Spineless Dev, Selfish n Blind Ishwari, Stupid Sona note:pg 21 - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

179

Views

17.6k

Users

58

Likes

1.1k

Frequent Posters

peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: ...Doctor...

Great post!

I disliked Dev since the day he broke up with Sona but yesterday Sona disappointed me more than Dev. How can she be so dumb! Her mom gave her a chance to back out, still she didn't budge. What nonsense was that! And her behaviour in the engagement. So insulting! Ritwik tried to talk to her, to cheer her up but Sona didn't have the decency to atleast respond properly or pay attention? She was busy looking for Dev *slow claps*

Dev was not supposed to be devdas, right? But that's what he was trying to be (and failing miserably)

Ishwari was, is and will always be blind.

Even Devakshi flashbacks look forced to me and make cringe. Ruined a good show for god knows what reason -_-

the day he broke up it cud be overseen as he was hell scared of loosing his mom but after that he should have made attempts to mend it instead he went stalking and drinking

If handled well, Ishwari's character wud hv been so so brilliant but she is turned into Komolika 😆
peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Loveforlife

Thanks Nas for making this post. I have been following this show from its conception and loved numerous moments between Dev Sona, both family members, the story telling etc. But these past few episodes post break up have left me disappointed.

I wanted to see a mothers journey from being possessive about her son to her letting go of her obsession, coming to terms with the fact that she cannot cling to Dev forever. He need a life, family and love of his own. This journey of Ishwari started well but somewhere all this drama is unnecessarily forcing her to accept Dev and Sona's relationship.

Time and again we have been asking for a show that is path breaking. That steers away from stereotypes that are bombarded on us in every other show. I was waiting for this show to do that. Show anger, resentment... Yes... but problems solved through controlled reactions and Matured
conversations. But suddenly it took the common path of self destruction and destruction of others for the sake of personal goals.

I do not know in what sort of Love the makers believe in. It seems the writer has overdosed on a staple of Mills and Boons in which we have women falling for the arrogant act. It is utterly misleading and untrue. What is the idea of Dev's love? Is it only about showering Sona with gifts? Is her presence in his life only to listen to how his mother sacrificed for them and how they came up from poverty?
One bad patch in their relationship and he starts rioting against her! Where was his love for her when he did things against her? Dev says to Sona I am not so strong like you. But He was strong and bashful enough to do wrong things towards Sona and Ritwick! Characters have been given a lot of leeway under the name of being flawed, weak or in love. As if these are their tickets to perform villainous deeds!


You have written perfectly about Dev, Sona, Ishwari and Ritwik.



break up was brilliant to show @bold but but 😆
This angle was never ever shown on TV and it was exciting concept but writers lost it
aisa bhi nhi tha k TRP race hai so drama quotient badhao aur TRP pao 😆
if we even assume that Ishwari will accept sona by force then what is the guarantee that she will not behave same way again and once again dev will not strand her for mother's sake?
i so hate it wen potential tracks are wasted and i hv to jhelofy it
Manasi90 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: ...Doctor...


Thinking of stalking, spying, emotional harassment and invasion of privacy as romantic/love story hai chalta hai is positive approach?

Supporting a guy for his looks and not for his good personality is positive approach?

Supporting spineless guys who can't stand up for themselves is positive approach?

Thinking it's okay to cross all limits of sanity for love is positive approach?

Insulting a good person for no reason, dragging him into your mess for no reason, leaving him at the altar os positive approach?

What exactly is positive approach?


I was actually talking about my positive approach towards the show. It is the only show I watch when I come back from work. It feels good to watch good people taking so much effort and hard-work to relax us from whole day's mess. Supriyaji, Jagat Rawat are all theatre people. Practicing acting from sucha long period. Watching them acting in daily-soap is fantastic. I have never seen Shaheer's Navya or Mahabharat neither Erica's south movie. But fresh faces, good acting, heavy and light moments feel good and positive approach to watch next day's episode.
peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: randomramblings

loved your caption. this story is all about these 3 most imperfect characters.

This is the story of how a "SPINELESS" dev, due to his lady love earns his "SPINE". only to loose it again in difficult time 😆
This is the story of how a "selfish and Blind " Ishwari, learns to open her "EYES" and "SEE" thingswhich she is royally ignoring and prentending to be blind
This is the story of how a "STUPID" Sona, emerges out of her "STUPIDITY" she isn't emerging out of stupidity, she is becoming one

Since you started off so beautifully , let me make you see the other side of the coin which you are conveniently trying to brush off!!

1. for the son, when did he see his mother as a "HUMAN" for you to be complaining in the first place.
for him he will always hold his mother at the highest pedestal and he need not show it in actions to prove his devotion for her. when ishwari could outrightly accept natasha , a random girl thrust down his throat for a damn deal, sona was her dearest nootrishan, the one she looked after as her own daughter, had emotional connect , took her along with her to a party... i can go on blah , blah, blah... why on earth do you expect that dev would have any doubts about his mother accepting sona and that she needs TIME????

