Over Reaction.. And how! - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

103

Views

7.7k

Users

34

Likes

235

Frequent Posters

XOXOgossipgirl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: spnfan

I yavent watched the episode till now and after reading some negative comments and now positive comments am confused... I watch wh and I like vibha in it...

So if I go by the negative comments n manik actually had real feelings for veebha then I dont like manik and veebha other wise its ok...
So can anyone without any partiality explain me what happened b/w manik and veebha in detail


Okay, so without ANY partiality let me tell you EXACTLY what happened.

1) Promo where they show Manik telling Veebha that she was the first girl to reject him. (Did not appear in the episodes)

2) Yesterday they showed Veebha video call with Fab 5. When Manik took the phone, she looked away and said no I will not look at you. He said seriously? That happened 3 years ago! She's like no you give away the phone only then will I look. So he gave it away.

3) Today once they reach WH, some girl comes and says Manik Sir, Veebha Ma;am has said that she is waiting for oyu where you saw her last.

4) Cut to flash back. Where they show Veebha in the WH uniform in the classical singing room. Manik, also in uniform, comes there and says I can't believe it's the last day. Then he says how both of them could have happened (as a couple) if she hadn't said no. But she says no. Aaliya has loved you since the 7th std. She deserves your true love. Then he argues and says something on the lines that he would have left Aaliya for her. And she is like no. You need to realzie how important true love is. He says what is the difference between love and true love. She is like there is a difference. And one day, you will realize the difference. They argue about it further. It turns into a fight. And they decide that they don't want to see each others' faces anymore. Manik says it out of anger but she means it seriously. And she says that until you can't have a level headed conversation with me, I won't talk to you or see you. He says fine. It's the last day anyway. It's gonna be easy to do that.

5) Back to the present. He enters the room and she is there, facing away from him. He calls out to her. She gerts happy but doesn't look at him. He keeps going in front of her but she turns around. She says only if you promise to have a proper conversation will I look at you. He says fine. Yes baba. You were right about everything. She gets happy and they hug. A nice long hug, that good friends share after not seeing each other for long. He tells her that it's been so long but he still hasn't found a FRIEND as good as her. Fab 4 join them.

THAT WAS ALL.
XOXOgossipgirl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: ...Oyshee...

GOD! finally...FINALLY! 👏 👍🏼

like seriously girl, thanks a tonn for this post... i was about to make one along the lines!!

kab se I.. ke post mei gala phaad rahi hoon..🥱

*bear hugs* :)

63


Thank you for all your positive posts!!! I love how there are atleast few people who think like me. Cause while watching it I was like wait a minute. WHAT IS THE BIG DEAL!!?? We love this show cause it'a a youth show and cause it is so real. All of this HAPPENS in real life. People get emotional. People face the past. Especially when you go back to school. All those memories come back to life. And I genuinely felt it was a Fab5 integration with WH. KY2 is not affected in ANY way at all!! :/
spnfan thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Posts (July 2022) Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: XOXOgossipgirl


Okay, so without ANY partiality let me tell you EXACTLY what happened.

1) Promo where they show Manik telling Veebha that she was the first girl to reject him. (Did not appear in the episodes)

2) Yesterday they showed Veebha video call with Fab 5. When Manik took the phone, she looked away and said no I will not look at you. He said seriously? That happened 3 years ago! She's like no you give away the phone only then will I look. So he gave it away.

3) Today once they reach WH, some girl comes and says Manik Sir, Veebha Ma;am has said that she is waiting for oyu where you saw her last.

4) Cut to flash back. Where they show Veebha in the WH uniform in the classical singing room. Manik, also in uniform, comes there and says I can't believe it's the last day. Then he says how both of them could have happened (as a couple) if she hadn't said no. But she says no. Aaliya has loved you since the 7th std. She deserves your true love. Then he argues and says something on the lines that he would have left Aaliya for her. And she is like no. You need to realzie how important true love is. He says what is the difference between love and true love. She is like there is a difference. And one day, you will realize the difference. They argue about it further. It turns into a fight. And they decide that they don't want to see each others' faces anymore. Manik says it out of anger but she means it seriously. And she says that until you can't have a level headed conversation with me, I won't talk to you or see you. He says fine. It's the last day anyway. It's gonna be easy to do that.

