Posted:
I was going through some forum topics and many are like 'There must be some GOOD reason behind Heer hiding Chahat from Prem' and everything. Even I believed that there was some major reason and now, that I was thinking it over, the reason that Heer hid Chahat from Prem is PREM!
The way Heer understands Prem, she is afraid of Prem. She knows that whatever Prem does/thinks of doing, he does it, no matter what happens and he does it to the extreme.
And her examples are:
- Premeer's love. The way he fought with everyone just for Prem and Heer, wasn't it extreme?
- Prem's care towards his family, especially his mom, dad, Preet, wasn't it extreme, that no matter what came, despite fighting for Heer, he still loved them?
- Prem's hatered/misunderstanding for Heer. Wasn't it so extreme that he went till accusing her of cheating on him?
- Prem's reason for going away from Heer and pretending to be Gaurav Sharma, he wanted to protect Heer, from what may have happened if he DID have a heart disease.
And now she left Prem 6 years back, cus she 'thought' he had slept with Ash, and we know what the truth is. And now, you expect her to trust Prem, just when he didn't trust her?
And now you guys are saying why Heer didn't tell Prem about that guy, well, don't you know that she wanted to see Prem happy, just the way he wanted to see her happy and that is why he put the false act of 'Gaurav Sharma'. Get it? It is all about staying happy and since Heer cares for Prem, and cus Gayatri told her not to tell Prem, she didn't, just like Prem didn't tell Heer that he was Prem, and pretended to be Gaurav Sharma cus he thought he had little time left.
So, does this justify it?
And then, the accusations of why, Heer doesn't trust HER Prem. Well, then where was Prem's trust for Heer 6 years back, when he accused Heer of having an affair with Rajveer and cheating on him? A misunderstanding right? And that was sorted out with Heer-Rajveer telling him the truth. And now, I don't blame Prem, cus here no one is wrong. Neither Heer nor Prem but still.
And now, you see her saying all those stuff, about Prem cheating on his wife etc, and having an affair...which is wrong. But now, don't you think that even though she might be in denial that she doesn't want to go back to Prem, but she can't see anyone else with him either, so her lines of him having an affair and what so ever, isn't it like, she telling someone else that Prem is not the right guy for them, so she has him all to herself?
Now goes, Heer's reason for hiding Prem from Chahat. She doesn't want to go back to Prem, cus she thinks that he is not her Prem anymore. I mean who wouldn't? You did so much for his family and then he ends up sleeping with your cousin? (Heer's POV). Ofcourse you are angry and on top of that, his personality. She knows that if Prem knows about Chahat, he would want to have Chahat and can go to any extent to get her. And that is why Heer didn't tell him about Chahat.
She knows that Prem wants Heer AND Chahat back, but she doesn't want to go back to him, cus she loves him, yes but she can't go back, seeing what he did by 'sleeping' with Ash. So basically it is justified/ her lines/ expressions etc.
So basically, Heer knows that Prem can go to any extent to get her and Chahat, but she doesn't want to go back to him right now, cus of what he did 6 years back, and she worries that what he did before, he can do it again, and this time, if he does do it again, then Chahat will be hurt with her and then, maybe, she won't get Chahat back, IF the Juneja family starts to get attracted towards Chahat, not as if they aren't already. So she fears, that they will take Chahat away from her and she doesn't want that. And she loves Prem, and can't see him with anyone else, and that is why, she keeps saying he had an affair and everything so the other girl would hate him, and then they would break the marriage and whatever she says, even Heer is confused of her feelings. She loves Prem, but she fears that what Prem did to her 6 years back, he might do it again!
Kabhi Neem Neem Kabhi Shahad Shahad
