Is it fair? - Page 16

i heard this quetion beofre and somehow i agree with you

Originally posted by: tehzeeb25

This question comes every season ... N in reality shows it's better to not ask about fair not fair n all cuz all undeserving win here... plus shakti already won DID so doubt she will win this one ... TThis is just a reality show watch enjoy n forget ...

i ree but i disgree too. In the past 2 seasons the undeserving are winning especially in season 5..the winner was NOT deserving as other participants. In season 6 we knew from the first episode that DD will win becuase of her fan following which she is not to blame for. But this season the competiton for fan following is really toight. Whether it is kritika karan ashish or shakti they have huge fan following so we dont who is gonna win anything can happen

I opened up a genuine thread and I would appreciate it if we could stick to the topic rather than side tracking. We've had a good 20 page discussion and I wouldn't want to thread to close. So please stick to the topic and continue on with a healthy conversation. I have enjoyed reading most of the replies even though they differ from mine.

Originally posted by: Cutiepie Rani

Guys it's not about being a trained dancer. It's about already winning a title and participating again. She ha the exposure, experience, etc ... isn't that a disadvantage to the rest?

But how is her winning the title in DID going to help her in JDJ? The only things that actually count towards anything are your dance performance (which is helped by training, which Lauren had and Isha had, but you just said that that's not what you're talking about), and your popularity as a celeb. As far as experience goes, most of these celebs have participated in other dance reality shows. Mouni was in Zara Nachke Dikha and won. Exposure? What will that give her? An fandom? They all have a fandom! Does it give her confidence? Well, if you go by any of the interviews, the non-trained, no-experience wale contestants seem to have more confidence.

I understand that you want a healthy discussion. It's just that I don't think there is much to discuss and it's being dragged out. Four or five people end up saying the same exact thing.

Originally posted by: AishuHiBawari

But how is her winning the title in DID going to help her in JDJ? The only things that actually count towards anything are your dance performance (which is helped by training, which Lauren had and Isha had, but you just said that that's not what you're talking about), and your popularity as a celeb. As far as experience goes, most of these celebs have participated in other dance reality shows. Mouni was in Zara Nachke Dikha and won. Exposure? What will that give her? An fandom? They all have a fandom! Does it give her confidence? Well, if you go by any of the interviews, the non-trained, no-experience wale contestants seem to have more confidence.

Originally posted by: Cutiepie Rani

Honestly I don't know about any other winners because I only watched DID. I don't understand if they have already won a title why do they need to participate in another dancing show? Of course if they were approached by colors, no one would refuse the offer. But it just becomes unfair to the non-dancers. I really think they need to change the format of the show and bring in non-dancer celebs who have had little to no training or if they have training they haven't been a winner on a reality show before. Being on another show does give you exposure and does give you an advantage even though it may just be a slight advantage.

Why would they need to refuse the offer though? Do you see Usain Bolt being all, "Naaah, man. I won an Olympic Medal. I don't need to run another race." No, he's passionate about what he does and he wants to run. Just like Shakti said that she's only here to dance.

That being said, I just pointed out a few places where Shakti needed work, just like everyone else ie classical, jitterbug, lambada, etc. Yes, there are less trained dancers, but so what? Every year, Jhalak puts out contestants who have different backgrounds in dance. Some have none. It's all about getting better at it. I honestly don't see how the exposure from being in another show factors in to Jhalak. They all have experience in front of the camera, most of them from other dance shows, and they're all pretty confident.

jhalak/dancing with the stars have always been considered as a platform for non dancers..

I really like Shakti from Dil Dostii Dance days, but I agree with you here. Bringing her like a choreographer made more sense than a contestant. She is so well trained and a very professional dancer, which is kinda unfair for the other contestants. But I don't think she will win..she will be like Lauren of this season. Scripted show.

Originally posted by: HawaaPot

I really like Shakti from Dil Dostii Dance days, but I agree with you here. Bringing her like a choreographer made more sense than a contestant. She is so well trained and a very professional dancer, which is kinda unfair for the other contestants. But I don't think she will win..she will be like Lauren of this season. Scripted show.

Mummy!!!!! i just visited the forum see that people are going gaga over shakti being contestant and so on