brother. She sacrificed for her brother but not for her husband.

She'd be the first to criticize if Sona leaves Dixit mansion in a huff when Ishwari is sick putting pressure on Dev to move away. Yet she did the same for Ranveer.

Ranveer took a decision in crisis to save his mother. She could have discussed about being included in that particular decision. But that was NOT the time to throw a tantrum.

Secondly, Ranveer did not run after Neha like Dev because he had a crisis at home. Would Dev run after Sona if Ishwari was in critical situation? Not the same situation at all.

Ranveer never claimed to be anyone but who he is - a middle class man who is not ambitious and is content with his life.

Whatever gave Neha the idea that one day he will be rich like Dev who is driven and ambitious is anyone's guess.

But she made some assumptions and when it didn't come true, she blamed Ranveer not reading her mind and making her dream come true.

At any point of time she could have told Ranveer that she wants to study and join Dev's business to fulfill her own ambition. I'd have blamed Ranveer if he had then refused to support his wife.

But he has always fulfilled his responsibilities as per his priorities. He took loan to buy an apartment to live separate from his family for his wife's happiness (which is more than Dev ever even considered even after watching Sona being insulted by his family). But when it came to his mother's health, that was a priority.

What kind of man would he be if he ran after Neha without considering his sick mother? Yet he made calls, texts and even came to see Neha with Sona only to get insulted and treated like unwanted pest.

Was he right for filling harassment case against Neha? No.

But let's not forget he was threatened by Dev to sic lawyers on him first and we yet don't know if Dev took away Ranveer's job first or Ranveer filled the harassment case first. So I will withhold my judgement on him until I find out.

However, considering Neha was effectively shut up by Ranveer's Bhabhi when she pointed out that they all know who is the actual problem here, it comes to mind that it was not Ranveer. Otherwise Neha is not the type of woman who can't answer back.

So whatever Neha faces now, will be her own doing aided by her mother and brother.
Edited by tia.o - 8 years ago
_Payalj_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#15
Neha is like the student who just doesn't work and then seeing another student pass with flying colours feels jealous and calls him lucky totally ignoring the hard efforts put on by that student.
Marriage like job or education needs a lot of hard work and patience. Neha refuses to do any courtesy the self pity induced Dixit sense of entitlement.

And then feels jealous of Sona. What she doesn't realise is - 1. sona's husband misses her because she makes him happy (though at a great personal cost) sona is slowly becoming the sunshine in Dev's life.

2. Nehas husband doesn't miss her because she actually mentally tortures him by simply refusing to understand or adjust and like a dark sun is leaching away the happiness and light in his life (again courtesy the Dixit mentality)
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#16
Excellent point. Here's another one. Was Dev's family in crisis when he ran after Sona like Ranveer's mother's health was? Would Dev still run after Sona if Ishwari is in critical condition? But Ranveer still called and texted and even came with Sona to talk to Neha.

Originally posted by: mena_k


Was it Dev's decision to go to Sona or was it Mamaji's intervention and telling Dev he could go and get Sona If he is sad.

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#17
What an apt comparison Payal. Yes, Neha is also the student who wants to pass university using her hard work in junior school. Sorry darling, you have to make an effort in every step of life to get happiness. Past credit only lasts with past debit holders, not with rest of the world.

Originally posted by: _Payalj_

Neha is like the student who just doesn't work and then seeing another student pass with flying colours feels jealous and calls him lucky totally ignoring the hard efforts put on by that student.

Marriage like job or education needs a lot of hard work and patience. Neha refuses to do any courtesy the self pity induced Dixit sense of entitlement.

And then feels jealous of Sona. What she doesn't realise is - 1. sona's husband misses her because she makes him happy (though at a great personal cost) sona is slowly becoming the sunshine in Dev's life.

