|firefliesHaven|MaNan AT#141|Boxing that 'X' - Page 102

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

112k

Users

72

Likes

5.2k

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
All this stuff about giving her SUBSTANTIAL monologues and introspection scenes is being said since AGES...but time and again they bring her back to the SAME point...this is what made me chuck the show during the FC phase too...and at one point in the trauma track as well...they drag and make her look a mute idiot at CRUCIAL points, thus leading to a disconnect.

And it bothers me cuz I truly have admired this characterization otherwise in the jhund of nonsensical, vapid female leads on TV who just give empty bhaashans and are hollow in their idealisms...when they reduce Nandu to a confused, aimless idiot but try to PROJECT her as someone who has a plan, knows what she's doing when she's totally out of her depth...well clearly shows the writers have NO PLAN and are just throwing whatever they want to on her for the heck of it...so NO, I do not see ANY justification for what they are showing on her.
Edited by AreYaar - 10 years ago
deepa2012 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Personally to me, this is about the fact that they made Nandini looks STUPID and AIMLESS.


Why even set her up as being intuitive and thoughtful about this if end mein it was just going to come down to "The deal is off"?😕 Where is the Nandu who was watching Arya with intelligent eyes, not buying his shit even as he tried to act oversmart with her? I feel cheated for THAT Nandu...when I read in the LU ki she's busy giving a final great speech before saying, "The deal is off", I just wanted to bang my head somewhere...SO hollow and SO pointless they made this entire sequence of events.


You know I can take/zone out Arya ki bakwaas IF and ONLY IF you give me an intelligent Nandu or Manik handling the other sideys ki bakwaas...but what did you do yesterday? Just made her give yet another hollow/pointless speech and that's supposed to impress me? Oh wow look Nandu is sunaaoing to Arya yet again...SO fruitful that is. I'm blown away...then what the hell were the last 2-3 weeks about? KYUN KHICHDI BANAATE HO? HAR BAAR...BAAR BAAR.



And to those saying that Nandu couldn't tell Manik cuz he would be angry and all...ek tareeka hota hai intuitiveness dikhaane ka that I don't think I need to EXPLAIN to the writers who just last week gave us a beautiful scene about Manik saying he'll wait for her to tell him even though this situation scares him so much...and Nandu didn't JUMP to DEFENDING this loser Arya in THAT moment as a reply...she just teared up with a smile...neither accepting or denying in that moment that she was indeed hiding something from Manik...THAT is the intuitive communication that is MaNan...not this NONSENSE they are showing ki just seconds after someone makes an attempt on Manik's life IN FRONT OF HER EYES, Nandu is STILL busy JUSTIFYING THAT PERSON to Manik...No...Just NO...Please stop this bakwaas and digging yourselves into a hole you can't come out of...Nandu is compassionate but not a FOOL.

THIS .. Just this 👍🏼
Though I still feel that Manik's anger is an issue for Nandini,just not the most compelling reason .😊
chickky thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Manik confronts Mukti on where was he..

Manik suddenly notices Alya and asks what's wrong ..Alya says she need rest..

Both encourage that to speak up though Manik don't know the context..
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
So let me get this straight...Nandu ACTUALLY trusted Arya? LOLLL Umm then why were they showing her confronting Arya after the saw incident? Or even before that she ALWAYS looked at him SKEPTICALLY...so what was that all supposed to be mean? That Nandu was suspicious but still trusted him to keep his word? LOL do the writers even SEE what they are writing for her? Makes NO sense...If you had atleast let her intelligence win this one and shown that even though she was giving Arya a chance, she didn't REALLY trust him...this could be salvaged...but GOOD LORD you ppl are ACTUALLY trying to make this LITERAL in terms of trust? Wow

Seriously Jotwani Baba, aapka bhai-behen pyar alone isn't going to salvage Arya-Nandu...please stop forcing something that isn't working.
chickky thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Manik shows the strum and asks Mukti how did he find it on that site..
Mukti lies that she don't know..

She defends that she's been with Alya as she don't trust Harshad ..
Mukti wants to figure what's plan..

Manik is upset as why all are lieing..

Manik ponders where's cabir
chickky thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Manik along with Nandini comes to principal and says she can't perform with Arya.
The radio O2 guy wants to come back on Navya for teaming up with Cabir in past, so she says Incase if Arya can't be part, then tram be disqualified
Sparkle_Trisha thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: deepa2012

THIS .. Just this 👍🏼
Though I still feel that Manik's anger is an issue for Nandini,just not the most compelling reason .😊


Okay everybody keeps talking about Manik's anger and it's a legit point we can't just forget his anger during the valentines track.
But my question is wouldn't it be better to sit him down and explain everything calmly? I mean he always does listen to what she has to say.
He's bound to get more angry if he finds out that She lied to him and put herself in danger even when everyone told her that Arya can not to be trusted.
chickky thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Navya and Arya conversing about wining..
Arya says we will win only if we participate and Nandini don't want to participate..

Arya says if he's not in team he don't want to participate ..

Navni conflict coming looks like ..
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
LOL they are mixing up this Talent Hunt issue in the middle of everything again...how does the stupid talent hunt matter now when they have to resolve the Arya issue first?


Manik has taken charge to sort out the Talent Hunt issue for Nandu now but core issue still remains
twinkle10 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Everyone just perform solo. Problem solved.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".