Jhanak Written Update and Discussions Thread No 3. - Page 18

Originally posted by: Groot

She has always been thankless to him , she very easily throws him under the bus whenever these Anti Jhanak people question her about anything (before and after the accident) . She has never ever cooperated with him whenever he tried to do anything for her , she has always insulted him publicly yet he never stopped helping her and he never vents out .

She vents out , family ka gussa Ani pe nikaalti hai .... Fair enough ..... But Her venting out makes no sense to me because venting out means you are emotionally attached to that person , thora bahut haq samjhati hai Ani pe so she takes out her anger on him. I think makers want to show this only but execution is so bad that i am not feeling it . I don't enjoy their fights , i don't see any kind of emotional connection or attachment between them specially from Jhanak's side so whenever she fights with him, it is not venting out for me but hate.

Like that day on the road , i think purpose of that scene was this only that unintentionally she thinks she has a right on him so she lashes out on him and he also made those few dialogues ke iss ko gusse mein pata nahin rehta etc ... iss sab se hurt or emotional connect dikhna chahiye but nahin dikha because execution was so bad that i didn't FEEL it ... i didn't enjoy that fight which i should have ... for me Jhanak crossed her line there and infront of family she pointed fingers on them while she herself is not very right because same argument she used with his family ke yeh karoon toh problem woh karoon toh problem .... Ani can also use this against her ke if she really wanted to be with Tejas, why did she even run from there. one second she wants to improve her life then she absolutely does nothing to do it , doesn't even cooperate with Ani whenever he tries to do anything to improve her life, instead she throws him under the bus and starts behaving as if Ani is doing some kind of torture on her " arre mein oh yeh karna hi nahin chahti thi " ... arre toh behn roti kiyun rehti ho poora din agar yeh karna hi nahin chahti thi

from her behavior it seems like her life's biggest dukh is that she can't go back to Tejas and Ani has forced her to stay with him

Yes she can be hurt with his behavior post the accident but i don't see any hurt either . i simply don't see any kind of emotional attachment or any emotion from her side that's why i am not able to connect with their fights or with jahank at all.

baaki sab toh assumptions hain ke she is hurt , she is emotional , she is this and that so she is venting out or doing this .... kuch bhi assume kar lo but we have never seen it, dikhta to hai nahin kuch. I have just seen her anger and her desperation to go back to Tejas. Even her reasoning behind this rant ke Tejas ke paas jaana hai is so badly executed that it feels like she genuinely wants to go back to him not because she has no other option .

I think a lot of it has to do with Jhanak's nature. She is impatient at certain things. Reckless. Takes things personally to heart. The way Ani is acting, anyone else would have understood, but Jhanak probably is not the type to. Hiba is not great at emoting Jhanak well. I can say a handful number of episodes where I felt for her as Jhanak. Most of the time her caricaturish acting also lends into disbelief over Jhanak's perceived circumstances and feelings. I can see where Jhanak is coming from and how it is valid, but also that Hiba's acting/directing cues/execution make it so weak she comes across as rude and thankless. Krushal's acting on the other hand makes us attached to his character, so it is easy to feel bad for him comparatively, not that Ani is without faults, but I am truly glad between them at least one has his head on the shoulders properly. I do feel bad for Ani who is met with insults from her for his help.

Good first half, Bad second half.

I'm thankful to God that we got some buffer with the Bharatnatyam bit before the Mohini Basu avatar. Though logistics wise it doesn't make sense at all. Ani is continuing to admire her and her dance. I like how they asked Krushal to give layered looks of being attracted to her.

He admired her happiness and her true love for dance in the Maharashtrian attire.

He was bowled over by the simplicity of her beauty in the Christian bridal attire. (Touchwood... the shot panning to Hiba's smile was so beautiful yesterday! Kisse pyaar nahi hoga!!)

He is now further falling into the rabbit hole of love seeing her Bharatnatyam dance. Loved and Awed that Krushal is able to pull such complex expression through his eyes.

Chotton on the other side is observing Ani and his expression. He is now knows pucca that Ani has fallen in love with her. Ani's daant for Jhanak shows him the concern he has for her career and his comment about the food and Juice shows him that Ani notices each and every minute thing about Jhanak. Ani is whipped for Jhanak abse. Wonder how he will be in the future?