5) Back to the present. He enters the room and she is there, facing away from him. He calls out to her. She gerts happy but doesn't look at him. He keeps going in front of her but she turns around. She says only if you promise to have a proper conversation will I look at you. He says fine. Yes baba. You were right about everything. She gets happy and they hug. A nice long hug, that good friends share after not seeing each other for long. He tells her that it's been so long but he still hasn't found a FRIEND as good as her. Fab 4 join them.

THAT WAS ALL.

So nothing like
1) he said veebha was his true love
2) cheated on alya
3) manik's character assasination
4) forgetting nandu

Why cant people make positive post first??
When I opened the forum it was full of neg post saying manik is destroued etc etc... It really turns ur mood of...
XOXOgossipgirl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: ishitaa22

YAAA...thanku so much fr dis. I agree wid u completly!!
Copy pasting frm wat i wrote in some oder post...

Yaar guys can i jst say somethins...i dnt want to offend nyone n its completly wat i perceived frm d episode!!
I for one dnt think ki dey destroyed Manik's character...for me he was totally in character actally.
I just saw d parts of V & Manik's convo...
First lets see abt d FB...
Many are saying ki he was running behind V and cheating on alya...dat was so not d case!!
He jst said ki hmari isse achi bhi memories ho skt thi,,,,if she wuld have said Yes...dats not cheating, d manik before nandini can totally say dose things...and we all knw hw manik was wid alya before meeting nandini.. u guys remember na 7yrs anniversary scene, his expressions!!
And basic thing...Dat was A FLASHBACK...he cant be d manik he is now...can he?
And in dat for manik...he didnt belive in love...wen he said "ya, wat we felt, haina?" to V he was jst retorting bak to V abt her true love bhashan!!
Manik was totally manik...in character...angry, unremorsefull and not understanding her point of view!
And now coming bak to Present...
Guys seeing one of ur best friends aftr soo long...u have missed dem u do get a little emotional!
Dey just hugged guys!
And he said he is on her level now...he understands her level, where she was coming frm abt True Love...and he agreed dat he was wrong and things have changed!!
Now dats d manik we know...present manik...Nandini's Manik!!

I think people are jst comparing FB manik, to present Manik...which is wrong cause both of dem are completly different
So all in all i think the character of Manik was done complete justice!!

So i think CV's are amazing...dey did not destroy d character dey themselves made.
De understand d inner workings of Maniks mind...his character...hw will dey be able to go completly offbook!!
Sry fr dis...got so big..but jst wanted to share my opinion!


Thank you for this!!! I don't understand why people who are watching KY2 since day 1 are not realising that at the end of the day, this show IS all about MaNan. They are going to focus on these two, no matter what.

Look at Manik's growth as a person. Look at what he was and what he's become. Even the conversation he had with Veebha (in the flashback) was WHEN HE WAS IN WH. It was 3 years back!!!! It was the OLD MANIK. The Manik we all know and love is the SPACE Manik. The Manik that Nandini has brought about a change in. The Manik who knows or rather is getting to know what real love is. :/

So I don't know why people are saying that his character is butchered. In fact, I love how he loves his friends. I always stand by the fact that despite having a love life, don't ever change your equation with your friends. And that is what I love most about Manik.

And I also don't know why people are giving up on MaNan. I can't force my opinion on them ofcourse, but I just don't get it.
XOXOgossipgirl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#45
So nothing like
1) he said veebha was his true love
2) cheated on alya
3) manik's character assasination
4) forgetting nandu

Why cant people make positive post first??
When I opened the forum it was full of neg post saying manik is destroued etc etc... It really turns ur mood of...

