What went wrong with serial?

myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
What went truly wrong with this serial?
I have disliked Benazir track and the Mathura track and the Begums fighting war and even Atifa track to some extent as we know that nothing of this nonsense happened in real history
But the Salim punishment track takes the cake. This track is truly getting on viewers nerves.
What exactly irks me is that Ruqaiah is giving opium to a small child with so many maids, soldiers etc all around
Lesser said about parents of Salim the better, mother only fights for criminals like Sharif, Abul Mali and Khyber and for a slave kid and father he cannot punish dreaded criminals of his family but targets his innocent child and his wife Jodha
Has Akbar ever thought why Salim lied because he was scared of Akbar? What sort of love of father is this where a child is so terrified of father and lies and hides etc
Then comes his justification of this harsh punishment that he wants his son to be human at childhood unlike him who took 30 years and a massacre to be one. But has he ever thought Salim is different human he is not violent like Akbar and cares even for animals and dreaded criminals. And Jodha instead of trying to explain Akbar is supporting him in name of making Salim great?
Now we hear the child may die and Salim may have to stay in hut serving old woman all life. What sort of NR is this?
All audience knows Salim was trained in war fare and went to battle at young age. So why show this nonsensical track?
Edited by myviewprem - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

5.7k

Users

11

Likes

73

Frequent Posters

elasingh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
two things went wrong with the serial ...One is Jalal blaming Jo for Hussain's death and ditching her for three years...When it was so obvious that it was Ruku's mistake that killed kids...but he said nothing to her...remained spineless as usual...
And second is Ruku's glorification...If a Salim who hit the boy unintentionally , still is punished then what makes Ruku go scott free...? She was an adult and her spite and jealousy towards Jodha made her bring zeenat...and caused kid's death...Why was she not chastised by Jalal and how and on what basis Jo was punished?
And you know what Ruk has guts to drug salim and instigate him against his own parents becoz she knows she will get away with it too
Edited by elasingh - 10 years ago
amina1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
From the time of sujamal track,the downfall of JA,from than on everything went wrong i skip hh baby sharing track,now the worst is rukiaya giving opiume to a very small child the worst thing to see on tv,cant believe BT can come up with something so horrible ,for me friday was the last episode,no matter what nothing is bringing me to watch JA,i liked the kids but thats not enough,this is worst than sbs,now its feel like horror show and thats not my cup,of tea
katana thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Now we hear the child may die and Salim may have to stay in hut serving old woman all life.
😡 😭
anael24 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Yes i completely agree
in fact as from the benazir track evrything went wrong...and this is not a HISTORICAL SHOW!
1. A third person was introduced to seduce the male like in any other typical serial
2..Its the woman who had to prove herself from a list of adulterous allegation.
3.An infinite triangle love.
4.A mahan jodha(but in every serial the bahu is mahan)
5.No respect b/w wife and husband.(each week they returned back to square1)
6.Jodha caring more for others than her husband(preventing us from having nhok jhoks and lovely scenes b/w husband and wife)
7.Sharing is caring but this wasnt sharing..this was giving it away like a mere object(hussein)
8.A supposedly secured palace but more like ths grocery at the corner of your street!
9.When it comes to a "bachpan ki dhost" , everything is possible..even torturing a certain MUZ.
10.Others have more power than the so called "king and Queen"..

At the end i wonder where the story revolved around jodha and akbar...it was more about enemies...screams...fights...roaming around to overhear a convo...or manipulating others...
smile.sara thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6



What went wrong with Jodha Akbar ?..