2. Nehas husband doesn't miss her because she actually mentally tortures him by simply refusing to understand or adjust and like a dark sun is leaching away the happiness and light in his life (again courtesy the Dixit mentality)

WeRockTheWorld thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#18

Difference betwn Dev- Sona and Ranveer- Neha

Dev and Sona faced a lot of trouble prior to marriage , so they know each other well and they have a fair understanding of the troubles that are going to hit them after marriage. Like Sona knows how possessive her inlaws are . Dev knows abt Sona's medical condition. Both may not be aware of the prenup that is going to hit them but I feel they will solve that one too. Dev and Sona had gone thru a break up and they are so scared of loosing each other , so every time they fight they want to get back because they know what life is with out the other. For Dev Sona is like oxygen , he needs her always . And for this I give credit to Sona because she loves him selflessly , It is her selfless love and blind understanding for him that made her so important in his life.

Ranveer and Neha did not have to face so much prior to marriage . It was much easier that what Dev and Sona went thru. But post marriage when they started facing issues they are not able to handle it. Neha and Ranveer are too adamant. Neha's side of family only added to her misery by guiding her in a wrong way !!


Neha is the most interesting character of this serial. Its like she entice us every moment because she herself is not sure what she wants in life and what will make her happy. Her problem she has locked herself in the past even though they have come out of it and she fears that poverty stricken past . As a child she has seen the worst . She was deprived of everything including her childhood. Both brother and mother knows it but by the time they realized it she was no more approachable .

Now comes Ranveer into her life giving all attention and care that yearned for as a child and she falls in love with him . She knew he was poor but she thought she could overcome her fear of poverty and marries him. After she reaches there , when she is dumped with responsibility and Ranveer busy making money to meet the family financial expenses she feels neglected . When she was young she didn't see this part of her brother s struggle because Ishwari never allowed the sisters to interact with Dev. We need to understand that the financial burden was ONLY discussed between Ishwari and Dev. Dev more of a provider like a father .

Neha thinks like her brother Ranveer should also earn money and start becoming rich . What she doesn't understand is that Dev didn't become rich in a day /month or a year. He took years to be who he is today with a lot of sacrifice from his side too. We know that with some of the statements that he shares with Sona. (His talk of friends having GF and how they go to meet them). His struggle for being rich and successful started from his school days ( Talks about selling newspaper early morning ). Had she been made to realise this aspect of her brother's struggle , she would have respected her brother more and also would have adjusted with Ranveer.

Neha's conversation with Ishwari showed that she is again thinking of just one aspect - abt Love that husband has for his wife. Instead of telling her daughter abt the scarifices and trouble that Sona had to go thru...Ishwari becomes jealous of what she hears from Neha. Ishwari is so occupied with her insecurities that she forgets Neha's issues. This is very evident by the way they are handling the issue. When Neha came home , Ranveer called her many times but she refused to pick the call. When he came home to talk to her , family members got involved in their fight and he had to walk out because of harsh words that were exchanged. Instead of taking an impartial approach , the Dixits stood by their girl and forgot that after marriage both should be seen equally.

The situation is the same with Dev and Sona. But the world doesn't understand this . Ishwari thinks she was able to sent her DIL home . Reality Sona wanted to teach a lesson to Dev and she went home. There she never agrees to her parents that they have fought. She always maintains that they love each other .So Dev's image in front of her parents is perfect. When Dev comes home she asks him to leave as she will stay at her parents house and get back. Her parents are smart , they sense there is some issue betwn them . Instead of interfering her father kicks them out in the middle of the night to sort out their issue. He played it smart. Now a loving husband is not going to leave his wife in the middle of the night so he is bound to be with her and eventually both of them got talking.

This maturity that was shown by Sona's parents is not there in Dixit family. A father's absence is greatly felt there . Dev is the patriarch of that house but he has come up of his own with very less guidance from a man. He is too young to fit the fathers shoes .

Just wondering how Neha's issue will be solved. With Ishwari and Dev being absolutely adamant of getting Ranveer out of Neha's life I don't know how Sona will be able to help Neha. Infact I think Sona should stay away from it or she will destroy her marriage.


Push-pull thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#19
Nice post and wonderful comments.. Bookmarking for a later read..👏
404_NotFound thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: mena_k


Was it Dev's decision to go to Sona or was it Mamaji's intervention and telling Dev he could go and get Sona If he is sad.


Was it Dev missing Sona or Mamaji .It was Dev who called her when he came home ,sent emails .It doesn't matter whose idea it is at the end of the day it's Dev''s decision to go to her place .No one forced him to go .
Edited by yyyy - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".