Chotton's concern today for Ani is a very valid one. Since both of them have not accepted their manage, and he has a good grasp of both of their feelings since he is a sort of middleman. He is worried about Jhanak making her own life and how it will impact Ani and whether he will be able to weather the storm that will come. I think future episodes will give a good glimpse of it to us the viewers.

After Mohini Basu's appearance, they take a break (gratitude to the director not showing close up shots, we get plenty later down the line ). I saw the guy who I assume is the AD giving starry eyed looks to Jhanak. He asks her to stay in the makeup room as per Director's instructions, but Jhanak refuses politely. Ani looks on the convo with acute interest! The poor guy would have crushed the bottles had the convo lasted longer... he doesn't like it when other men take excessive interest in Jhanak lol. On that note, wonder if these people know Jhanak is married. Would have been cherry on top if the AD's name was Rahul

Chotton calls Jhanak and asks her to have the juice. While initially accepting, she immediately denies once she gets to know it was Ani who brought it here giving all nonsensical excuses. She declines sternly and upon Ani's insistence says she is refusing exactly because he brought it for her, and it screams special treatment. She only asks him to let her do the job in peace. These two bicker like a married couple. really. Again and again, this is being emphasized to us viewers. But each such conversation reveals more information, like a layered cake. Ani in gussa throws away the bottle and refuses to share the drink with Chotton.

This scene really gives us a glimpse of their mindset with respect to eo. Jhanak is well aware Ani treats her special. But he also blows hot and cold every time, and it makes Jhanak scream at him and run far away; because both he and his family scold only her and humiliate only her when it is not her fault at all. Ani on the other hand, is confused as hell; he reprimands Jhanak and puts her down for good intentions and reasons (to make her successful), but also expects her to be nice to him after all this as if she is understanding of him. Her words affect his actions. He is getting too attached to her emotionally without even his notice. They are both at such crossroads, seeing their story progress will be a treat to watch.

As this convo unfolds, Arshi and Shristi arrive. The two want Jhanak out, but also don't want her to have any semblance of independence. Shame on them, they lose basic humanity when it comes to Jhanak. What did Jhanak ever do to them man?

At least from a relationship point, Arshi and Shristi are asking the right questions. Why is Ani hiding stuff related to Jhanak? Why is he here personally when he has his job in the company? They know the answer why, but still the question is a correct one. No matter the faults, Shristi is a protective mother to Arshi. This has been shown numerous times in her advising her to question Ani even today. But she goes a bit overboard in cultivating hatred and insecurity for Jhanak in her daughter's heart. Well, what else to expect, like mother like daughter. Blood always runs thicker than water in this world.

Jhanak from my opinion was totally valid in how she reacted. These people abuse her for anything and everything and Ani after putting her in such situations never is upfront and supports her. He leaves her alone to fend accusations and she is tired of it. As for her insisting she is a maid and telling the truth as she knows, like @Anindita said, it's defense mechanism she has learnt. She knows these people leave her alone if she lowers herself. She doesn't need the feel to elevate herself as there is no one worth fighting for in her life. The Basus and the mother daughter duo have thoroughly extinguished her hope for a better life through constant humiliation and harassment.

Funny thing Shristi thinks that Jhanak got it because she is her relative, but the contracts don't even know it. As if Arshi is any better, she only has the platform she has because she is Shristi Mukerjhee's daughter. Look at yourself in the mirror before you open the mouth!

Loved the look at Arshi's face when Jhanak said yes Ani forced me here. Lol! She thinks so highly of herself.

Now that the contractors opened the mouth, let's see how Ani handles it tomorrow.

Precap: Ani and Jhanak go to open bank account, and it seems like Valentine's Day. Seems that Ani forgot the card and leaves. Arshi and co come and sit after they leave, and she notices the card and gets shocked. Wonder what's in it. Timeline is messed up here. So, is the party going to happen or not?

[/QUOTE

You write like a bomb dear. Keep writing dear. Thank you for the update. Yet to watch the epsiode. Very valid points made from both Janak and Ani sides. After all this happens, Ani and Janak goes alone to create bank account ? Nice! Whatever fights they do, end of the day they both are hubby and wife 🤣

Thank you for the lovely detailed update! Your analysis is very good. I hate the Bose drama but right now I can't wait to see how Ani wriggles out of this because the engagement party is happening as per the promo. 🤞

I am sure they are going to drag this till marriage as well so that they can have a bigger drama. But will the marriage happen is another thing. I don't think the so called "The Shrishti Mukherjee" is stupid.

