Review Week 5 +mystery of scores and Immunity ball!!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

.SmokeySilence.

@.SmokeySilence.

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: princessglory
Nice post and I completely agree with faisal points dont know why judges always give him low marks if they dont want dancers then why they added him in this list dont understand and that judge Ganesh completely mad I feel he doesnt know anything about dance Remo was super gud and Scarlett is too gud She is such a fab dancer Out of all the contestants I really liked Sanaya Scarlett and faisal all others r just boring and except Karan all other judges also boring

No i dont think judges gave him low marks earlier but it was this time which was really bad. maybe they have too high expectations from him but yea i agree then why adding him. it's always the thing that there's just 1/2 trained dancer in JDj and rest all are non dancers. Remo was better and i sometimes like ganesh's comment because he points out where is the problem in the performance but sometimes i fail to understand the judging at all like yesterday

Quote

.SmokeySilence.

@.SmokeySilence.

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: mansi_sweet
hi agree with all your points
balancing wali baat sahi kaha
I am happy that vivian actually danced and he is showing improvement in dance
most importantly he danced with confidence and didn't forgot any steps
finally his fear from dancing is getting over slowly
sanaya act was entertaining
pehle mai judges ke scores ko justify karne ki koshish kar rahi thi
like faisal ko 32 diya maybe coz he was trained dancer so they are getting strict with him
mohit ko 37 maybe coz effects were good
raftaar ko 40 coz sensuous act tha though I didn't like the act at all
but after giving irfan 39 I have become convinced that judges are not capable of judging the show
he deserved 35 at most
scarlet was amazing yesterday

thank you. balancing because nobody is going to be scored at a same scale every week so its better we accept it. exactly Vivian danced with confidence, he was smiling and he didn't forget steps as well and he was;t consciously dancing. he was totally free and dancing with spirit. he has overcame his fear finally and i hope he will keep doing better and better.

don't try to justify the scores. about irfan and scarlet it's pretty obvious they scored both of them in same scale to keep both in the show.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

.SmokeySilence.

@.SmokeySilence.

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#13

@Howard scarlet, as i said its okay to give the immunity ball to someone whose performance they liked the most. why after two performances that is the question? lo logic -_-

Quote

Shreya Patel

@spate22

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: .SmokeySilence.

yes someone said that in some other thread i noticed. so it was total unfair that means not even editing. i don't understand how they can give immunity ball after two performances. doesn't make any sense.

Ganesh did say beforehand that they will give it anytime after any act who they see worthy!! 😆😆

Shreya

Quote

minal

@minal11

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#15

I know how amazing Faisal is! I have loved all his previous performances but this time actually thr was lack of co ordination between these two n thats the reason it wasn't wow this time IMO ! But I don't remember judges pointing out this thing ! Most of the time their logic to give less or more marks is beyond me 😆

Radhika's choreographer is total meh! Thr was nothing innovative! I m not at all impressed so far!

When they were about to announce who is going today i was like Irfan toh abhi abhi aaya hai n i m sure many of us felt the same! So that means we already knew Scarlet is going for an unknown reason! I m liking the way Irfan is improving! He enjoys it to fullest nd i find him really

genuine! So if u ask me i didn't wanted any of them to go!

Sanaya is my love! So obviously i will be biased while commenting about her performance 😆 but still i feel she was really good! The most important factor needed for her performance was ENERGY n she was full of energy thr! Her expressions n overall act was really entertaining but i would have loved it if she had given 38/39 ! In fact it would be awesome if they had given 40 for her last week's sexy siren wala performance! U know i m waiting for something brilliant se bhi brilliant from her side n i know that will happen just don't know what it will be! LOL

I m very much satisfied with her choreographer Jai n i m loving the fact that since last few weeks he is giving her really good steps(i know it was her rib injury when her steps were simpler in the beginning) n showing us more n more of her! She is not getting over shadowed by her him!

I loved Vivian's "besharam" part more! His foot work,his dance was really good thr!

Immunity ball should have given to Raftar IMO ! I really liked his performance!his act was real sensuous.I have always loved Sneha.She always tries to bring out dancer in her partner n doesn't concentrate on her own unlike most of other girls choreographer😆! She really works hard on her partner!

Without watching other performances i really want to know on which basis judges has given that ball to Shamita 😆

Quote

Midnight

@Midnightsorrow

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

#16

Not sure about Sanaya scores at all but if you look at it this way Kangana isn't someone who's known for her dancing but her acting and judges picked these actors for the contestants. I wish Sanaya had done someone like Ash or even Deepika would have been good. So adding acting to her performance was a good idea especially if you're playing tribute to a non dancer.

I am surprised no one get to do Madhuri or Sridevi who are fabulous dancers but got regular stars instead because I believe its too early to call the current lot of actors today 'Superstars'

This is the only performance of Mohit I didnt like so far, I find him clumsy in some parts. I love that song he choose and was using SRK forte.

Vivian danced for once even Shahid mentioned it, I love the pyar hua hai part didn't like The second besharaam song at all.

Colors didn't want to get rid of Irfan so they overscored him? Especially if he's up against someone like Scarlett of course she would do better than him. She was much better than him as a matter of fact the best performance of this week, she also deserved a 40 Irfan messed up in parts he wasn't even doing his moves right. I would give him not more than a 35 consider he's a non dancer.

Radhika performances are going down... She perform to a fast beat song but her act bored me and her energy is weak.

Shamita was fabulous but I think the Immunity ball was given out too early. Should have waited for a few more weeks atleast.

Faisal didn't give a 40 act like last week but 32? He deserved 35/36 atleast.

Quote

Ekta

@HaymurS

Achiever

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#17

exactly i was like omg is vd actually dancing??😆

i m glad he moved finally🤣

so m fine with it...ahhaha

scarlet dance was osm...they did overscored irfan though

didnt watched sat epi so no idea about those performances...:)

Quote

CherHorowitz

@TotalBetty

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#18

TM - Like you said Shamita was graceful, her footwork great and moves smooth

I think she has the best legs in the show( haven't checked Kavita and Dipika's legs 😆) not the other girl GH was complimenting, although she is very pretty

Shamita is tall and slim so that helps

Subreet didn't complain or whine on stage or off stage did she? Others could learn a lesson from her

GH was complaining about Indian viewers, he said 'Why aren't you voting more for Subreet?'

If they think so highly of her dancing abilities then why don't they give her the immunity ball?

Quote

Midnight

@Midnightsorrow

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 9 years ago

#19

^^ I agree I didn't like the way Ganesh said "please vote for her" and give her a 10 out of sympathy because he fell bad for her. I salute her guts, she's an inspiration... but forcing viewers to vote for her that is where he went wrong. He can't buy anyone votes, you have to earn it, people will vote if they like her performance not because they fell bad for her.

Quote

CherHorowitz

@TotalBetty

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#20

^^^

Maybe GH meant to say, she is a great dancer, she deserves more votes but it didn't come out well!

Anyway I am planning to vote for her too this weekend if she remains on the show, not cz of what GH said, cz she said 'Please I need more votes to continue on the show' and also I like her spirit 😊

Quote

1 2 3

Review Week 5 +mystery of scores and Immunity ball!! - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics