on the topic of bad judge... - Page 2

Originally posted by: ReemAnshu

With regards to your comments on judges, well just to correct you, Himesh Reshammiya was never a Judge. He was the 'Mentor' of his gharana and so has all the rights for supporting her in every which way he feels. As you know the format, the mentor was never allowed to give marks to his own Gharana student. Each mentor was also asked to train their singer, at times they asked votes for them and they also Sang with them.

Coming to this show, I certainly agree that the judges were good (thats what I thought initially), I think Juhi & Vaibhavi were very good. However I have some harsh comments for Saroj Khan, she should be BANNED FROM JUDGING DANCE REALITY SHOWS. She is very rude, prejudiced and does not have knowledge of western dancing. I wonder why they did not go with Shiamak again this season (Terrence would also do but he is on rival show) as he has such great knowledge and is such a well behaved man.

There is a vast difference being a Great choreographer and a Good judge. I have seen her in other shows also like Nach Baliye & Zara Nach Ke Dikha, she was very insulting to Bakhtiyar and took out her personal grudges against him by degrading him.

Saroj is very good in Indian dances and Sensuous numbers but not in western numbers. The only western no of repute which I can remember is Tamma Tamma (which again was copied), all her numbers have been Indian. It is a joke when she comments on dance forms like 'SAMBHA' & 'Sulsa'. But the WORST aspect in her is that she is VERY RUDE & Biased in her judging.

Anyways, 2 out 3 being good judges is still great as compared to last season when they had Jitendra & Urmila and in other shows where they have had David Dhawan & Arjun Rampal to judge dance shows !!

PS - I am not a Karan fan, I am a HK fan. Infact I hate Karan and also BB. Please take my comments in the right sense and Saroj Khan fans please dont mind.

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

Saroj ji, Vaibhabi nor Juhi are bad judges in my opinion. You want to know who are bad judges? And I do not mean any ( any any any offense) Feel free to refute my points, I dislike empty talks.

Bad judges I have seen on TV

Himesh Reshamiya -- My god!! what a character. He just wanted to scream. On last srgmp given Vaishali was a talented singer he felt it was necessary to show off her good character. And got outraged when Adesh said she is talented, let them vote on her talent, why bring up her personality talk. I didn't see Adesh flaunt what a good son Soumen was. He was also very biased.

Abhijeet-- wow! I can't believe zee is bringing him back again. He babied Sanchita. He was clearly biased in ESBE. Even when she did something normal he would sing praises. He was also rude to Rajishree and Amit. Saroj, Juhi and Vaibhabi answered the hosts honestly when they were asked if Karan deserved to be in the finals. What would you want them to do lie? At least I don't I am sorry. I believe one should go by merit and he shouldn't come to the competition to hear false praises. On the other hand Abhijeet pointed at rajishree saying she should be out. Then not wanting to judge Musharraf because he doesn't want paki singers in India was highly unprofessional

Ahmed-- gave Amit Paul a 1!! a 1??? Indian idol runner up who almost became the winner really deserved a one?? even if I sang I believe I would get more than a one. (I suck) Because he felt his points really didn't matter. At least saroj ji and Vaibhabi didn't do that..

I do ask..when such people exsist how can JDJ3 have the worst judges as people claim.

I do think Juhi was stingy with her marks. But what is wrong with that? It is her opinion. She was brought in to look at the overall performance. Now if the whole performance doesn't look nice to her, she has every right to give the contestant low marks. I always found her honest. She was very polite, and because of that she said lots of nice thing a lot of times. You could tell when she loved a performance, she would give a bouqet of marks.

I don't think it was necessary for the judges to be rude, but I do think they have the right to go ona strike or seriously disagree if they feel something was wrong. I have said this before and I say it again. It is not because their favorite went out. It's because the A+ student had to leave while F student was still there.

At the end they urged people to vote for gauhar not as like hello don't vote for anyone but Gauhar. It was like "this girl has talent, it's time you vote on merit". It was a plea to do the right thing.

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

I do think Juhi was stingy with her marks. But what is wrong with that? It is her opinion. She was brought in to look at the overall performance. Now if the whole performance doesn't look nice to her, she has every right to give the contestant low marks. I always found her honest. She was very polite, and because of that she said lots of nice thing a lot of times. You could tell when she loved a performance, she would give a bouqet of marks.