Jalal is in Amer - but things are a bit over the top! - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

145

Views

12.8k

Users

38

Likes

649

Frequent Posters

minnie2308 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: skanda12

No Minnie I expected her bland expression because as I wrote I thought she was not fully in grasp of her mind and faculties. She seemed in some alternative reality of imaginings and autoameted responses. She did not look like a thinking and cogent individual. maybe its the after effect of her negative feelings gone leaving a void in her that now needs to be filled with positive feelings. Sometimes when we have had a lot of negative feelings and it gets removed suddenly, we ourselves feel spaced out for a while.

Mansi, For somebody, with some background on psychology and understanding of human emotions(as I can gauge from your lovely posts on the forum) , it was an easy interpretation for you. Not so much for me. And I still am unable to buy that her face did not register any shock upon hearing Abul Mali😲... He and his aide in Agra palace is the reason why she and her bro were worried sick ... and now the mention of same man does not elicit ANY reaction.
I did not find anything amiss in her not being able to judge that Jalal is badly wounded since, he had that huge shawl covering himself. I did not find it odd that she in auto pilot mode repeated her dialogues... "I am not coming with you to Agra".
But try as I might, I cannot register the reason for blandness and the excessive concern for space
AFTER knowing that Jalal is wounded and not just exhausted in journey and wounded by the very Abul Mali whose conspiracies she was trying to expose with the help of her bro! That reaction did not sit well with me...
ayushimehra thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: skanda12

Radhika, I expected nothing less than this absolutely delightful post from you and my hopes were answered. Thank God we have agroup of far-thinking people on this thread whose positivity we can feed off!
There was a bit of over the top stuff as you have mentioned (like the necklace bit and Jalal "tottering" to the waterfront and all that) but if you sink all that for a moment Jodha's feelings are realistic ... the poor dear is spaced out and in some alternative reality where there is only the empty shell of ego and some automaton-type responses. What she now needs is cajoling from the man in the bandages! She will be pulp before very long, I assure you. He is too determined for words!


Radhika, Mansi, good analysis, i also not fed-up jodha's behaviour, Mansi & radhika you both described, beautifully, her mentel, status, this staze, that was right. we should not accept more awareness in jodha, she is also a humen being. she was confused at that time, not knows jalal is in AMER, not knows how much jalal injured. firestely she was doing everything, because her sick-sense indicating, jalal is not FINe. suddenely things changed, & suddenely, how can she behave
in, dutiful wife, then no meaning, which she fight for her self respect, past days. when BM noted that point, she quikely understand, &followed her. Husband wife needed some space
BM, & MV doing that, so some time needed also AKDHA, to sort out this situation, so some patiance requried.so things will be better for whole life, & both will understand, this is not fun
they both needed to adjust eachother.
comeing soon.
MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: Akdhaparijatluv

Buddy I know most of ppl r disappointed with Jo but I'm not...Jo is angry bird now Jallu is love bird lets see how these two birds understand care and finally fly with love. Jallu wil get well soon by the powerful Lep of Jo and win her love back...I want to see Jallu manofying her teasing her and winning his love Jo ..
Regarding Jo Parents doesn't know wat exactly happend btw JJ...they r thinking it's normal fight bcz of MU and try to pacify and they r unaware of words that happend btw JJ ...they evn dint realise how much Jo got hurt only Jallu knows how much he has hurt her and only amer can help her to get out of this situation...wen bharmal said wat happend to previous jodha I Thoght of sayin anyone in that mental Agra wil become lik this...they al made her to get kicked out of Agra that Jo made herself stubborn...
She wil try to b hard,stubborn and pretending not to care but she also knows that deep inside she is melting and remembering seeing him eveywer ..stil those words were ringing in her years and the person whom she Thoght loved accused her of infidelity and thrown her out of his life...just lik Jallu in Ben track how he was blinded by dhakka issue Thoght of forgetting his mohabbat bcz of hurt and insulted in DEK also that she dint fulfil her responsibilities as wife now same Jo is suffering with that bcz how Jallu has thrown her out of his life and trying to forget her love and not to be kind to him even wen he got injured ..it's her deep hurt not ego or pride ...this is culmination of her hurt, humiliation and pain from Ben track til the day wen he askd her to leave..
Jallu cudnt forget dhakka n hurt for two months and Jo is also human how can she forget his words in five days she needs time and amer is the bestest place for Jo to get out of the situation...if she gets melt easily we wil see nxt day JJ packing their bags to that mental Agra which I dnt want now at all.. Let these love birds understand and Jallu assure Jo that he wil always trust her n respect her and later Jo confessing her love to Jallu...im enjoying these ruk Maham sharif adham free episodes



Bhavana 👏👏👏👏👏
You are rocking 😃😃😃
Donjas thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#44
Nice analysis. I liked an episode after a long time. Action, romance, no Maham and logic.

As for the "no reaction from Paridhi". I believe that is because of non-communication between director and actress.

By the way if you google Jodha Akbar today, you will find many articles claiming that Paridhi has accused director Santram of sexual assault. Yes, that is the word that they used in the "Times of India"

These are no longer wild accusations, there are serious claims made by respected dailies.

