Six questions I want answered! - Page 2

Originally posted by: sun29

mansi...jalal is conditioned to think of himself as Emperor ,the God ...he has people around him feeding him that...yesterday look at ruqaiyya ka dialogues ..it was how could jodha defy the Emperor and dare to lie to him...so he marches off to her not only angry at her lie but angry that he was nearly going to kill her for it...in order for things to register to such a mule headed person it will take time...jalal is very very very arrogant ...and change will occur but not instantly...jodha's talks will have some effect on him but for him to actually turn into a thinking empathetic reasonable human it will take time

his reactions and actions regarding jodha are always extreme...he hates the fact that he is obsessed with her and hence he wants to prove to himself she is his enemy and nothing else...he is impulsive and hot headed...the decision to swing the sword was not that of the Emperor or the father but the man who was betrayed and made fool of ...he let his emotional guard down and a mere woman fooled him ...jalal would never accept that ..hence his extreme reaction..

jalal most certainly does not love jodha at present..the seeds of affection just got sowed on the poetry wala day and it got destroyed too that same day...besides why are people surprised ...hav e we not seen people n love to commit murder of their lovers...crime of passion...in that moment of utmost anger nothing makes sense..no one makes sense...he is the jallad we saw in the first week of the show...it is pride and arrogance that rides him...what he feels for jodha is a extreme obsession ,fixation and he is unable to get ridd of it or even make sense out of it...his emotional turmoil got the better out of him...

the strategy in the war scene was really ridiculous no arguments on that and the hamaam scene even i feel it was bad editing ...the flashbacks and the smirk made no sense together

about salima ,hopefully he will use his brains this time ...and he should coz she is not jodha hence she is entitled to reasons and stable emotions lol...

Beautifully put forth Sun...absolutely breathtaking analysis here...many courtiers and kinsmen false-fed their emperors sky-high praises and gifts in order to be in their good books - now, I don't know if this really helped kings in personal development though!

Originally posted by: skanda12

Okay if he was blinded by his reactions to Jodha, let's hope his reactions to Salima are different. If they are the same as before then I cannot but conclude that is blinded by any and every action to produce the same reaction!

Originally posted by: lashy

Beautifully put forth Sun...absolutely breathtaking analysis here...many courtiers and kinsmen false-fed their emperors sky-high praises and gifts in order to be in their good books - now, I don't know if this really helped kings in personal development though!

You know what Mansi..I think all of us - especially Indian TV - has always portrayed 'adarsh' heroes on screen and we've become pre-conditioned to watching depictions of larger-than-life ideal kings, ideal freedom-fighters, ideal cops etc! Why, even the movie JA did the same!

This serial has depicted him closer to reality me thinks...which serial do you recollect where we got to watch THE MAIN LEAD as an ill-tempered cruel-ish emperor with many wives? Maybe this serial is about a king of great achievements with a not-so-great personality! 🤔

LOL..i remember saying...the war will look fakish and silly...nd thats exaclty wht happened...As it is the rajputs luk so dull that to highlight them they hv to bring down Jalal!

Well mansi , mansi mansi ...

If all things were perfect ... ( best left unsaid)

Iam sure tht even the C.V's realize tht the war scenes were not aptly directed n shot ... what they did was just show jalal have one o one fights with his swords n since the amerwalas play dandiya .. this time they tricked us with showing them with bows n arrows ... but i feel they should have invested in this war sequence or probably shown jalal not knowing about the chapammaar style of fight the sujanpurwalals were going to use , it would have made sense ...

With jalal knowing the plan n scheming the battle , when no soldiers turned up was humorous n a face-fall for the show , every one agrees with this ... I think C.V's are more consumed than us by this track...

As far as the last tub scene goes EVEN I FELT THE SAME ... I COULD NOT GUESS WAT JALAL WAS THINKING... were they the fond memories n if yes why was tht grin showing off on his face ???
I thought by now shyamala aunty would have figured it out so i jumped onto IF first thing fter waking up today ... n i find company here ... so welcome to the gang ...

