Originally posted by: lashy
JALAL VS BHARMAL
Yesterday quite a few were slapping their foreheads when Jalal pointed his fingers at Bharmal- wondering if this was another brain-freeze moment of his. However, the biggest shock came when it turns out that Raja Bharmal was indeed aware of the entire escapade and had ended up hiding everything from the Sultanat and from Jalal!😕
I can't believe that a man I'd otherwise considered noble would cheat his own son-in-law in this fashion - the very son-in-law who'd fulfilled more than his fair share of responsibilies in helping his second daughter's wedding go through! [Playing with Jalal and Jodha's characterizations weren't enough, so they jumped on to Bharmal now? And when we say Bharmal, we shouldn't forget Bhagwant Das either - he is just as much to blame in all of it!]
Here, loveanime's point, that Bharmal has repeatedly used his eldest daughter to get himself out of the trouble he had landed in because his incompetence - at war the first time and as a parent now, is pertinent.
"I have to say something about Bharmal, what he did was quite realistic. It happens even now and I am sure it happened a lot more then where marrying within your status, caste and religion was everything. He was true to his character I see him quite capable of doing this, after all this is the same man who thought it would be just to not even allow Jodha to see Jalal's face before marriage. It wasn't that he bartered her that is natural and within the ethics of politics and war of the time, but it was that he lied to his daughter about the real deal so what does that say about him."
'You found a solution for your difficulties through my humiliation?' Jalal questions his father-in-law rightfully so - his maner still composed 'You've adviced me well on many issues in the past...so, please tell me what punishment should I mete you?'
It was a cringe-worthy scene indeed to see the father-in-law kneel in front of the Shehenshah thus. On the other hand, Jalal kneeling down to give the man's relationship respect was laud-worthy!
Even though the majority of the blame lies with Shivani, I cannot absolve Bharmal of his sins either -
As a mansabdaar it was his duty to inform the Shehenshah of any such developments in the matter
As a father-in-law, it was his obligation to let Jalal know of the prime reason of why he was going ahead with this. Wouldn't Hakim's life had been affected, if Shivani had gone ahead with some silly plans AFTER the wedding?
If Shivani has been responsible for the humiliation of her clan, Bharmal is no less - had he been upfront from the beginning it would have saved him and his family a lot of heartache. He's ended up jeopardizing one daughter's life/family to save another's and it doesn't make much sense to me. So now, Jodha has to suffer for the Ameris fault?
And it is not just deceit, it is the kind of stupidity that passeth all understanding. How could he risk Shivani's fling being found out in Agra, whether or not she ran away with kaarigar? With such an immature girl, how could he be sure she would keep the secret? If she blurted it out, what then about her life with Mirza Hakim and the scandal too?
JALAL VS HAKIMI am glad Jalal gave Hakim the example of Shareefuddin and Bakshi Bano. It makes no sense to ask the culprits to be forgiven just because the crimes were one of 'love'! If that's the case then all the young men who carry crimes of 'passion' against the women they are obsessed with can request to be excused based on the fact that they are 'in love' too. True, in this day and age running from the wedding mandap might not be as big an issue, but this is a royal wedding in the 16th century, we're talking about.
Hakim is very large-hearted in forgiving Bharmal and Shivani, however he cannot rule an Empire with the principles he was meting today. (I still can't believe this man is going to turn against Jalal in future🤔) Agree 111%. This is pure populist folly. I cannot believe Hakim ruled Kabul using these principles!
However, Jalal is right in his stance of not excusing the culprits. I was glad when he didn't forgive BB - rightfully, he shouldn't forgive Bharmal or Shivani/Tejwant too. Hakim was within his 'legal' rights to have Bharmal pardoned - but, I hope Jalal gives Shivani/Tej at least some form of punishment - because if not, he's only going to look partial/unjust when he does so!
By making Hakim proclaim an 'Aakhir mohabbat hai' statement the CVs have downplayed the crime committed. Then, the lady in the court the other day who had a lover was also justified because she was only in love with a man other than her husband! Why was she alone stoned? (I definitely DON'T WANT Shivani/Tej to undergo such a thing 😆, but they need to be incarcerated)
If not, all the culprits will begin coming out with such sob-stories and request to be forgiven in court. So, would the judge just pardon them? Also, if Jalal forgives his own family, he is only setting a wrong example for the rest of the Sultanat - obviously, Jalal is not going to go about forgiving all his subjects now, is he?😕 Very, very relevant and even more uncomfortable questions, which no one will answer, for the only answers possible will not suit the CVs.
HB
HB forgiving Bharmal made no sense whatsoever!😕 They could have shown her at least momentarily saddened or offended! Instead, she's asking them to stay back and celebrate Shivraatri! This scene was so unbelievable, I didn't even know what to say. 😕 She is at least consistent in her folly and her partiality. She is never there for Jalal (or now for Mirza Hakim, but that does not matter as he is not there for himself) but she is there for everyone else. She had not a word to say about the humiliation of the Mughal sultanate either, that was left to Jodha.
JODHA
The only people I feel sorry for it at the end of it all are Jalal, Mirza Hakim and Jodha. Having said that, I wish Jodha had not requested Jalal to forgive Bharmal. Yes, she is emotional and anyone would be pained as a daughter to see what the father was going through. However, I would have liked her to remain silent in the matter. I too had noted this, and had noted in my post on this episode as follows:
She does remark, curiously enough, that his fault is not so great (as to merit being imprisoned). This does not jell with what she feels and says later, and the only possible explanation is that in the meantime, she has learnt that Bharmal had known all along about Tejwant, and was thus using Mirza, and Jalal, for his own selfish ends.
Watching Jodha in the last scene - in that room - crying to herself was adorable indeed. Her anger against her family and the 'impressed'/'touched' expressions she had on her face when she learnt that the Shehenshah had forgiven her father was Pari at her best!
Her final lambasting against her family was aggrieving, but a necessary one! I liked all that she said - because, it was all true! Aggrieving? Not at all. Everything she said needed to be said, and said as bluntly and harshly as she did.
PRECAP
Again interesting - lets see how it pans out!
MY TAKE
They need not have had the Ameris involved in this scandal at all - it's reflected quite poorly on the entire clan (unless history has some other tit bits to offer that we know not about)
Are the makers not worried about the protests now? I thought Shivani eloping was bad enough...
Look, I do not see why any Rajputs should protest, for most fathers would have done exactly what Bharmal did, except that they would have taken care not to run afoul of the powerful son-in-law. Is there not the old saying Aayiram poi sholli oru kalyanam pannu? ( You can tell a thousand lies to get a wedding through)
CID
Hindi TV Shows
Anupamaa
