Faceoff SalmanVsShantanu. FairnessVsUnfairness - Page 5

Originally posted by: Lighthearted

I dont liked his daance i think shantu overrated he is still very much behind with Salman might be he took 2/3 years more to reach that stage no bash its just my point

Originally posted by: tctctc

I am saying that Salman deserves 27-28 just bcoz his earlier performances were much better and if they got 27 then this one should have also. Coming to faceoff scores undoubtedly salman was better.

The fact is salman is a great dancer and you have to give him credit for that rather than always associating word unfair against him always. If what is actually unfair is guys trying to find out mistake in any dance he does even though the dance is great while actors whose dances actually have mistakes are ignored. Just think the number of mistakes in other people's dances also. Salman just had 1 mistake that was in landing. Why not see how many mistakes shan had in duet. The score is given on overall performance not just part of it. Also solo shan had an upper edge but salman was also good unlike duet part where salman got upper edge but shan was bad. One could easily see that.

And its high time ppl accept that salman is a good dancer that is why he deserves to win. Give him the credit he deserves. Salman deserves to win jhalak coz he is best

Originally posted by: Y12345

It's Shantanu :)

Thank you for your point of view,I truly respect that but you can't predict something that doesn't depend on you . Seriously 2/3 years to reach Salman stage? What stage? DID winner and JDJ winner as a choregrapher you mean? 😆

Or you mean 2/3 years which is 0.667 years ? Please clarify

😊

Originally posted by: ExpectoPatronus

@Y12345 dude dis is hilarious 🤣

Originally posted by: rbpll

Root of the issue is not shantanu got 26 but y salman got 29...there was nuthing like 29 in his perfomance. 🤔

Definitely duet of Salman was way better than shanatanu...being a ardent shantanu admirer I am saying it myself that I didn't like his duet perfomance. It was clumsy and lacked the attitude that was needed for these kind of dances. The initial part was only Tango rest was freestyle/hip hop. But that is all on Alisha not Shantanu and I felt that Alisha is heavy on her feet. Now coming to Salman, definitely he was good. He was performed as expected. But most of the dance was done by Ashwariya . Y?😳 Salman is the main performer here not Ashwariya. Solo is something where Shantanu nailed it. Now my point is if judges would gave points only on duet then I would be satisfied but including solo the points should contain only the difference of 1 marks. It seemed their scrore are only nbased on duet. Thety didn't include the solo.

Now for the people who are saying that shantanu should come out of his comfort zone. This season, other than shantanu, Nora n salman are the professional dancers. They are also dancing within their comfort zone then why everyone points only towards shantanu to break his mould. I feel that non-dancers are the one who are actually trying different dance style.

Originally posted by: ---Priya---

Salman was better in duet and Shantanu was better in Solo!!

But their marks hv a 3 points diff??? How in the world will this be justified??

Originally posted by: ExpectoPatronus

agreed... & shantanu too is trying diff styles. see.. 1st ws intro. dat ws freestyle. 2nd ws hiphop + bolly. 3rd ws freestyle & tap-foot, 4th ws tango & krump. so he did show diff styles. yes i wanna see him explore more. the thing is channel & judges ko salman ka mistakes dikhte nahi. 😡 shantanu did an awsm job in solo portion. totally throw salman out of d stage.