The tag line


"Dehshat hae Akbar ka doosra naam ----- kaise banaye gi jodha osey insaan"

And the claim

"EPIC LOVE STORY"

In epic love story couple support each other ... Stay with each other ... They do mistakes and correct them with each other

But here jalal should always wrong and jodha should always right


This jodha bachao project is main problem of this show

The tag line is vice versa of epic of love story

Epic love story of reformation of insaan from haiwan

Now after 350 + epi ... Jodha is always right theme... Killed evry dam thing in story ... Every character every concept ... Including jodha , epic love story and her project -jalal to akbar- who should reformed by her after 350+ epis and 16+ years of their marriage

But no

Just bec they are taking inspiration for main events from akabr history

So

When ever there should be any reform of akbar ...the credit should go to jodha

Like just after twins birth she was doing morcha andholan for jazya aboliation.

But she took and bear all wrong accusations of husain death and his abundance for three whole years ...

Why and how

Just bec to save jodha side in chittor war ...to show jalal is out of jodha influence ...

Now this ultra week jodha ... The jodha went to khaiber in her pregnancy, when whole her family were gathered for shab e qadar she freed him, risked so many soldiers and poor people life at the sacred night of shab e qadar ... But now she just stop just on mention of jalal order


Why ..???

Bec now story is heading towards salim anarkali ... This story has no happy ending ,...salim will be shown rebellious and drugged edict And just to show her safe from the sad end of this epic love story of SA... She is showing week and not able to control any one nor jalal neither salim not even herself...

To make some thing creative ... There should not IFs and n BUTs... But here main problem is to save jodha butt from every dark part of akbar life and give every credit of his good deed and doings to her...bec of this very reason... Nothing is making any sence ... Every things is looking out of order ... Drama, love story, characters, actors , logic , history ...everything is in complete mess





Edited by smile.sara - 10 years ago
sweet_diksha thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
good post, prem... now CVs crossing every limit... just read abt ME... and Shaguni's new bhavishyavani... like she tells u ll lose ur this child too and Jo is all shocked...

WOW... gr8 going... Gr8 Shehenshah and his gr8 supporter MUZ, but losers as parents...

keep up with ur epic love, CVs... coz that's only thing to be done now
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Goras



Do you really find in JA there is jodha glorification, I don't find it here . Here is only Ruq 's winning n the hot abba huzoor who ditched jodha for no mistake of hers for three years.n you are saying this show is about jo , I must see through your eyes as I didn't get this



@bold: I agree totally with you here. here this show is all about Ruks Glorification and she wins all the time fooling even the emperor. Looks like she runs the sultanate and emperor is a Ghulam to her just like how she is trying to get Salim as her Ghulam

Jodha and Jalal both are shown to be dumb and foolish..

I guess we need to start looking with a separate set of eyes to see and understand if All Jalal's achievements was given to Jodha. If a husband praises his wife does that mean she gets all the credit. So that means now a days Jodha Praising Jalal, means we should assume all his good works and efforts is indded done by Jodha.
Edited by SindhuMenon - 10 years ago
sweet_diksha thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Anarkali is getting undue footage just like Ben and Atifa... Jo and Jalal have become side characters...
NutellaWaffle thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail 11th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
From strt of this serial it's all Abt vamp glorification ... First it was Maham which is bearable but now it's rukayya glorification too much... Lik any other serial heroine wil hv to prove herself eveytime from strt... She has to sacrifice , take blames, gets abused, all sort of bad things happens to only heroine which can't b watched aftr certain limit...
Actual down fall of ka strtd from ruk fake oreg track it was disgusting to watch ruk stupidity... And it continued with twin sepertaion n her bakwas til now... Now it crossed evrythng by drugging child but stil that moron wil not get punishmmet... Til wen wil viewers watch jA for her punsishment? Always ruk has to win over jodha lik evil wins over good n ruk gives sadistic smile wen her plans wrk out... Isn't there any full stop for this ? Who wil put ruk in her limits? It's jalal who can do.. But unfortunately here heroine has to suffer bcz of vamp so jalal punished jodha n dimt punsih ruk... How long can viewrrs watch ruk winning evrytime? She succeded on almost all plans including sepertaing mother from child... The day she wil get punishment ppl wil watch

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".