Divided we stand - article - Page 5

Originally posted by: lunza

Meena , Sudha refused to be part of the show through wildcard (in her own words). Prachi too had a choice ; she could have refused , right ?
Probably thats the reason why everyone is cold shouldering her ? Because she chose to agree to be a wildcard entry , in fact the only wildcard entry ...

The contestants have a right to feel shortchanged because if later sandhya , sonali etc are going to get eliminated later , they are not going to get a second chance right ???

However I would have expected the contestants to take up the matter with the jdj producers instead of .. uh ... forming camps
😕 How silly is that ... reminds me of school days ... and all the school politics ... 😆 😆

See lunza, I know she had a choice. But see she is still young and everyone just want to win the competiton and if she is giving second chance, she just accepted it. Sudhaji is much more experience, have been through a lot in her life, had experienced a lot and she knew how the world works and she made her decision. But Prachi is still young and facing the world now. So far, she has been accepted by all, be it KS or even JDJ. So probably she would have felt that it is okay for her to come back. Also, it was an unfair elimination for her and very shocking. It is like "i have been eliminated unfairly and I am getting a chance, so why not use it". Wont you feel the same.

Probably next time, Prachi will reject such offers now that she has learnt her lesson.

Also, does Sony really gives a choice? When Sudhaji has rejected to participate in Wildcard, Sony still went ahead and asked people to support Sudhaji.

Cant you see, it is all planned by Sony to have their TRPs up and Prachi was made the scapegoat in this whole process and she is just not realising that.

Originally posted by: zerobstolerence

Lunza, does SONY know that Sudhaji refused to be part of the show through wildcard because they were clearly asking the public to choose? Even one of the judges Shaimak gave an opinion that he wanted Sudhaji back because she was "good." I'm reading alot of talk about Sudha saying no, if that is the case, why has SONY been promoting her and asking public to vote for her? However, I'm really baffled and confused about this supposed little fact.

How can they not know know that ???😆 Sudha has gone on record saying that ..... Probably thats another reason for the contestants anger ? Maybe they feel the whole voting thing between sudha and prachi is just a ruse/cover-up/farce to get her back ?

Originally posted by: lunza

How can they not know know that ???😆 Sudha has gone on record saying that ..... Probably thats another reason for the contestants anger ? Maybe they feel the whole voting thing between sudha and prachi is just a ruse/cover-up/farce to get her back ?

If Sudhaji has gone on record of saying she doens't want to come back and YET SONY took the opportunity to portray to the public that she's in the running, what does that tell you? Quite frankly I think her entire so called elimination was a ruse to begin with. I find it extremely hard to believe that she was suddenly voted out when she has been one of the top 2 in terms of public voting and her marks surely weren't the lowest in comparison to say Sonali. This entire thing reeks of a set up and Prachi is being used as a scapegoat. And that in and of itself is highly unfair.

Originally posted by: lunza

How can they not know know that ???😆 Sudha has gone on record saying that ..... Probably thats another reason for the contestants anger ? Maybe they feel the whole voting thing between sudha and prachi is just a ruse/cover-up/farce to get her back ?

Even if that is the reason for their anger, why show it on Prachi. That is what we are all saying. It is unfair to show their anger on Prachi?

I can understand their sentiments also. Probably I would feel the same if all these happened to me, but that does not justify their behaviour and blame game towards Prachi.

Well, this really happens everywhere but what is really disheartening is the two faces of the participants.

Originally posted by: zerobstolerence

Quite frankly I think her entire so called elimination was a ruse to begin with. I find it extremely hard to believe that she was suddenly voted out when she has been one of the top 2 in terms of public voting and her marks surely weren't the lowest in comparison to say Sonali. This entire thing reeks of a set up and Prachi is being used as a scapegoat. And that in and of itself is highly unfair.

I totally agree with you Zero.

I wont believe that Prachi was out. She has constantly been getting high votes. She also was getting high scores from the Judges.

Sonali who was constantly in danger zone was safe that day. Prachi was out. Even if people did not vote due to Diwali, it would have affect all the participants not only Prachi.

Sony really played a very bad trick and Prachi is the scapegoat in the whole process.

