Whose house is it anyway? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Mages

i agree with you totally...maybe milind bought or took over the house but he never built the house with love...relationship in that house....he may bought the house but the true owners are Inder-Prermlata and after that Prachi..to me this house belongs to inder-premlata after that prachi....milind just took over it from ayesha..premlata-inder built it and they are the legal owners they built it without cheating plus love and relationship are built through the house...may milind took over the house but the original legal owner of the house is Inder-Premlata Shah and Prachi

Milind-Sukriti-Milind all came after that a name of revenge milind takes the house from ayesha but fully he never handed it to prachi she have the rights only as his wife....how sick is that prachi who lives in the house since childhood and alot memories are in that house yet those came afterwards took over the house and control the whole house...in fact they have no rights to tell prachi out of the house

I am really sorry, but I am afraid Indian Law isnt going to agree to that😊!
And I just did watch the scene again... Ayesha held the property under Inder Shah's Trust...she signed it on behalf of Inder Shah Trust. So that property was in the name of a Trust. There is no which way Milind could have transferred that property into his name without complying with EVERY legal aspect required including a fitting consideration for that property... So it wasnt a mere transfer... It is a SALE. The Indian Trust Act is very stringent when it comes to transfer of properties held under Trust. So if Milind has managed to pull it off... you cant question his legal right to that property, the courts will decide in his favour. Sadly No emotions hold good in the court of law. And even on moral grounds... for being the man of the house and shouldering the responsibilities of it after his take over... Milind Mishra has every right on that property... Legal, Moral, Emotional... ALL of them!

Originally posted by: amu682

I am really sorry, but I am afraid Indian Law isnt going to agree to that😊!
And I just did watch the scene again... Ayesha held the property under Inder Shah's Trust...she signed it on behalf of Inder Shah Trust. So that property was in the name of a Trust. There is no which way Milind could have transferred that property into his name without complying with EVERY legal aspect required including a fitting consideration for that property... So it wasnt a mere transfer... It is a SALE. The Indian Trust Act is very stringent when it comes to transfer of properties held under Trust. So if Milind has managed to pull it off... you cant question his legal right to that property, the courts will decide in his favour. Sadly No emotions hold good in the court of law. And even on moral grounds... for being the man of the house and shouldering the responsibilities of it after his take over... Milind Mishra has every right on that property... Legal, Moral, Emotional... ALL of them!

if he have the rights on that house right ask him to make ayesha the two timing snake out of that house...he does all responsiblities no dount only on his family not prachi's he only saved their business nothing else.....its only prachi doing all the responsiblites in that house for Shahs/Mishras and Shergiils too...Milind does nothing any responsiblites if he does only for Mishras have done any sacrifices for the Shahs and Shergill no does only for Mishras....may he is the woner of Legal...Moral..Emotional but the real credit goes to his wife Prachi Mishra...to me its always INDER SHAH HOUSE even now its knows as Shah Mansion not Mishra Mansion even Milind took over it...he bild it with love and legal matter doesn't worth when it comes to LOVE...Law is Law may milind get it by law but LOVE in that house his fulfilling by Inder Shah daughter Prachi....thats the biggest court for me

Originally posted by: Mages

if he have the rights on that house right ask him to make ayesha the two timing snake out of that house...he does all responsiblities no dount only on his family not prachi's he only saved their business nothing else.....its only prachi doing all the responsiblites in that house for Shahs/Mishras and Shergiils too...Milind does nothing any responsiblites if he does only for Mishras have done any sacrifices for the Shahs and Shergill no does only for Mishras....may he is the woner of Legal...Moral..Emotional but the real credit goes to his wife Prachi Mishra...to me its always INDER SHAH HOUSE even now its knows as Shah Mansion not Mishra Mansion even Milind took over it...he bild it with love and legal matter doesn't worth when it comes to LOVE...Law is Law may milind get it by law but LOVE in that house his fulfilling by Inder Shah daughter Prachi....thats the biggest court for me

I agree high time Milind shows Ayesha and her Husband the way out of his house. And as far as Milind's responsibility goes towards the Shah Family...No one can dispute the fact that he IS the Provider, Protector of that family at this point in time... simply put every person living under that house lives out of Milind's money. Just because his responsibilities arent shown on screen that doesnt mean he hasnt fullfilled them. Whatmore do you want... when Milind has admitted that Shah's family's happiness is just as important to him as his own. You want to give him credit for that or not... The truth is and will remain that Milind shoulder's Prachi's responsibilities towards the Shah's.... the fact that Premlata places him above her own son, Alaap and the fact that the importance that once was Neev's goes to Milind in that house... speaks for the importance of Milind in that house. Inder might have built that house out of LOVE, but will you dispute the fact that the house (or home) stood destroyed by the hatred his children had for eachother... esp Ayesha and Alaap? The Love with which Inder build the house stood destoyed by the hatred of his own legal heirs. So that home as such never existed when Milind stepped in... and he stood gaurd against the hatred of Inder Shah's children to give Shah Mansion the glory it once had. And the same was shot symbolically... when he picked up Inder Shah's photo that Ayesha threw... he gave the photo to Prachi who stood holding it. He took it back from Prachi and reinstated that photo of Inder Shah with respect👏. It is surely is a home due to the warmth Prachi has given it... but standing gaurd against the enemies (internal & external) to protect that house.. IS Milind. I think it has been discussed time and again... and verdict has been in the favour of Milind.. and rightfully so!

