Gauri's Reasoning.... *Ahem*

sareeta thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Well, keeping aside the fact that I havent been particularly praising for her act and her reasoning ever since the leap , well today's reasoning of hers for bringing out the truth about Nikhila was to save her relation with Shiv ??!!!!...*Ahem..*..

Well before you guys pounce on me for saying that , here is my take...

Gauri has always been shown or portrayed as someone who is selfless..( Although I have believed otherwise, her being the most selfish in entire khaandaan and my reasons have been repeated in several posts.. )....and one who will do anything for Shiv and his happiness... but the reasoning she gives today, saying, "Apne rishte ko bachaane , main Badi maa sacchai sabke saamne laaongi"...

Well had this been done , for the sake of Shiv, who needed to know about his Mother , than jus for being her Hubby and father of her children, would have given the touch of selflessness, that is she is so portrayed to have.

I am not agaisnt her thinking about her family and her own happiness.. but well blame it on teh kreatives or the dialougue writer, but that one line, marred the selfless aspect of the character of Gauri...

And personally.. for me, my take on her being the most selfish has only been strengthened...

Your thoughts are welcome...

PS: No offence to anyone who thinks otherwise.. these are jus my thoughts and my take on the single line she utters .. for a reasoning , that changed the dynamics of how she treats her relationship.. and her priority....😊

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1k

Users

7

Frequent Posters

Howlarious thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#2

Well am not really sure what to say. Gauri always wants whats "best" for her family. Don't know what "best" is. Thats all am gonna say 😳

Edited by Anisha7 - 18 years ago
Catwoman thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
I total agree with you and i have found Gauri's mantra which she sings daily!!! 😆

sajnaa Ji Vaari Vaari Jaanu Ji Mein

Tu Hi To Mera Sansaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai
Charno Mein Jo Na Jagah Paanu Ji Mein
To Mera Jeena Hi Bekaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai - 2

Mera Maan Hai Tu
Abhimaan Hai Tu
Meri Pooja Hai Tu
Mera Dhyaan Hai Tu
Tu Devata Mein Pujaaran
Sanjnaa Tujpe Mein Arpaan
Tere Gungaan Hi To Gaanu Ji Mein
Oh Tere Gungaan Hi To Gaanu Ji Mein
Tu Hi To Mera Sansaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai - 2
Sajnaa Ji Vaari Vaari Jaanu Ji Mein - 2
Tu Hi To Mera Sansaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai - 2

Love Kat!

btw i love this song and think it suits Gauri to a "T"
Edited by Catwoman - 18 years ago
Howlarious thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Catwoman

I total agree with you and i have found Gauri's mantra which she sings daily!!! 😆

sajnaa Ji Vaari Vaari Jaanu Ji Mein

Tu Hi To Mera Sansaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai
Charno Mein Jo Na Jagah Paanu Ji Mein
To Mera Jeena Hi Bekaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai - 2

Mera Maan Hai Tu
Abhimaan Hai Tu
Meri Pooja Hai Tu
Mera Dhyaan Hai Tu
Tu Devata Mein Pujaaran
Sanjnaa Tujpe Mein Arpaan
Tere Gungaan Hi To Gaanu Ji Mein
Oh Tere Gungaan Hi To Gaanu Ji Mein
Tu Hi To Mera Sansaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai - 2
Sajnaa Ji Vaari Vaari Jaanu Ji Mein - 2
Tu Hi To Mera Sansaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai - 2

Love Kat!

btw i love this song and think it suits Gauri to a "T"

😆 Great song!!!!!! 😳

sareeta thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
Totally agree with you Kat... its sure ... is perfectooooo for her... especially the bit

"Tere Gungaan Hi To Gaanu Ji Mein
Oh Tere Gungaan Hi To Gaanu Ji Mein
Tu Hi To Mera Sansaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai - 2 "

😆
smartc thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
Sareeta, I havent watched the episode yet. Let me watch it and I will then comment on it 😉 ~

Sana..Sneezing her soul out..
Catwoman thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sareeta

Totally agree with you Kat... its sure ... is perfectooooo for her... especially the bit

"Tere Gungaan Hi To Gaanu Ji Mein
Oh Tere Gungaan Hi To Gaanu Ji Mein
Tu Hi To Mera Sansaar Hai
Aisa Mera Pyaar Hai - 2 "

😆

See i know my tunes i have one for Ippy and Shiv!!

Thank U!!

desi chic thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: smartc

Sareeta, I havent watched the episode yet. Let me watch it and I will then comment on it 😉 ~

Sana..Sneezing her soul out..

Same... lemme watch it first... Waise Sana Di... aap teekh ho na?😕 Mausam kaisa hai jaani?

