Her dead eyes & mournful silence - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

51

Views

11.9k

Users

24

Likes

279

Frequent Posters

Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: IFLove

What a muhtod jawaab grace😂

Ideally, perception and difference of opinion is the basic of any forum...very simple thing to understand

Anyways, great story. If not anything, Erica definitely is that elephant who will simply ignore the the world fighting over her and walk away to concentrate on her job and let her work make the noise once again!!

Bold - This is something even i didn't think of when i posted this story; but now that you pointed it out is literally suiting Eri in all ways. And thank you for pointing out this resemblance dear. 🤗

Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: hope4u

It's funny how the entire post has become one about giving the TM lecture on how her choice of comparing a relatively novice actress with a legend is wrong.

Don't people in this forum usually take offence when they're asked to do or not do something? Hypocrisy much?

Bold - AnuPre fans or solo stans of Parth/Eri are not supposed to take anything in offence. Because we are supposed to be pure & understanding like our AnuPre. 😉

-Doppelganger- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 5 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: grace4317

Bold - AnuPre fans or solo stans of Parth/Eri are not supposed to take anything in offence. Because we are supposed to be pure & understanding like our AnuPre. 😉

🤗 Respect to you grace for handling the bullies with so much maturity rather than crying and playing the victim card

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 5 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: hope4u

It's funny how the entire post has become one about giving the TM lecture on how her choice of comparing a relatively novice actress with a legend is wrong.

Don't people in this forum usually take offence when they're asked to do or not do something? Hypocrisy much?

I think there is a lot of difference between "comparing " and mocking someone's choice . The former will lead to quarrels and the later , ugly bashing ..its the choice of tm to love erica and praise her to skies...everyone has the freedom but not compare her to a living legend..for sure smita is one of the best actresses ever...she is the latamangeshkar of acting...if I say neha kakkar reminds me of lata , lata fans will take offense isn't it ? Like if you cared for perception you wouldn't be writing this isn't it ? I am sure a lot of people here will jump up and down if someone else other than anupre/parica are compared to some Greek gods in looks and acting without caring for hypocricy.....there is no need to pull the entire world down to show that your choice is the best..no need to show others actors/actresses/serials as bad to show your favourites as the best...if it happens the reply will be likewise ..either dont create such posts in a public forum and expect everyone to just agree...there will be opposing views also when comparison posts will be created.


Perception it is not hypocrisy...I am glad smita patil has fans too in this age and her performance and shabana's performance in arth stays unmatched by ANY actor past or present n here she is being compared to someone whose accent alone is unbearable.....good bye.

Edited by _charu_ - 5 years ago
zeal11 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: _charu_

I think there is a lot of difference between "comparing " and mocking someone's choice . The former will lead to quarrels and the later , ugly bashing ..its the choice of tm to love erica and praise her to skies...everyone has the freedom but not compare her to a living legend..for sure smita is one of the best actresses ever...she is the latamangeshkar of acting...if I say neha kakkar reminds me of lata , lata fans will take offense isn't it ? Like if you cared for perception you wouldn't be writing this isn't it ? I am sure a lot of people here will jump up and down if someone else other than anupre/parica are compared to some Greek gods in looks and acting without caring for hypocricy.....there is no need to pull the entire world down to show that your choice is the best..no need to show others actors/actresses/serials as bad to show your favourites as the best...if it happens the reply will be likewise ..either dont create such posts in a public forum and expect everyone to just agree...there will be opposing views also when comparison posts will be created.


Perception it is not hypocrisy...I am glad smita patil has fans too in this age and her performance and shabana's performance in arth stays unmatched by ANY actor past or present n here she is being compared to someone whose accent alone is unbearable.....good bye.

Wonderful post. Thank you for this.

SheAish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: _charu_

I think there is a lot of difference between "comparing " and mocking someone's choice . The former will lead to quarrels and the later , ugly bashing ..its the choice of tm to love erica and praise her to skies...everyone has the freedom but not compare her to a living legend..for sure smita is one of the best actresses ever...she is the latamangeshkar of acting...if I say neha kakkar reminds me of lata , lata fans will take offense isn't it ? Like if you cared for perception you wouldn't be writing this isn't it ? I am sure a lot of people here will jump up and down if someone else other than anupre/parica are compared to some Greek gods in looks and acting without caring for hypocricy.....there is no need to pull the entire world down to show that your choice is the best..no need to show others actors/actresses/serials as bad to show your favourites as the best...if it happens the reply will be likewise ..either dont create such posts in a public forum and expect everyone to just agree...there will be opposing views also when comparison posts will be created.