The last but not the least , salima case remains to be seen , infact today is the TRP day tht is why tht raunchy precap was shown... for sure ... bt wat makes today's episode worth watching is the fact how will jalal react to jodha ... would he even understand tht she is complaining to a husband ? I want to his reaction n action , and yes a self driven action as u mentioned to wat jodha informed him about yesterday ...

Kashi

Originally posted by: lashy

As for your first few questions on the war, I have NOTHING to answer for it NOR defend it - the scenes were abysmally directed and personally, I feel they depicted Jalal, his courtiers, his army, the Sujanpuris - EVERYONE weak and silly!

Some are defending the Mughal army stating that they were not yet ready...I read Shyamala aunty's reply somewhere that stated 'Did they need breakfast in bed to get ready?'

There are 24 hour soldiers stationed FOR A REASON...and these soldiers guard not only the emperor but all of his important aides 😕

Similar is your observation on the wry smile in his bathtub - I didn't understand the significance of it. I've come the conclusion that it is a not-very-well directed continuation of his dialogue to his AmmiJaan - 'That the wounds on a warrior are a token of his victory at the battlefield' He was relishing his wounds - if you know what I mean! LOL

As for Jalal swinging his sword on Jodha, hmmm...but, what else did you expect dear?😊

He is not emotionally invested in Jodha for certain and they've shown him to be very emotionally invested in what was his child-to-be

He thinks he HATES her...and tries acting thus!

He is obsessed about trying NOT to be obsessed about her - thus, any reaction by her incites an extreme reaction

She stormed in there deliberately (knowing what pushes his buttons) and incited him so that he would raise his sword upon her

He is the emperor (this is 16th century autocracy) and technically he owes a culprit (even a royal) no explanation - especially one who's just confessed to royal treason!

I read somewhere that Jalal was always known to be impulsive...he mellowed down in his later years!

(Alakh please help me out here - apparently I read that, Jalal didn't trust his own temper and in his later years made a decree that trials would be tried thrice in front of him - just in case he acted brashly!)

good questions even i am annoyed about some scenes the cvs shouldn't show such bloopers akbar jodha are the strongest & main characaters of the show they always keep this in mind making one character strong doesn't need cutting down the other character
now i want this royal murder mystery to end this week

Originally posted by: tara_211

LOL..i remember saying...the war will look fakish and silly...nd thats exaclty wht happened...As it is the rajputs luk so dull that to highlight them they hv to bring down Jalal!

Regarding Jalal raising the sword on Jodha...i again dont feel it was so OTT that bought down Jalals character. Its Jalal...a cruel emperor...he dint see Jodha in front of him..all he saw was the criminal who accepted teh crime. copy pasting my reply in another post -

In their present scenario Jodha feels nothing for Jalal and Jalal definitely cares more for his murdered to-be-born child than Jodha. He might be mesmerized with her, but we cant expect him having eyelocks with her when she has stated that she killed the child. He pulled the sword on her as an action to the punishment any person who would come forward and claim to hv done the act.

coming to Jalals expression while taking bath...well he was just impressed by the bravery and loyalty...Definitely he dint expect that...but he needed more time with the girls pouring water on him to reach the point where he could strt thinking over Amer people not plotting his childs murder...which was sadly interrupted by Jodha!

Salima action reaction yet to happen...nd i dont wanna think much on it...after all jo hum sochte hai..EKTA bilkul nahi sochti!

Jalas apology wont be grand eventhough i want it to be..he will probably just declare the amerians not guilty with respect which will be considered as a let go..Though i feel he surely will hv a talk wiht Jodha...BUT how long is all this gonna be dragged is wht will test our patience!

No way are u over thinking...but yes...we cant watch this show keeping our expectations high on teh characters being loyal and up-to the mark...we will face disappointment in one episode and will be satisfied with other...EKTA SPECIAL...!