For him the only reason him mom was angry is because ishwari had figured it out, while he did not tell her about this most important part of his life, himself. so as soon as he came clear with Ishwari, the chapter is closed. period.

the real problem started when was forcing Sona in Ishwari's live while with Natasha it was not the case, he wasn't desperately trying to bind Natasha n Ishwari whereas with sona-ishwari he did that...every single person noticed Ishwari's discomfort but the son who kept at her pedestal failed to notice


2. his mother taking pills is not the driving point dear... if you have not watched the episode , i suggest go watch it again... his mother blaming herself that she is not happy with her sons decision and calling herself as a bad mother was the break point. He can bear anything, but not a freck of disappointment in his mothers eyes, and here she was not only disappointed, but DEJECTED and calling herself NAMES.. do you think he would behave rationally.

i didn't said that taking pills drove him, what i said that the extreme action taken by his mother made him realised that she was not happy wid his relationship

3. he ignored sona ????? are you sure??? how about the phone conversation he had with sona where she clearly stated that they are strangers now... do you think for a man like Dev who never opened himself even to his mother, to be able to digest the fact that the only person to whom he has bared his soul, treats him a stranger now!!!. can his mind even process what was being told, to react ??? to me he is brain dead, even to invoke a reflex action as soon as sona called him a stranger!!!

what do you expect sona to do? to behave normally? she was DEJECTED by break up, she tried her best and consoled him and told him together they will solve this mess and convince Ishwari still he broke up, he should have made more attempts if he was so concerned

4. Who said ishwari is WEAK?? what everyone is afraid of is not her emotions/health but her EGO. They all know how she relates even the smallest action of Dev like eating a halwa to him being devoted to her!!! how to make a egoistic person like her to come out of this lala land without mentally disturbing her??? since you want the story to be realistic can you give some ideas to the CV's ???

i am fine with her being weak health wise but emotionally she is weak. Don't she hv trust on her love? she is afraid of loosing Dev and that is not due to some EGO but her emotions which are fragile

5. Sona, she too was in her own dreamworld, wasn't she?? for her love was always a fairytale where a prince charming would sweep her off her feet, and they will have a happily ever after. Dev being her prince charming, always treated her as his queen. You call her strong and LOVED her way of handling the break up??? so moving on means get hooked to the first available bait... shabaash...

give that shabash to Sona she deserves it 😳 😆 I never said that she shld get married, i said she rushed in shaadi due to CHALLENGE she gave to Dev and wen she decided to do that she should stick to it

6. Dev was stalking her, oh so she knew it and had problems with it?? hahaha... who are you kidding, atleast dev maintained his distance. She on the other hand directly goes to his house at the slightest pre omnition... ... i think we need to redefine stalking.

then what should I make out of that whole date sequence 😆

7. is it fit of rage,??? i dont think so. The best of both Sona and Dev came out only after verbal spats. every instance where they challenged each other, ended in making them aware of the new layer of emotions/side of other person , brought them more closer to each other emotionally and binded them with unseen twines.

but there verbal spats were too late, dont you think so? it did make them aware of new layer but disrespected other's feelings

8. darling when you are broken/shattered , the person who needs to be sitting next to you is" THE ONE" who can make you assemble all the broken pieces. not your family/fiancee/spouse because they are related to you. one look at his room, sona knows dev is on the verge of self destruction. NO amount of self respect is worthy when it comes to mending a broken individual. let alone respect, there is no humanity left in you , if you chose to evaluate your worth over somebody's very existence.


9. oh so you feel inviting an ex is a stupidity?? really!!!,
true yesterday you were hitting the headlines along with your ex and your so called fiance's family had issues with it.

when sona knew he is so heart broken she should not have invited him, you urself gave answer in above point 😉 mending broken individual at the cost of family respect, parents feelings *wow*

Today when you are walking into their family with you head held high infront of your ex, mere presence of him shall cause them embarrassment. iska matlab yahi huva na, that as long as your ex is not picture , they are ok with you but at the mere sight of ex, they are reminded about your flaws????. same goes with Ritwik, if he did not have issues in accepting sona with her share of past relationship, he should not have any problem in seeing her ex in the party. Sona's family, Ritwik and his family knows that DEV is "EX"- that should have silenced them . why does an EX bother you so much when sona's "CURRENT" and "FUTURE" is right next to her????

isn't it too philosipical to follow in life #justasking
you should keep the situation in mind while acting. IT was her engagement not some B'day party

Is Ritwik blind??? did anyone force him into this relationship,?? Did sona not make it clear to him that she is trying to use him to overwrite her past?? . so when you have walked in with our eyes wide open , why complain that you are being "USED" .

wen did he complained? What I am saying is wen someone is trusting you so much atleast respect it

of course DEV was sleep walking.. he love his sleep and his dreams, he never wants to wake up to harsh realities...

but unless he open his eyes he cannot solve the mess and to face harsh realities one needs COURAGE

peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: mayu1982


After reading this post: My reaction



People are analyzing characters without looking into in-depth problems of any character.