Perception it is not hypocrisy...I am glad smita patil has fans too in this age and her performance and shabana's performance in arth stays unmatched by ANY actor past or present n here she is being compared to someone whose accent alone is unbearable.....good bye.

Both hopeful and grace have posted in a very dignified way, I don't get this bold: "like if you cared for perception you wouldn't be writing this isn't it?". Excuse me, but which rule states that legends have to be legends for everyone or they can't be compared..? Arey if Grace thinks Erica is similar to Smita, its none of anyone else business and no one has the right to judge her on it. Its' her freaking perception....iss forum meytho basic concept of right and wrong is 'subjective' why is it such a big deal if grace compares Smita with Erica? Why can't she express her perception?

Those who disagree, its their choice too....she gave her answer in a dignified manner too....again her perception.....Are we seriously going to vilify her here for her right to expression that too in a very graceful manner.....??? If there is one thing that describes grace's behavior in this forum its graceful...please spare her what ever anyone's problem with her perception is!

hope4u thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: _charu_

I think there is a lot of difference between "comparing " and mocking someone's choice . The former will lead to quarrels and the later , ugly bashing ..its the choice of tm to love erica and praise her to skies...everyone has the freedom but not compare her to a living legend..for sure smita is one of the best actresses ever...she is the latamangeshkar of acting...if I say neha kakkar reminds me of lata , lata fans will take offense isn't it ? Like if you cared for perception you wouldn't be writing this isn't it ? I am sure a lot of people here will jump up and down if someone else other than anupre/parica are compared to some Greek gods in looks and acting without caring for hypocricy.....there is no need to pull the entire world down to show that your choice is the best..no need to show others actors/actresses/serials as bad to show your favourites as the best...if it happens the reply will be likewise ..either dont create such posts in a public forum and expect everyone to just agree...there will be opposing views also when comparison posts will be created.


Perception it is not hypocrisy...I am glad smita patil has fans too in this age and her performance and shabana's performance in arth stays unmatched by ANY actor past or present n here she is being compared to someone whose accent alone is unbearable.....good bye.

1) I have nowhere quoted you or accused you of hypocrisy. I wonder what made you feel my post was meant for you.

2) my post was simply directed towards many of my fellow members who take offence if questioned about their choices. Finding replies here questioning the TM on her choices is, under these circumstances, strange.

3) since you've taken the liberty of quoting me and addressing me directly,I will take this as an opportunity to say nothing about your earlier post is polite. There's disagreeing with an opinion, and then there's doing so in a manner that's meant to be insulting and demeaning. You and I both know what would've been the result if a post, as unpleasant as the one you made had been made about a certain other character of this show. Let's just leave it at that.

_Seera_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 5 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: grace4317

Dedicating this story to all those 'special guests' who took their valuable time to bless this thread with their gyaan on how i should adore my girl.

There were once six blind men who stood by the road-side every day, and begged from the people who passed. They had often heard of elephants, but they had never seen one; for, being blind, how could they?

It so happened one morning that an elephant was driven down the road where they stood. When they were told that the great beast was before them, they asked the driver to let him stop so that they might see him.Of course they could not see him with their eyes; but they thought that by touching him they could learn just what kind of animal he was.

The first one happened to put his hand on the elephant's side. "Well, well!" he said, "now I know all about this beast. He is exactly like a wall."

The second felt only of the elephant's tusk. "My brother," he said, "you are mistaken. He is not at all like a wall. He is round and smooth and sharp. He is more like a spear than anything else."

The third happened to take hold of the elephant's trunk. "Both of you are wrong," he said. "Anybody who knows anything can see that this elephant is like a snake."

The fourth reached out his arms, and grasped one of the elephant's legs. "Oh, how blind you are!" he said. "It is very plain to me that he is round and tall like a tree."

The fifth was a very tall man, and he chanced to take hold of the elephant's ear. "The blindest man ought to know that this beast is not like any of the things that you name," he said. "He is exactly like a huge fan."

