who is wrong Prachi or Sanchi? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

5.9k

Users

17

Likes

198

Frequent Posters

hemangi0601 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21
I personally feel it is Prachi who is wrong 98% with her selfish and insensitiv nature.
Saachi has to be over protective as she has to play a mothers role for aadu and prachi.And these two are old enough to realize saachi's sacrifices and should support her.But on the other hand prachi behaves so immaturely and arrogantly with elders👎🏼.
Only 2% wrong if at all
Saachi is, it is her unconditional love for her family and alwys trying to take the whole responsibilty of family only on herself which make her not to give any responsbility to her siblings.
ApoorvaFan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Heema22

I am glad you made this post . I was thinking about this issue too.who is wrong and who is right ? Is Sachi making choice between what's right and what's easy ? Or she is a sibling and trying very hard to be parents which is very hard to do . Prachi is spoiled child doesn't understand disappointments is part of your life. Sachi needs to know its impossible to protect Prachi against disappointment in life. If she is thinking that she is Prachi's parent then Her primary job as a parent is to prepare Prachi for how the world really works. In the real world, you don't always get what you want . Sachi needs to know that Prachi doesn't have to love you every minute of every day. She'll get over the disappointment of having been told "no." But she won't get over the effects of being spoiled.One painful duty fulfilled makes the next plainer and easier.
As my experience , I accept that there is no right or wrong . There is many ways to see same situation . But in this situation Prachi need to evaluate Prachi's demands before she goes out of her way and capability to fulfill them .

absolutely right... If Sanchi wants to be a parent, she has to teach Prachi how to deal with life. If she wants to be a sibling, by this time Prachi must have understood that they do not have parents to they cannot demand things ...
ApoorvaFan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: nidhirohan

offcourse saanchi is very much over protective...but i dont think that it's her fault..she lost her parents and she very well know the imp of parents in upbringing of children...she does notwant prachi and adduu to suffer from any kind of pain..so she is lit bit overprotective towards them...fault in this case here is of prachi only,she is not understanding imp of her tai in her life.. i mean prachi is not a kid she is a grown up girl..she knows very well what sacrifices saachi has given to make their life better.. i hope dhruv plays a imp role in making prachi understood the imp of saachi in their life 😳

well said. by treating them like kids, Sanchi has over stepped in her responsibilities I feel. And you are right about Prachi .. she needs to learn the sacrifices made by Sanchi
mudraswathi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
A very thoughtful question and post AF!👏

In my view, there is no one rule to state who is right and who is wrong.

The circumstances have a big role behind why one should act in a particular way... Saachi has learnt the lesson a bit early and her sister is taking time.
Heema22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
Hi I don't know your first name ! R U Apoorva or Apoorva's fan ? I am Heema .
I see your Thread has difference of opinions and most of them blaming Prachi . obviously , because of her behavior .

When tragidy strikes family and older sibling has to rise to the occasion and become "The surrogate parent " sometimes just a teenager him or herself - must manage household logistics and make difficult decisions for siblings, all while dealing with their own grief and anxiety. This dynamic affects younger brothers and sisters influence them later in their life.Everybody knows how to raise children, except the people who have them so I expect Prachi to make mistakes and she will learn . We don't have schools or formal education for parenting .

Sachi is not sure of her role . Sometimes I feel like she is Tai ( older sister )and sometimes times Aai .( mother).Prachi behaves the way she does because someone lets her. If you want your child /your sister to keep their feet on the ground, put some responsibility on their shoulder. Sachi needs to give some responsibility to Prachi . We have seen many times she overrules Grannies . Prachi takes advantage of this weakness and expect Sachi to solve her problems and expects perfect solution .If she takes life in her own hands, and what happens? A terrible thing: no one to blame. it's easy life when we have someone to blame for . Prachi was very young when her parents died so she has attitude problem "she deserves every thing her own way on the silver platter "
Selfish people are self centered and always looked at life as if they are the center of the Universe. It is very difficult deal with people because they are always willing to take and never willing to give and Prachi is not exception . More Sachi gives more she will expect !! It seems.
Now the sari comments . Prachi was very young when her parents died . We never saw her missing or Idolizing them the way Sachi does . Her memories are very different than Sachi .
At this time she is in love . She is only going to think about what her boyfriends thinks and wants. It's different stage of her life . That's why she chooses pink sari ( and also writers want that yellow sari for Sachi to show her appreciation for parents ) I don't think any thing wrong with this or this doesn't make her " bad daughter " no way !! She is just a normal girl in love .

Edited by Heema22 - 12 years ago
ronshaan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: Heema22

Hi I don't know your first name ! R U Apoorva or Apoorva's fan ? I am Heema .
I see your Thread has difference of opinions and most of them blaming Prachi . obviously , because of her behavior .

When tragidy strikes family and older sibling has to rise to the occasion and become "The surrogate parent " sometimes just a teenager him or herself - must manage household logistics and make difficult decisions for siblings, all while dealing with their own grief and anxiety. This dynamic affects younger brothers and sisters influence them later in their life.Everybody knows how to raise children, except the people who have them so I expect Prachi to make mistakes and she will learn . We don't have schools or formal education for parenting .