Mark my words, something big is brewing on the sets and it could come out at any moment.
minnie2308 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: ayushimehra


Radhika, Mansi, good analysis, i also not fed-up jodha's behaviour, Mansi & radhika you both described, beautifully, her mentel, status, this staze, that was right. we should not accept more awareness in jodha, she is also a humen being. she was confused at that time, not knows jalal is in AMER, not knows how much jalal injured. firestely she was doing everything, because her sick-sense indicating, jalal is not FINe. suddenely things changed, & suddenely, how can she behave
in, dutiful wife, then no meaning, which she fight for her self respect, past days. when BM noted that point, she quikely understand, &followed her. Husband wife needed some space
BM, & MV doing that, so some time needed also AKDHA, to sort out this situation, so some patiance requried.so things will be better for whole life, & both will understand, this is not fun
they both needed to adjust eachother.
comeing soon.

I am sure the writers had the same thoughts in mind when they decided to give Jo bland expressions upon the mention of name' Abul Mali". Its just that is does not sit well with my immense expectiations of Jo.
I know she is not into PDA...and offcourse hugging jalal would have looked stupid. But to show no expression is what exasperated me. Frankly I do not see this as a normal reaction, specially from JO. She is different and I would have been OK if she had reacted in anger again! But some reactions atleast. Why think about your room and space when the husband is all wounded after suffering the attack from his sworn enemy?
I would have liked if she had lectured him again" see What I told you...this is what me and Bhaisa were trying to unearth and you had to spoil it with your shak. Now you are wounded...yada yada...'
Some reaction ...any reaction... no reaction was silly!
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: Jeevitha.P

lovely,very lovely post indeed...i really hope Jodha can float her ego in the river where she floated the diya and we get our caring jodha back again...fingers and toes crossed for it.😃

Jeevitha, what a lovely thought about floating her ego on the river!👏👏👏
minnie2308 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: MaddyO



Bhavana 👏👏👏👏👏
You are rocking 😃😃😃

Jalal definitely has been downright ill-behaved to Jo.
See the reason people cant relate to Jo for the 2 sec on mention of Abul Mali is that she did not get shocked upon hearing that he is wounded by Abul Mali...she was bland. I would not expect her to hug Jalal...par kuch reaction to hona tha?
Edited by minnie2308 - 11 years ago
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: minnie2308

Mansi, For somebody, with some background on psychology and understanding of human emotions(as I can gauge from your lovely posts on the forum) , it was an easy interpretation for you. Not so much for me. And I still am unable to buy that her face did not register any shock upon hearing Abul Mali😲... He and his aide in Agra palace is the reason why she and her bro were worried sick ... and now the mention of same man does not elicit ANY reaction.

I did not find anything amiss in her not being able to judge that Jalal is badly wounded since, he had that huge shawl covering himself. I did not find it odd that she in auto pilot mode repeated her dialogues... "I am not coming with you to Agra".
But try as I might, I cannot register the reason for blandness and the excessive concern for space
AFTER knowing that Jalal is wounded and not just exhausted in journey and wounded by the very Abul Mali whose conspiracies she was trying to expose with the help of her bro! That reaction did not sit well with me...

I know some of her behaviour seemed unreasonable but I thought it was more because she was disoriented rather than deliberately rude.
Edited by skanda12 - 11 years ago
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: ayushimehra


Radhika, Mansi, good analysis, i also not fed-up jodha's behaviour, Mansi & radhika you both described, beautifully, her mentel, status, this staze, that was right. we should not accept more awareness in jodha, she is also a humen being. she was confused at that time, not knows jalal is in AMER, not knows how much jalal injured. firestely she was doing everything, because her sick-sense indicating, jalal is not FINe. suddenely things changed, & suddenely, how can she behave
in, dutiful wife, then no meaning, which she fight for her self respect, past days. when BM noted that point, she quikely understand, &followed her. Husband wife needed some space
BM, & MV doing that, so some time needed also AKDHA, to sort out this situation, so some patiance requried.so things will be better for whole life, & both will understand, this is not fun
they both needed to adjust eachother.
comeing soon.

Ayushi, as Radhika has written if this stage of Jodha's disorientedness is not there, and if she had just smiled at Jalal and been at peace with him the track would be over!
skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: Donjas

Nice analysis. I liked an episode after a long time. Action, romance, no Maham and logic.

As for the "no reaction from Paridhi". I believe that is because of non-communication between director and actress.

By the way if you google Jodha Akbar today, you will find many articles claiming that Paridhi has accused director Santram of sexual assault. Yes, that is the word that they used in the "Times of India"

These are no longer wild accusations, there are serious claims made by respected dailies.

Mark my words, something big is brewing on the sets and it could come out at any moment.

Let everything take its own course. That's the best way to handle anything that is sudden or unexpected!
Incidentally the same dailies also misreport many times, so I would take everything good and bad with a big pinch of salt. The big dailies are no better than the tabloids when it comes to TV and cinema gossip.
Edited by skanda12 - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha Akkineni & Jalal Ahmed of Pale Blue Dot : A Story in Verse 💙

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".