Simple logic is :





But anyway thanks for making this post.. Activity and viewing will definitely increase 🥳

We will get rank #1 next week also




Lastly





P.S. well you don't like any characters of this serial .So we are definitely not standing on the same page. So I will not waste my energy and time in explaining to you at all.Anyway




meeting you.

you wasted tym in posting gif 😉
lovely gifs and congratulations on 1st rank in advance
peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Sharicafan

if you dislike all the 3 protagonists of the show, it is going to be tough...Ritwick is anyway leaving the show...

Hope you find a serial you enjoy watching just like most of us here love KRPKAB and won't miss even a single episode...why? Because we understand why Dev, Sonakshi and Ishwari behave the way they do..no one is perfect but that does not mean we can not try to see their point of view...
No hard feelings...just my POV!

the way they are behaving is dislikeable, i never said i dislike them 😳

peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Divine-Pearl

That's how humans should be

They have flaws. They are not mahaan like super bahus and saas of soap. No one is super intelligent, their is stupidity in us. No one is completely selfless, we all are somewhere selfish.

These are flaws. Shit happens, not only in reel life, real life as well.


And people need to stop getting personal with someone who has different opinion. It's not cupalsary to like or understand the leads.


I love grey characters but wat is being portrayed is dumb n plain stupid
All i am saying is cvs cud hv handled it better widout destroying basic traits of characters
peeyara thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Shona456

Did u evn read wat u wrote 😆 nvr mind..thnk god i dint read d whole post 😆
Thnx fr d disclaimer itself 😆 😉


I hv a talent that i cannot read what i wrote...isn't it amazing 😉
Kisi ko batana mat is talent ke baare mai 😳 😆
*Dev.* thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: peeyara


hey Dev
you still remember me😳
hamare khayalat milte jhulte hai😆



Hey Peeyaara! 😳

Of course I do! I'm just not that hyperactive but I do check forum and posts on threads which interests me or have similar views as me.

Yeah hamare khayal kaafi mature bhi hai 😆 ...

When Dev felt down in floor, I just had a sentence in my mouth and I said to myself; look a weak Dev just went down...how weak and timid he has become... and I felt so much pain for him but than I said he, Sona and Ishwari deserved this to realize what they did wrong.

I feel bad for Ritwik a lot... why wasn't he angry and why he behaved like a saint? I wanted him.to a bit angry lol. Anyway... looking forward to future episodes.
DMGFan-2b-not2b thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
Hello. You are a brave young person! To come on a forum which had blind devotion for the leads, no matter how irrational they might be, and make a negative comment on them, needs courage :-) well done!


I have not read the 18 pages of comments but I am quite sure that much of it must not be complimentary :-)


I wonder what the reaction would have been if the male lead had not been "hot"? Though I don't find him hot personally, but many do see to think. Erica I think is pretty.


But the characters? I agree human beings are not black and white but grey but Dev is spineless. He is like a child whose favourite toy is taken away and instead of sorting it out, he sulks in a corner, throwing a petulant fit and whining away.


Sona, I can perhaps still understand. In a fit of anger and a bid to move on, she decided to get engaged to Ritwick. But she is guilty of bringing shame on her parents and putting their dignity at stake. She is also guilty of being unfair to Ritwick and making a spectacle of him and his family, but sometimes we do not think rationally.


Ishwari while I feel is unreasonable and insecure, I have seen enough mothers who are possessive about their sons and many sons who are unable to say anything to their mothers even if they know they are in the wrong. Marriages get destroyed by this tug and pull between mother and daughter-in-law and its not only the mom-in-law's fault at all times.


I do feel like whacking Sona for making a mess of everyone's lives and Dev for being such a cry baby And Sona does not realize, that it is her family and her who would suffer because of her stupidity. Society, sadly, doe snot take the man to task but will point fingers at her family, her upbringing, the spectacle that she made while Dev will walk away unscathed.


I would be very disappointed if Ishwari now agrees to the marriage and Sona says yes. Cos the decision has not been because Dev convinced his mom and made her change her mind, but made by Iswari finally capitulating seeing her son waste himself and her brother, bless him, trying to knock some sense into her.


Dev has had no contribution in changing her mind except to get drunk, behave like a wastrel and make a scene in other people's home and make a mockery of their dignity. If Sona is compelled by her love to say yes, after all this, then she and Dev deserve each other ! :-)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".