who should NOT be a judge of JDJ ?

Poll

who should NOT be a judge of JDJ ?

Login To Vote

Tanya

@tanya.91

Sparkler

30

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#1

Please strictly vote (& comment) solely on the bases of their quality, understanding and level of fair judgement of dancers and giving them the scores they truly deserve... not as per your personal choices or favorite personalities as judges.
Thanks.
😊

Reply

Quote

Arnav90

@Arnav90

Stunner

35

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#2

JDJ Forum Dance Experts 🤣 Who likes to judge free of cost 🤣

Edited by Arnav90 - 12 years ago

9

Reply

Quote

sqrly

@sqrly

Dazzler

20

Posted: 12 years ago

#3

honestly I like all of them. A bad judging pannel was what Nach Baliye had (Terrence being the exception though). I mean no one on JDJ is mean and they are encouraging to all the contestants. If you want to see a bad judge watch Sajid on Nach - dude was so mean ppl would start crying. And half the times his comments made no sense and he would keep going on about "entertainment, entertainment, entertainment". When Farrah came on the show it was a breath of fresh air.

12

Reply

Quote

MsFoodyTwoShoes

@MsFoodyTwoShoes

Sparkler

32

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#4

Originally posted by: sqrly
honestly I like all of them. A bad judging pannel was what Nach Baliye had (Terrence being the exception though). I mean no one on JDJ is mean and they are encouraging to all the contestants. If you want to see a bad judge watch Sajid on Nach - dude was so mean ppl would start crying. And half the times his comments made no sense and he would keep going on about "entertainment, entertainment, entertainment". When Farrah came on the show it was a breath of fresh air.

Terrence was no less...he always used to lift 11 ka score card for rahul's mediocre performances 😆

Reply

Quote

Tanya

@tanya.91

Sparkler

30

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#5

imho, the only one who don't deserve to be a dancing judge is Karan Johar... not bcoz he is mean, unfair or negative (he is a very nice person) but honestly he don't know much about the technicalities & delicacies of the art of dancing the way a judge should know.
Apart from KjO, Remo & Madhuri Dixit are "PERFECT" as JDJ judges (as Madhuri Ji says in her poetic voice ...perfect 😊 )

Reply

Quote

drashtimeetu

@drashtimeetu

Voyager

19

Posted: 12 years ago

#6

according to me best judge is KARAN johar...

he is always on the face

if he likes then he will tell

otherwise he straightly says that he dont like the performance...

Madhuri trying to become extra sweet...

No comments about REMO

Edited by drashtimeetu - 12 years ago

5

Reply

Quote

Tanya

@tanya.91

Sparkler

30

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#7

Originally posted by: drashtimeetu
according to me best judge is KARAN johar...
he is always on the face
if he likes then he will tell
otherwise he strictly sayd that he dont like the performance...
Madhuri trying to become extra sweet...
No comments about REMO

for me judging is NOT ABOUT PERSONAL LIKING or PERSONAL DISLIKING and saying this on face of contestants...
its about TRULY KNOWING the ART OF DANCING and FAIRLY judging the contestants on these bases

+ plus I am not saying this as Madhuri's fan, but I've seen alot of bashing of Madhuri just bcoz of her good nature... she is like that , not trying to be extra sweet... if u notice, how much she becomes nice, but she always gives MARKS according to the PERFORMANCE and keeping tehcnicalities in mind, she just don't wanna be a mean know it all strict teacher... despite being considered the undisputed dancing queen of South Asia 👍🏼

Reply

Quote

SnowGirl18

@SnowGirl18

Voyager

16

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#8

IMO all of them, would like to see a new set of judges in the next season, fair and unbiased, though i like Madhuri!!

1

Reply

Quote

IFrozenl

@IFrozenl

Inactive

26

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#9

Well for me it's Karan Johar.
He's a nice person, but being a judge of a Dance reality show...i would say ..No.

1

Reply

Quote

Mahi78

@Mahi78

Rocker

27

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: sqrly
honestly I like all of them. A bad judging pannel was what Nach Baliye had (Terrence being the exception though). I mean no one on JDJ is mean and they are encouraging to all the contestants. If you want to see a bad judge watch Sajid on Nach - dude was so mean ppl would start crying. And half the times his comments made no sense and he would keep going on about "entertainment, entertainment, entertainment". When Farrah came on the show it was a breath of fresh air.

I never watched NB live when it was telecasted but I saw all the episodes quite recently envelope there then judges where biased, every time 11 for some particular contestants and even 7 for some who deserved more. And every one flirting with Shilpa which ppl criticise MD for in this foroum. Remo is in some ways better in judging and KJo is many times better then Sajid who sometimes becomes 😡.

Edited by Mahi78 - 12 years ago

1

Reply

Quote

who should NOT be a judge of JDJ ?

Poll

Related Topics

Explore Topics