Cheers,

dc

smartc thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
Ok, Sareeta babez, this is what I heard:

"Maire aur aapke rishte ku todne ke liye badi maa itna gir gayee kai wo aapke hamshakal ku leker ayee ta ke hum dono ke beech wo ghalat fahmian paida ker sakain? Aaj badi maa ne humei laa ker us mor per khara ker diya hai jahan ghalat bhi hum dono ke saath hi hua hai aur uski sazaa bhi hum dono ko hi mil rahi hai. Mujhe maaf ker dijeye Shiv, najane kitni baar meri wajah se aapko takleef pohanchi hai.."

My Take: This paragraph to me shows Gauri to be selfless. I don't see her whining about how she got manipulated and abused physically by samar. Not once I heard her complain about how much emotional abuse she had to endure because of this twin twist by badi maa.. But she is more concerned and is apologizing for her behavior to Shiv where she was rather begging Shiv to believe her when she brought up Badi maa's name due to be instigator behind things. Gauri's character here is apologetic to the pain and cause she caused Shiv by having her to choose b/w his mom and his wife.. I don't see her crying in that alley about how much she endured personally at the wrath of that evil witch from garbage land aka Nikhila.

2nd Part:

"Aur ab mai unki sachai sabke saamne laoongi. Aapko sab kuch bata doongi Shiv. Jaanti hoon, badi maa ka ye chahra deikh ker aapko bohat takleef hogi. Mager apne rishte ku bachane ke liye mujhe aapko itni takleef deni paregi Shiv..

My Take: Call me naive but which woman in this world would let another person walk all over her dreams and shatter her life? If Gauri were to be shown all crying and whimsical here portraying somebody who would not dare say a word against her badi maa for Shiv's happiness, then we'd be crucifying and dissecting her inside out once again. I am actually happy that she has the guts to reiterate the fact that badi maa is the problem here. With Gauri, there is not one life attached but there are 3 other innocent lives attached who need their parents guidance and support together. Like Sareeta mentioned, she is not thinking of being selfless anymore here. Agreed! But if she doesn't do so, 3 more lives will be destroyed. Her being selfless now would rather be senseless to her own children. For hypothetical case: what if Gauri kept quiet and didn't utter a single word against her badi maa and let her ruin her marriage? She'll be all high and mighty for being selfless then, right? But what about her own children when they grow up and ask her why she kept quiet and ruined their lives? They would then say that:

"For the sake of her selfless act, she let badi maa destroy their lives. Isn't that being selflish towards her own agenda in that case?"

Moral of the story: Look one way or another, she had to take this step. Insaan kissi haal mai khush nahi yaar. Each and every action of yours in this world gets scrutinized and pounced upon whether u intend to do something good/selfless or not. Gauri, unfortunately, is in the midst of such a dilemma now..


3rd Part: (Shiv-Gauri)

"Shiv, mai aajtak aapko kitna ghalat samajhti rahi. Ke aap mujh se nafrat karte hain, bacho se nafrat kerte hain aur na jaane kya kya.. Mujhe aesa nahi sochna chahiye tha Shiv. .... Per shaid badi maa per aapka yakeen hamare rishte ke yakeen per bhari par raha hai. "

My take: Reference to her world, her bacha's there.. U have to understand that motherhood changes everything. My mom always tells me that I won't understand the love and bond a mother shares with her children until and unless I become one. And rightly so.. If saving her life and her duniya, her kids, and her rishta is a selfish act, then so be it! I am all for it rather than have her kids come back after a 20 year leap and blame her all over again for giving them a life from hell in the form of their broken family.. Again, it depends on a person's perspective. I see Sareeta's point loud and clear, but I also see that whether she goes left or takes the right, she will be criticized nonetheless. So might as well do what's right for her relationship as a wife and her relationship as a mother.

Conclusion: Loved the lines where she said, "Ho ga wahi ju usne te ker rakha hai (referring to God Almighty).. Jitna neeche gir ke chalain chalni hai, chal lijeye.. Mai aapki tarah neechi tu nahi gir sakti leiken haan, aapki her chaal ka jawaab doongi mai.. Yaad rakhna.."


Cheers,
Sana~
Edited by smartc - 18 years ago
smartc thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: desi chic

Same... lemme watch it first... Waise Sana Di... aap teekh ho na?😕 Mausam kaisa hai jaani?

Cheers,

dc



Inteehaaa ho gayeee... Is zukaaam ki.... *achoooooooooon*
Ayeee naa phir khaber... Mere araam ki.... *achooooooon*

Thanxx for asking neetu.. Bas.. Na hi pooch kuriye.. 😕

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".