shiamak voices out before grand finale! - Page 2

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

I don't know why people bring other things like which serial one worked or movie they did. Just watch them on dance floor and judge them for their performances and personalities on JDJ.

I dont think Bani-Prachi is any more popular than Sandhya who also has worked serials and movies. so all that even outs. Anyways who cares about that?

Who ever dances well, has great stage presence and positive personality will win with public.

Shamiyak should not be giving out his personal opinion abt a specific contestant. he has job to be fair. he can say a general statement to vote for best dancer but should not be rooting for a specific candidate b/c his fans will vote for the contestant who he is supporting and the other two contestant will lose out IMHO. That is the point Mr. Negi was trying to make.

Woow !!!
I agree with you !!
Sandhya is not less popular than Prachi !!!

Sandhya is in films and Prachi in serials !!!
I done get why some people are using Prachi's 'bani image' as an excuse to why she is getting loads of votes !!!
If she is getting loads of votes is because she is a great dancer and has imporved alot same goes with Jay !!!
Both are great !!!!

Anywayz, good luck to all of the 3 finalists !!! 😃

Angelrockz 😳

I think Shaimak shouldn't show favouritsm so obviously - I fully agree that he wants talent to win, but there is no need to name names. This is one thing that I haven't liked about JDJ at all - teh blatant favouritsm by the judges. It happened in season 1 - when all teh judges rooted for Shveta, and teh same is happening this year with Sandhya.

I am not saying that Sandhya is not talented she is,, but the judges behaviour - especially Shaimak's is really off putting. Being a judge you have to be partial to everyone's performances - even if you personally know the person. Everyone says that Jeetu ji sides Prachi - he might, but he has always given her fair marks, never has he given her better than what she deserves. As a top choreographer Shaimak needs to give constructive crticism about what would have made teh performance better, or them a better dancer. he doesn't do that - all he says is I liked it or I didn't like it. Urmilla does a better job of judging the contestants than Shaimak does, as she always remains partial to everyone.

It fine to say to the Janta that the talented should win, but naming names is wrong as a judge, because it shows blatent impartiality. He can say please vote for the person who has gotten the most marks, because they have gotten them for a reason. I really dislike Shaimak as a judge because he doesn'y do a good job of it.