And btw why is Prachi being singled out for the legal heir of the Inder Shah legacy? What happened to Ayesha, Alaap, Soumya and Bobby arent they the legal heirs of Inder?

Originally posted by: amu682

I am really sorry, but I am afraid Indian Law isnt going to agree to that😊!
And I just did watch the scene again... Ayesha held the property under Inder Shah's Trust...she signed it on behalf of Inder Shah Trust. So that property was in the name of a Trust. There is no which way Milind could have transferred that property into his name without complying with EVERY legal aspect required including a fitting consideration for that property... So it wasnt a mere transfer... It is a SALE. The Indian Trust Act is very stringent when it comes to transfer of properties held under Trust. So if Milind has managed to pull it off... you cant question his legal right to that property, the courts will decide in his favour. Sadly No emotions hold good in the court of law. And even on moral grounds... for being the man of the house and shouldering the responsibilities of it after his take over... Milind Mishra has every right on that property... Legal, Moral, Emotional... ALL of them!

Well cool! Makes sense, and definately true 😛 But the thing is this is an Ekta Kapoor, her serials are never logical, and therefore I don't think you can cite the Indian law for a BT show like Kayamath, cause they never follow or adhere to such Indian rules and regulations 😛 In my viewpoint the programme doesn't give a damn about Indian law regulations. If Indian law were to operate, things would be completely different.

Like for instance, Look at the way Milind burnt down Neevs factory, or Neev sends Milind to jail and the police just foolishy buy their defense. There was this scene in which Neev brings the police in to go arrest Milind for burning his factory (with zilch evidence btw) and then Ayesha, Neevs wife, says that Milind hasn't burned it down, cause he was with her at night in a hotel room. Isn't that a little dodgy of an evidence? A married woman with another married man in an hotel room at night. Just how an affair would be, but the police stupidly buy it.

So this is what I mean, you cannot cite the Indian law, for something as Kayamath which never follows the Indian law. So in Kayamath point of view, I honestly think Inder and Premlata are the moral and true legal owners of the house because they've acquired it truthfully, without any deception and taken care of the house with love. Sure, in real life, Milind Mishra will be the legal owner of the house. But in Kayamath, which displays reel life, I would say Inder and Premlata are the owners. Just my opinion.

Originally posted by: amu682

If I think i remember right, The property is Milind and he has paid for it. He told Ayesha that he incurred huge losses in the Bangalore deal he signed with her...but he is fine because he got the property for his wife. So obviously if Milind has incurred losses he has paid and paid more than required... so that covers the payment for Shah Mansion aswell. No it doesn't, he paid for a purely business project and that flopped - its not like he gave a loan to Ayesha, because in that case maybe you could say Milind has paid Ayesha for the Shah Mansion as Ayesha owes Milind money. But Ayesha doesn't owe money to Milind for investing or incurring losses. He does need to pay money to Ayesha for the Shah Mansion, his investment in a Bangalore project cannot be termed as his payment for a house. Investment is different from a loan, in investment the people acquire a share of profit - and thats their pay-off or gain. In a loan, the person who has been given the loan has to repay it back. And more over Milind has invested a huge amount in Ayesha's International project in Mumbai... which never took off.... and I dont think Ayesha repaid Milind! Well we don't know that, do we? Why make such assumptions which aren't backed up by any evidence? I can similarly say I think Ayesha has repaid Milind and so Milind cannot be the legal owner of the house! 😛 And Milind has enough self respect for himself to make false claim that he owns Shah Mansion... He doesnt have to do that when he can afford a house 10 times the value of Shah Mansion! He has in more than occassion said he has BOUGHT over Shah Mansion.He also said that he cheated to get the Shah Mansion. So Yes, Milind has paid for Shah Mansion... he has paid Ayesha who held the property at that point in time.... he paid it through the contract he signed. As far duping Ayesha and getting her sign the papers... then it is only fair to trick a girl who originally tricked the rightfull owners of that property. It would have been fair if Prachi had done the same, not Milind even if he was her husband. But even if she had done it, I would say two wrongs don't make a right.

