Originally posted by: Cleo12345
I agree with you Radhika... All kinds of trivia is allowed but not serious, intelligent discussion. And the discussion on his thread never turns ugly unlike some other threads. In fact, I find more fan wars on daily threads. Should they all be grouped into a sticky too? Probably not...at least people who disagree can avoid each other on different threads. But it is difficult to avoid POVs you disagree with on a sticky.
@underlined:
Yes, it is difficult to avoid different POVs on a single thread. You are forced to read posts you could ignore otherwise, as you have no other choice, while you search for the posts you do want to read.
Another thing that puzzles me is that if what Abhay writes is incorrect history, why allow it to be written even on a sticky? What cannot be posted on one thread cannot be posted on another thread also.
The purpose of a common thread for discussion is served if we just ask simple Qs and someone gives us direct answers. It is like an FAQ.
But if a lot of information is to be shared on a subject, it cannot be mixed up with info on some other subjects, doubts, clarifications, answers and general chat. The seriousness of the subject is diluted and the focus lost.
Kabhi Neem Neem Kabhi Shahad Shahad