I have to say I commend the realism. Arshi is more preoccupied with Ani going to see Jhanak shoot. She still hates it but it’s not blown out of range like social climber Bipasha. I liked that a lot, even when she wanted to go and shristi was like no, so as not to be humiliated, I liked it a lot. Normal ITV would have made her forget the main priority: Ani, because Ani is the most precious thing that Arshi is trying hard not to lose to Jhanak. All the opportunities of Jhanak are just channels because Ani is involved in helping her get there, and her talent scares Arshi. But above dance, comes Ani for Arshi, so that was good. I really don’t see Shristi wanting him for her when she finds out about marriage, but it’s possible that Arshi will want Ani back (which she will) and Shristi will join for her sake.

Originally posted by: vimeo

Thank you for the lovely detailed update! Your analysis is very good. I hate the Bose drama but right now I can't wait to see how Ani wriggles out of this because the engagement party is happening as per the promo. 🤞

I am sure they are going to drag this till marriage as well so that they can have a bigger drama. But will the marriage happen is another thing. I don't think the so called "The Shrishti Mukherjee" is stupid.

How come they can drag until Marriage when the marraige fotos are getting released during wedding announcement party.

True. They are husband and wife completely. These bicker like they have right on each other. Get angry. Save eo when the time comes without a care for anything else. But one thing I want Ani to take time to understand is that Jhanak may function how he wants her to by manipulating her with words. But ultimately, she is not used to this daily humiliation saga from people not her own aka., relatives and would keep this in heart. From what it looks like she only works sometimes for the Raina's. Chotton, Appu and her parents are Basus at the end even if they support her. Case in point, we have seen Anjana silence Appu whenever she tried to defend Jhanak on multiple occasions. They can only give marginal support as they are going against their own family after all. Anyone would hesitate. So she really does feel alone and doesn't have the mental capacity to tolerate their BS. Now that she is being forced to stay against her will unlike last time, it's even worse for her and she is lashing out at Ani who is the root cause in her eyes. He really shouldn't get angry/hurt because he knows what he is doing and what will be the consequences for his actions. After all, Newton's third law... for every reaction there will be an equal and opposite reaction

Originally posted by: vimeo

Thank you for the lovely detailed update! Your analysis is very good. I hate the Bose drama but right now I can't wait to see how Ani wriggles out of this because the engagement party is happening as per the promo. 🤞

I am sure they are going to drag this till marriage as well so that they can have a bigger drama. But will the marriage happen is another thing. I don't think the so called "The Shrishti Mukherjee" is stupid.

oh, she is def not. If she was Urvashi would not have lived the life she had. She is very shrewd, clever and Manipulative. The only reason I feel she is being convinced by Ani is that she never penned him to be that type. I am happy that diff shades of people are coming. Like how Ani can be manipulative, Shrishti can also be a fool at times.

Originally posted by: Anusha16

True. They are husband and wife completely. These bicker like they have right on each other. Get angry. Save eo when the time comes without a care for anything else. But one thing I want Ani to take time to understand is that Jhanak may function how he wants her to by manipulating her with words. But ultimately, she is not used to this daily humiliation saga from people not her own aka., relatives and would keep this in heart. From what it looks like she only works sometimes for the Raina's. Chotton, Appu and her parents are Basus at the end even if they support her. Case in point, we have seen Anjana silence Appu whenever she tried to defend Jhanak on multiple occasions. They can only give marginal support as they are going against their own family after all. Anyone would hesitate. So she really does feel alone and doesn't have the mental capacity to tolerate their BS. Now that she is being forced to stay against her will unlike last time, it's even worse for her and she is lashing out at Ani who is the root cause in her eyes. He really shouldn't get angry/hurt because he knows what he is doing and what will be the consequences for his actions. After all, Newton's third law... for every reaction there will be an equal and opposite reaction

What has Jhanak ever done to these women except for like just having innate goodness, except for having high potential? I mean in the end, she is still a relative…so why? I just wish Jhanak can go elsewhere and have a smooth sailing career. Because Ani and her having any sort of thing in her present state is dangerous. I’m worried about her enough. Maybe they can only show feelings before she leaves. She can come back when she is powerful and then the story can start proper for them. Arshi and her gang really have it out for her.

Don’t tell me Jhanak left her check and that’s what arshi saw in precap? What?!!