I might be completely wrong... but I do remember vaguely that Ayesha was deseparate to pay Milind's investments back that she was contemplating pledging her assets. Now I dont know if the contract that she signed with Milind's sister concern was in that regard.

Anyway Milind has paid for Shah Mansion and he IS the Legal and Moral owner of Shah Mansion.

Originally posted by: meteora_smt

Well cool! Makes sense, and definately true 😛 But the thing is this is an Ekta Kapoor, her serials are never logical, and therefore I don't think you can cite the Indian law for a BT show like Kayamath, cause they never follow or adhere to such Indian rules and regulations 😛 In my viewpoint the programme doesn't give a damn about Indian law regulations. If Indian law were to operate, things would be completely different.

Like for instance, Look at the way Milind burnt down Neevs factory, or Neev sends Milind to jail and the police just foolishy buy their defense. There was this scene in which Neev brings the police in to go arrest Milind for burning his factory (with zilch evidence btw) and then Ayesha, Neevs wife, says that Milind hasn't burned it down, cause he was with her at night in a hotel room. Isn't that a little dodgy of an evidence? A married woman with another married man in an hotel room at night. Just how an affair would be, but the police stupidly buy it.

So this is what I mean, you cannot cite the Indian law, for something as Kayamath which never follows the Indian law. So in Kayamath point of view, I honestly think Inder and Premlata are the moral and true legal owners of the house because they've acquired it truthfully, without any deception and taken care of the house with love. Sure, in real life, Milind Mishra will be the legal owner of the house. But in Kayamath, which displays reel life, I would say Inder and Premlata are the owners. Just my opinion.

You have a point😆... But in the case of Milind & Neev.... both of them had legal options... it is just that they didnt bother to take advantage of it... because both parties knew if they do explore legal options... both will be in soup😆

For discussion sake Inder and Premlata are the owners of the property in the absense of any law... agreed... but doesnt Premlata endorse the fact that Milind is the rightful owner of the house? I would say she does feel that Milind is the owner of that house, her behaviour does imply that... so there you have it.... the owner (along with her legal heirs) ratify that Milind is the owner of the house and Man of that home😊

Originally posted by: amu682

You have a point😆... But in the case of Milind & Neev.... both of them had legal options... it is just that they didnt bother to take advantage of it... because both parties knew if they do explore legal options... both will be in soup😆

For discussion sake Inder and Premlata are the owners of the property in the absense of any law... agreed... but doesnt Premlata endorse the fact that Milind is the rightful owner of the house? I would say she does feel that Milind is the owner of that house, her behaviour does imply that... so there you have it.... the owner (along with her legal heirs) ratify that Milind is the owner of the house and Man of that home😊

Ok fine, I'll give it to you because I'm really lazy to argue back and my younger sister has made an excellent, stupendous point about this debate "WHO CARES? (she literally screamed at me) Its just a serial, godd don't die over it" 😆.

So my conclusion: Milind is the legal owner of the house, but I honestly don't think PL or Prachi or Ayesha (beings PL's daughers) or Neev (being Ayesha's husband) should be obligated to him for staying there. . 😃😛

Originally posted by: meteora_smt

Yes, it is a serial after all. Prachi doesnt have obligated because it is her husband's house. PL doesnt have to feel obligated because Milind treats her like his mother and Milind considers the Shahs as his family. Well Ayesha & Neev... I say belong to a different family all together.. Milind doesnt ack them as family.... so? That will start off a fresh round of discussions... so lets us leave it at that😊

Originally posted by: amu682

Yes, it is a serial after all. Prachi doesnt have obligated because it is her husband's house. PL doesnt have to feel obligated because Milind treats her like his mother and Milind considers the Shahs as his family. Well Ayesha & Neev... I say belong to a different family all together.. Milind doesnt ack them as family.... so? That will start off a fresh round of discussions... so lets us leave it at that😊 Sure! Lets agree to disagree, I feel Ayesha is a daughter so she also kind of has a right. Plus hasn't this right been withhold from her since her childhood. If Ayesha's mom was a normal parent, she would've SUED Inder for lack of child support. In a way, this could be her compensation.

Well I already agree with you (to disagree), so I'll agree with you once again.

Just couldn't resist making one small remark to this comment: "Ayesha didnt have that money... if she managed to pay Milind, she would have been bankrupt... it wasnt one or two crores... it is whooping 50 crores. ". Well in BT shows, people come back from the dead, so paying off 50 crores doesn't seem very difficult in comparison. 😆

Originally posted by: optimist

Personally, I feel Prachi is better off living away from Milsi. That guy seems to think of her more favourably when he does not have to stare at her face 24/7, going by his behaviour in Panchgani or wherever he went to. Michi have a better chance of getting back together with Prachi away from SM than within.

Agrees as well written document👏. Keep it up and u r absolutily right about Milind. I think he will get better with time as his temper is high most of the time?😡