The sixth was very blind indeed, and it was some time before he could find the elephant at all. At last he seized the animal's tail. "O foolish fellows!" he cried. "You surely have lost your senses. This elephant is not like a wall, or a spear, or a snake, or a tree; neither is he like a fan. But any man with a par-ti-cle of sense can see that he is exactly like a rope."

Then the elephant moved on, and the six blind men sat by the roadside all day, and quarreled about him. Each believed that he knew just how the animal looked; and each called the others hard names because they did not agree with him. Without realising that none of them were right.


one more from the Special guest that you mentioned...

this is not about People who are not in the show.. it’s about the lack of skill that the current FL has..

she is good in some scenes like ones with some comical elements but the 95% job is to cry bucket load of tears and make us feel the pain that she is going through...

Erica has bad dialogue delivery.. her voice is monotonous.. she can’t modulate her voice to give the necessary punch to the lines..

on top of that her Hindi is bad.. she makes me cringe every time she messes up the grammar.. Hindi is not my mother tongue but it’s my most used language and every time she messes it, it looses the impact.

Smita Patil a Maharashtrian was flawless as far as Hindi dialogue delivery and voice modulation was concerned.. grammar flawless.. her eyes spoke volumes.. I would suggest watch “ Arth” and see what powerhouse performance she gave.

You love the way you want but don’t expect people to just sit and paise bad performance.. if you expect people to praise ur post then definitely expect the criticism too..

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 5 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: SheAish

Both hopeful and grace have posted in a very dignified way, I don't get this bold: "like if you cared for perception you wouldn't be writing this isn't it?". Excuse me, but which rule states that legends have to be legends for everyone or they can't be compared..? Arey if Grace thinks Erica is similar to Smita, its none of anyone else business and no one has the right to judge her on it. Its' her freaking perception....iss forum meytho basic concept of right and wrong is 'subjective' why is it such a big deal if grace compares Smita with Erica? Why can't she express her perception?

Those who disagree, its their choice too....she gave her answer in a dignified manner too....again her perception.....Are we seriously going to vilify her here for her right to expression that too in a very graceful manner.....??? If there is one thing that describes grace's behavior in this forum its graceful...please spare her what ever anyone's problem with her perception is!

I wouldn't have said that if I didnt read words like bullies and hypocrites . Discussion will remain civil as long as actors and their work and characters is being discussed .... If it was only about erica and smita patil ,it would have remained a discussion ...Calling someone a hypocrite for having a perception is what happened in this thread and it happens in all threads..both sides....the moment anyone opposes a thought he becomes a bully ....I think everyone fails to see that before calling others hypocrites for having an opinion ,they too fall in the same category when it comes to reverting back.... ? There will be varied responses for a post , nobody is being vilified. For every statement or a thought there will be opposing views ,not all will agree... I dont agree with grace. That's it . What is the best way to disagree ? Like the tm is free to have her perception , others have their freedom too to disagree and write what they feel about the actress in question.... why are others hypocrites while those who agree are the only ones who are right ?? Why is her right to express being protected and not mine? That's all I am asking . What's the point behind making a post ?that all will agree ? Like there was a post about lotus and mud a few days back , I didnt go there and write lotus and mud will take offense..but here acting comparison was made with an ace actress.. Hence such strong reactions.


Do me a favor. Write a response from my side which says that I dont agree ... I couldn't think of worse actress than erica and a better actress than smita if I try to make a comparison. 😳

Edited by _charu_ - 5 years ago
Hari73 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: grace4317

Bold - It's fine if you felt so. If I compared her to Smita Patil, that doesn't mean like Eri is awarded with some highest honour. Smita Patil too had her own flaws and I am not an obsessed/blind fan to feel that Eri is some queen or devi of acting. When I compared her to Smita, I just meant that Eri reminds me of Smita when she performs in emotional scenes or in scenes you are meant to feel dull. Today, Eri's portrayal of Pre clearly reminded me of Smita Patil's role in Arth. Hence i commented so. No need to feel so hyper about it.

I am happy to see you comparing eri with smitha. I did compared eri with smitha during krp days. Eri really brings that intense atmosphere from her acting. I am happy its not just me, someone else also feel the same..🤗

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".