Originally posted by: lunza

How can they not know know that ???😆 Sudha has gone on record saying that ..... Probably thats another reason for the contestants anger ? Maybe they feel the whole voting thing between sudha and prachi is just a ruse/cover-up/farce to get her back ?

I don't think the comment that Sudha made during an interview before the WC became a reality, should be taken as her official stand. The point she made that comment WC was just a speculation. Sony is not that stupid to spend lakhs on a campaign for Sudha and Prachi if she was not agreeable. Sudha could have sued Sony for falsely promoting her on national television that she is coming back if she gets the vote. People like Shamak and Shivaji Satyam asking the audience to vote for her for the WC cannot be a whole coverup process.

I agree to this that it wasnot a all fair play if wild card was introduced voting should have been open for the all the contestants but i dont think there is an anti-prachi camp. Sonali was very angry as she is inconfident herself other than her i dont think any1 was that insecure

Originally posted by: Je_aime

See lunza, I know she had a choice. But see she is still young and everyone just want to win the competiton and if she is giving second chance, she just accepted it. Sudhaji is much more experience, have been through a lot in her life, had experienced a lot and she knew how the world works and she made her decision. But Prachi is still young and facing the world now. So far, she has been accepted by all, be it KS or even JDJ. So probably she would have felt that it is okay for her to come back. Also, it was an unfair elimination for her and very shocking. It is like "i have been eliminated unfairly and I am getting a chance, so why not use it". Wont you feel the same.

Probably next time, Prachi will reject such offers now that she has learnt her lesson.

Also, does Sony really gives a choice? When Sudhaji has rejected to participate in Wildcard, Sony still went ahead and asked people to support Sudhaji.

Cant you see, it is all planned by Sony to have their TRPs up and Prachi was made the scapegoat in this whole process and she is just not realising that.

Honestly I dont buy the "She is young " argument ... She is 19 and comes across as quite mature through her interviews ...
Reality shows are never fair as far as voting is concerned .... the most deserving person never wins ... But it is the format of the game ... and Prachi must have known that it is based on voting and can easily overturn the judges scores ....
It must have come as a rude shock for her when she was eliminated ... she has a huge fan base and also gets good scores ...
How can we be sure that the voting was rigged to oust Prachi ... heck that doesnt even make sense .... she was one of the most popular contestants on the show and a lot of people watched JDJ only for her ....
So just to prove that BT proteges are not being favoured by the channel , prachi was shown the door ????
I would think sony was sucking up to BT 😆 ... first with jitendra on the judges panel , next with four BT actors ... I dont know about BBC but I feel BT can definitely influence Sony ... none of their daily serials are clicking and they are banking on Ekta to change their fortunes ... they have some 4/5 BT serials lined up for the channel in the coming months

Originally posted by: lunza

Honestly I dont buy the "She is young " argument ... She is 19 and comes across as quite mature through her interviews ...
Reality shows are never fair as far as voting is concerned .... the most deserving person never wins ... But it is the format of the game ... and Prachi must have known that it is based on voting and can easily overturn the judges scores ....
It must have come as a rude shock for her when she was eliminated ... she has a huge fan base and also gets good scores ...
How can we be sure that the voting was rigged to oust Prachi ... heck that doesnt even make sense .... she was one of the most popular contestants on the show and a lot of people watched JDJ only for her ....
So just to prove that BT proteges are not being favoured by the channel , prachi was shown the door ????
I would think sony was sucking up to BT 😆 ... first with jitendra on the judges panel , next with four BT actors ... I dont know about BBC but I feel BT can definitely influence Sony ... none of their daily serials are clicking and they are banking on Ekta to change their fortunes ... they have some 4/5 BT serials lined up for the channel in the coming months

Precisely why I think she accepted the offer. She had a huge fan base and their is no way that she was out. Just like other felt it was unfair, she could have felt that same and when given a chance she uses it.

Btw, maturity and experiencing something bad and learning from it can be two different things.

Honestly Meena,
even i think that it is all a set up from the time when Mika was constantly saved even when the marks were wrong...
and then the elimination of Prachi or even sudha-ji smelled something reeking and i have suspicion that just like Zee gained TRPs for some of its show by showing the wrong stuff Sony is following their lead...
what say on that?
i think Prachi was safe that day but somehow the channel played a role and had her kicked out for the TRPs so yes prachi seems to be a scapegoat..
rooj