Sachi is not sure of her role . Sometimes I feel like she is Tai ( older sister )and sometimes times Aai .( mother).Prachi behaves the way she does because someone lets her. If you want your child /your sister to keep their feet on the ground, put some responsibility on their shoulder. Sachi needs to give some responsibility to Prachi . We have seem many times she overrules Grannies . Prachi takes advantage of this weakness and expect Sachi to solve her problems and expects perfect solution .If she takes life in her own hands, and what happens? A terrible thing: no one to blame. it's easy life when we have someone to blame for . Prachi was very young when her parents died so she has attitude problem "she deserves every thing her own way on the silver platter "
Selfish people are self centered and always looked at life as if they are the center of the Universe. It is very difficult deal with people because they are always willing to take and never willing to give and Prachi is not exception . More Sachi gives more she will expect !! It seems.
Now the sari comments . Prachi was very young when her parents died . We never saw her missing or Idolizing them the way Sachi does . Her memories are very different than Sachi .
At this time she is in love . She is only going to think about what her boyfriends thinks and wants. It's different stage of her life . That's why she chooses pink sari ( and also writers want that yellow sari for Sachi to show her appreciation for parents ) I don't think any thing wrong with this or this doesn't make her " bad daughter " no way !! She is just a normal girl in love .



u wrote it very nicely and i agree with every one
especially the responsibility part
prachi is working person but yet doing nothing at home so why would she care about the home issues she knows her sister is there to deal with all so why would she care
well sari issue .. even at that time sanchi supported prachi and prachi knew it very well that sanchi will support her that's why she can say no and do what she wants to.
nutan7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
this mightbe little out of track but want to mention here that the way saachi took decision of attending lunch and postponing the court date.
she thought there can be another chance and upper court is available . but ther is no second chance
for prachi's happiness if suneel's parents made disapointed . this is the proper way to chose one between two which r equaly important to you. and she made her mind readyto face disadvantages of her decision. good Manager . hatts of to her.
( here I am not commenting on her decision that is whether her decision is rt or wrong. I want to admire the way she took the decision.

and I like cvs decision to show that sanchi need not regrete for her decision. DV solve the court date problem. I want the serial tension free like this . no dragging of problems and unnecessary tension . we saw serials for entertaing us and not to bear the tensions. so👏 👏 for cvs.
ak75 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#28
@heema22- Agree with the first part. Reg saree- prachi is not a teenager in love. She is grown up, maybe around 25 yrs and working. She is so concerned about Sunil's likes and dislikes. The same way she has to consider her nani's wish also. Nani is a bit senti on that day she's missing her daughter and she want's to see her in prachi.
Its her nani...prachi can listen to her once and fulfill her wish and make her smile. Saachi understood nani's feelings saw her sad face and agreed to wear it. That's the diff between the sisters.
Heema22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: ak75

@heema22- Agree with the first part. Reg saree- prachi is not a teenager in love. She is grown up, maybe around 25 yrs and working. She is so concerned about Sunil's likes and dislikes. The same way she has to consider her nani's wish also. Nani is a bit senti on that day she's missing her daughter and she want's to see her in prachi.

Its her nani...prachi can listen to her once and fulfill her wish and make her smile. Saachi understood nani's feelings saw her sad face and agreed to wear it. That's the diff between the sisters.



Hi sorry I am new so I don't know your name . I am Heema .
Thank you for agreeing and and disagreeing . I love healthy debates because it makes me think . Again in my first post said there is no right or wrong . There is many ways to see same situation .

Yes, these two sisters are very different and we need expect different responses from both of them otherwise this show will be boring . One is almost perfect and other doesn't give a damn .
I see lots of discussion about " Prachi being disrespectful " I am not praising Prachi for her behavior . It has taken me so many years to accept that its okay with being different . I finally know the difference between pleasing and loving, obeying and respecting.
Do you really think that not wearing mom sari is disrespectful ? I think Prachi was very polite when she refused and gave an explanation . As you said,she is not a teenager . She is grown up with job and just was promoted she she must be responsible person at work . She asserted herself. May be moms sari is not her taste . First time Sasuralwale are coming to see her . She needs to be comfortable . She needs to look good and have confidence . Nothing wrong with wearing something your boyfriend likes that's human nature .I wish grandma had given her choice or asked her about her choice but she didn't she choose the sari she likes and was expecting to wear it . Is that fair ? I know Nani was little senti but Sometimes you've got to emotionally let go of the things that once meant a lot to you, so you can move beyond the past .I personally liked the way Sachi handled the situation . so Prachi asserting herself on her engagement to please her fiance and feel comfortable and have confidence in herself , this is fine with me plus as Prachi's character is written ,she has her own mind and I am very sure Sachi will wear that sari she is the one who does everything right . Plus I want to find out how many forum member would prefer to wear attire of their own choice on their special day ? How many like grandma to chose your attire for sentimental reason ?
Edited by Heema22 - 12 years ago
TBDRESS thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30
I completely agree with Heema on this whole Sari issue...I don't even understand why in this day and age, this has to even be an issue? The grannies in this show need to be shown a bit more mature- but then I guess Saachi would not get the opportunity to swoop in and save the day every time😆 But seriously, the nani was upset because Prachi didn't want to wear the sari chosen by her...give me a break!
They are trying to show Prachi and Saachi on two extremes- for very obvious reasons. But honestly I don't like either of them! Prachi seems to do things that please her boyfriend and Saachi seems to do things that please only her family/father etc etc. These two women are poor role models- neither has the ability to balance their personal goals and desires with the demands placed on them by others.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".