Nope. Nothing at all.
ishitaa22 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: XOXOgossipgirl


Thank you for this!!! I don't understand why people who are watching KY2 since day 1 are not realising that at the end of the day, this show IS all about MaNan. They are going to focus on these two, no matter what.

Look at Manik's growth as a person. Look at what he was and what he's become. Even the conversation he had with Veebha (in the flashback) was WHEN HE WAS IN WH. It was 3 years back!!!! It was the OLD MANIK. The Manik we all know and love is the SPACE Manik. The Manik that Nandini has brought about a change in. The Manik who knows or rather is getting to know what real love is. :/

So I don't know why people are saying that his character is butchered. In fact, I love how he loves his friends. I always stand by the fact that despite having a love life, don't ever change your equation with your friends. And that is what I love most about Manik.

And I also don't know why people are giving up on MaNan. I can't force my opinion on them ofcourse, but I just don't get it.




Seriously...
Seeing all dese negative comments i was really surprised wen i actually watched d episode. Cause i didnt find any diversions frm his character.
If a person is in love...dat does not define his whole life!
He can have a life besides it too...
So if he was happy to be in WH and to see his old friend...dat does not mean he forgot abt Nandini. He was not alone for sometime to even think abt her. He was jst taking a break frm all d confusing and craziness in his head!!
Edited by ishitaa22 - 10 years ago
shibz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: XOXOgossipgirl


4) Cut to flash back. Where they show Veebha in the WH uniform in the classical singing room. Manik, also in uniform, comes there and says I can't believe it's the last day. Then he says how both of them could have happened (as a couple) if she hadn't said no. But she says no. Aaliya has loved you since the 7th std. She deserves your true love. Then he argues and says something on the lines that he would have left Aaliya for her. And she is like no. You need to realzie how important true love is. He says what is the difference between love and true love. She is like there is a difference. And one day, you will realize the difference. They argue about it further. It turns into a fight. And they decide that they don't want to see each others' faces anymore. Manik says it out of anger but she means it seriously. And she says that until you can't have a level headed conversation with me, I won't talk to you or see you. He says fine. It's the last day anyway. It's gonna be easy to do that.

@bold, you don't find that out of character? Are you sure you have watched and followed the same KY2 we have? I don't want to say more.. because I know it isn't acceptable of Manik's character from what we have been shown before this crap fest happened! So I'm not even considering these 2 epis for the sake of my sanity.
XOXOgossipgirl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: shibz

@bold, you don't find that out of character? Are you sure you have watched and followed the same KY2 we have? I don't want to say more.. because I know it isn't acceptable of Manik's character from what we have been shown before this crap fest happened! So I'm not even considering these 2 epis for the sake of my sanity.


No honestly I don't because that was the Manik before Nandini. He was flamboyant. He was a casanova. But he has changed now. He has changed after Nandini. And he said that to Veebha in the flashback. NOT IN THE PRESENT. So yes, it is out of his CURRENT character. If he had said that to her NOW, I would have been mad. But he had said it ALL THOSE YEARS back. So no. I didn't have a problem cause it didn't affect THE CURRENT MANIK is any way.
baisakh45 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#49
let me tell you first- i just loved your post.everyone has a past. we should not judge anyone on the basis of it when he is a changed person.but anyway i hope everyone will be able to understand it.
Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#50
ydays merger epi ws DISASTER coz fab5 were shown only for some seconds...but todays epi...i LOVED it...coz ky2 got deservin importance n this is wht u call a merger epi..!!

n i loved all scenes today n there ws NO FREAKING CHAR ASSASSINATION of Manik neither yday nor today...!!


i hv already wrote big fat ramayan here on y i din find nything wrong on Manik's side for yday epi...so wnt repeat again here...so jst postin link
120407664

coming to todays epi...today i could CONNECT to story flow in this merger epi..loved hw they showed bonding of Veebha with fab 5 esp Manik..!! n Manik-Veebha reunion ws simply a cute reunion when two besties met aftr a long time..!! Parth n Anupriya were so good in tht scene..!!

nywz am glad i could find this post here as i could also do my rant here..!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".