2. Inder (dead, scratched face) - He made his presence known.
2.5. Shakti Devi (Survived) - We know that Shakti Devi was present in the temple as well during that time, but she stayed hidden during the aarti.
3. <I think there was one other guy?>
4. Inder's Assistant (dead, unusual: car accident) - he escaped alive from the temple but later died in a car accident, which was unlike the other deaths. Maybe it was a planned attack, or maybe Kaal Bhairav really did kill him for being a douche.
5. Rahul (barely survived, scratched face) - Got scratched up like the other, but survived.
6. Gauri (survived) - Kaal Bhairav's Ring O' Fire protected her from the doggos. Shortly after, blood tears began.
7. Sheru (dead, unusual: chopped off head) - Was left in temple, managed to escape, and then got his head chopped off by Headless Warrior (adding in that villager guy who died as well, he was unimportant though)
8. Mahesh (kidnapped, probably alive) - First victim of the Kaal Bhairav Tears of Blood Trial.
9. Saumya (kidnapped, alive) - Second victim of KBTOBT.
10. Vaid (dead, unusual: stabbed with trishul): Third victim of KBTOBT. Escaped, got caught by Datta Thakur, taken back by Lakhan, stabbed via trishul.
11. Dead Guy with Red Dirt (dead, unusual: stabbed with trishul): Probably a victim of Rahul's brilliant (dumb) idea to blow up the tunnel. Whoever's behind this had to get rid of the body, hence ...
12. Gauri's Brother (Dead, unusual: stabbed with Trishul) - Fourth victim of KBTOBT, Datta Thakur saw him leaving the temple after hours with Pujari. Was helping Rahul (that was the dumbest idea ever, but that's another post), Gauri blurted it out, got killed.
The killings have gotten more violent as Rahul got closer and closer to the truth. I'll sleep on this one and come back with a theory later on. Feel free to post any ideas, etc.