Originally posted by: ghalibmirza
abhay thank you for your candid reply as i am always up for sensible discussions!..first of all i have not watched the epi yet but responded as per WUs and various comments, none of my networks are working and i probably will not be able to watch it plus just like you i am busy as hell!..lets begin one at a time..first of all i did not mention ruk and neither wanted to bring her up its just one comment out of the blue mentioned my old post which i kinda remember..i must say my posts are popular..people remember😆..anyway my main point is that i feel sad when it comes to Akbar, the whole credit goes to his hindu begum for his greatness whereas the reality is something else and when it comes to indian rulers such as ashoka or MP the credit is all theirs and their wives are only their love interests even though they might have contributed more than is required..and here muz might have been powerful but akbar was akbar,,in fact he sometimes did not even listen to his 9 gems..he only did what he thought was right and was not led by anyone like a baby..he had a brain of his own and we should not take the credits from him for what he did and this is more to do with NRs and the way the serial is going..well abhay no qualms just a sad feeling when i hear and read some biased views about a muslim ruler..nothing else!
MANDY I AM IN COMPLETE AGREEMENT OF YOUR POST. FOR A LONG TIME NOW AKBAR IS BEING SHOWN BY OUR GREAT CVS AS, NOT AS THE GREAT EMPEROR THAT HE WAS IN HISTORY, BUT A PERSON OF NEAR NORMAL INTELLIGENCE -
1. AKBAR- SALIM-JODHA-RUKS EPISODES - BOTH JODHA AND JALAL ARE CLEARLY ESTRANGED AS FAR AS SALIM IS CONCERNED. RUKS HAS MANAGED TO GET HIM UNDER HER CONTROL FULLY. SPECIALLY IF YOU SEE EPISODE NO 399 IT IS CLEAR THAT AKBAR SAW SALIM DRUNK AND MISBEHAVE AND IMMEDIATELY SENT HIM TO WAR. HE DID NOT CHOOSE TO VERIFY OR FIND PUT EXACTLY WHAT HAD HAPPENED. EVEN JODHA FOR THAT MATTER IS SHOWN OBLIVIOUS OF ALL RUKS ANTICS. SALIM ONLY BEHAVES NORMALLY WITH HIS PARENTS A FEW TIMES. AT ALL OTHER TIMESHE IS SPEWING VENOM AGAINST THEM
2. IN THE RESHAM KHAN- SHAREEF FATHER EPISODE JALAL NEVER EVER REALISED THAT IT WAS RUKS WHO WAS THE AFEEM GIVER. THIS IS SPECIALLY WHEN SALIMA HAD POINTED A FINGER AT RUKS. EVERYTHING JUST PASSED OVER N RUKS WAS SCOT FREE. NEVER DID JALAL FEEL LIKE DIGGING DEEPER
3. IN BENAZIR TRACK AGAIN JALAL STARTED WITH MAKING JODHA FEEL JEALOUS, BUT THEN SUDDENLY ENDED UP AGREEING TO MARRY BENZO. RUKS AND MAHAM WERE PLOTTING AND PLANNING AND YET JALAL HAD NO CLUE. ONLY WHEN JODHA WAS UNCONSCIOUS DID HER REALIZE HIS ERROR
4. EVEN IN THE RUKS MISCARRIAGE EPISODE, JALAL AGREED TO WHATEVER RUKS FED HIM WITH. NEVER DID HE TRY TO FIND OUT THE DEEPER TRUTH.
IF LOOK BACK AT OTHER EPISODES IN THE SERIAL, THERE WOULD BE SEVERAL SUCH INSTANCES WHEN MAHAMANGA AND RUKS HAVE BEEN SHOWN TO HAVE FAR SUPERIOR BRAIN LEVELS AS COMPARED FO JODHA AND JALAL
HISTORY TELLS US THE GREATNESS OF THE MAN THAT JALALUDDIN AKBAR WAS, MY ONLY ENTREATY IS THAT CVS ARE NOT GIVING HIM HIS DUE.
I AGREE WITH ABHAY'S HISTORY AND RADHIKA'S PARIENT REPLIES TOO
BUT WHERE IS THE JALAL WHO WAS A FORCE TO RECKON WITH AND WHERE IS THE MUZ WHO WAS KNOWN HER INTELLIGENCE. WHY IS IT OK FOR CVS TO SHOW RUKS AS INTELLIGENT, MAHAM ANGA AS INTELLIGENT AND WHY IS IT OK FOR US TO ACCEPT THAT IF THEY SHOW HISTORY WITHOUT NR THEN VIEWERS WILL FIND IT BORING
WHERE ARE THE JODHA AND JALAL THAT WE WOULD ALL LOVE TO SEE
Edited by Sabdabhala - 10 years ago
30