Faceoff SalmanVsShantanu. FairnessVsUnfairness

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

-.Seerat.-

@-.Seerat.-

Beginner

Posted: 8 years ago

#21

Silent Visitor, Newbie, No Judge, but felt that the judges were fair in giving Shantanu's comments and marks, but unfair when it came to Salman. He definitely didnt deserve a 10 from J and K, a 27 would have rather seemed fairer. But as far as Shantanu is considered, I dont think they were unfair with him, even though he outshined Salman in the Solo portion, his duet looked pretty messed up, and overall, even tho I like Shantanu more, Salman was better. But definitely not worth a 29!

Quote

Chitra.

@..MiStLeToE..

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 8 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: tctctc
I feel the scoring was proper bcoz shan dance with alisha was weak. You could easily see the mistakes. His solo dance was too good but the scores were on overall performance. And the judge said that shan performed well on solo and not in duet coz it was his fortay was true. He needs to explore more dance forms and show his versatileness. Since past 3 weeks he is dancing in his comfort zone. Today he actually got out and his scores showed it.
However all said i like sidhant even more than salman. Plz dont evict him. Hr is so good

Doesn't that go for Salman too? Whu does he always choose to have his forte in dance battles??? Like ALWAYS?Why? Why couldn't he do Hip-Hop?Because that would show his mistakes? He is the one to stay in his comfort limits ALWAYS!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

AntiDDT

@FraudBB

Stunner

+ 9

Posted: 8 years ago

#23

they should have give salman 28 and shantanu 27

Quote

Destiny_015

@Destiny_015

Sparkler

Posted: 8 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: tctctc
Shan last scores were 26. This week also 26. Why? The solo part is shan fortay which was already seen since past few weeks. Nothing new and no improvement since its his fortay and we all know he is so good.
Second dance form the duet one had a lot of mistakes. So this failed go impress and did not increase scores.
So shan 26 was fair.

However i felt salman should have got 27 or 28. His ayaat was much better. And sidhant should have got 29 this week. He was best today. Dont evict him

In the duet if someone was off that was Alisha. But the judges completely forget her fault and put her blame on Shantanu. She didnt even wear heels for a Tango act. Coming to Salman as Hedge himself said Salman was very stiff in the solo and it was clear Shantanu had the upperhand there. He even missed steps. Fumbled in the end. Comments were all fine by judges. But when the marks came only Shantanu's faults were kept in mind and he was scored accordingly whereas Salman's were forgotten. Both the dancers didnt give a perfect performance. And it would have made sense if they would have got equal marks. On a 1 mark. The way the face off was which was on a equal platform. A 3 mark difference tells a different story. Thats the problem here. Salman was overscored. And if we talk about variety. Salman has been doing the same since ages. And judges themselves said this was tango was Salman's forte and Shantanu went out of comfort zone.

Quote

Y12345

@Y12345

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: tctctc
Salman had problem only in 1 step that was last jump. However shan duet had a lot of mistakes. Evn wer the part he lifts Alisha, the landing was clumsy. I agree with judges. I love both shan and salman but i actually found sidhant better than all today. Shan really needs to try other dance forms coz if sticks doing hip hop, etc ie his comfort zone he will do awesome like solo but his scores will be same like last week 26. Since there is no improvement since shan is so good in hip hop that we know from day1 of jhalak. So why would judges give him more marks. If he did some new dance form n good like duet today but since it had mistakes it did not help him increase his scores.
Shan really needs to get out of comfort zone n show new and good dance forms now. Or his scores will always be 26

Nope he was stiff and I felt he lacked energy

Yes I agree but it was not that bad after all. Average perfo got like 27 so.

And why didn't they choose Hip pop ? Salman doesn't show anything new,the same latin salsa thing we'v been seeing it since decades.

Shan did 3 different styles in 3 weeks but I agree he has to explore more but judges are way too strict with him.

Edited by Y12345 - 8 years ago

Quote

Y12345

@Y12345

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: tctctc
That's what i am saying shan 26 was correct but salman should have got 27-28. Even alisha mistakes were put on shan- i agree. I want to see him perform Indian forms in future.

Yeah and this is where everything went from fair to not fair

Quote

sky_fighter

@sky_fighter

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#27

SALMAN YOUSUF KHAN FTW. The dude is just outstanding and gets better and better with each dance he does.

He really deserves to win

Quote

Ram Chai Waala.

@-Sneha6-

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

#28

I haven't watched the episode yet.

But:

Things like these go to show why D+ is such a hit, and JDJ is such a flop this season. Also, bring in more judges who know nothing about dance. Way to go Rangeela!

No one cares about dance. No one even cares about technicalities. Except perhaps Ganesh Sir in instances. Who cares about delineating differences in mistakes and correct moves and marking accordingly? For the contestant by the way, not the choreo-partner. The partner isn't supposed to be accounted for except for the choreography given to the actual contestant.

Duniya gayi tel lene. Hum humare favorite ko hi jeetayegein. Isiliye toh iss season public voting bhi band kardi. Sab ka kaam asaan. Pata nahi dikhate bhi kyun ho show. Pura season shoot karlete phir ek hi baar release karlete DVD mein.

My problem isn't that you're making a show according to your standards; with your people and your winners. It's their money, waste it however they want. My problem is them calling it a "dance" show. It's an insult to people like me who revere dance. Just call it a reality show with thoda moves and get it over with.

I'm losing interest so fast. If not for 1-2 people in there I genuinely like, I wouldn't even care. I already skip through so many parts anyway.

Quote

LiveEatLove

@LiveEatLove

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: tctctc
I feel the scoring was proper bcoz shan dance with alisha was weak. You could easily see the mistakes. His solo dance was too good but the scores were on overall performance. And the judge said that shan performed well on solo and not in duet coz it was his fortay was true. He needs to explore more dance forms and show his versatileness. Since past 3 weeks he is dancing in his comfort zone. Today he actually got out and his scores showed it.
However all said i like sidhant even more than salman. Plz dont evict him. Hr is so good

What versatility is Salman showing? Aayat kinda hot dances he has been doing since time immemorial and rest two dances were latin which is his forte. So where has he done something different?

Quote

Ananya

@ExpectoPatronus

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#30

shantanu deserved 27-28 if salman gets 29. i mean what d fughe... ???? yes i agree shan's duet portion ws not gd. but solo portion me he just nailed it. & salman's duet portion is gd & solo portions as judges said ws bad. den why marking him wid 29.??? 3 points ka diff is so unfair. 1 marks hota toh main maan leti.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

Faceoff SalmanVsShantanu. FairnessVsUnfairness - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics